M.D. vs. D.N.P.

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm sure that when you add up all the degrees, a 4 year undergrad, plus 2-3 years masters, then 2-3 years doctoral program you get more than that. I'm sorry you needed to take calculus in order to get simple elementary math.

You said –
LOL!!! You do know that you need to be a baccalaureate prepared registered nurse and a Board Certified Advanced Practice Nurse Practitioner before enrolling in a DNP program? Do you know it takes 8-9 years (6-7 of which are from an undergrad/master's degree IN NURSING) and thousands of hours of clinical before you get a DNP?

I provided examples of people I personally know who went from BSN straight into DNP programs without ever working as a RN. 4 years of undergrad + 2 years in a DNP program (yes 2 year DNP programs do exist) = 6 years total. In the case of the person who went AA in nursing (2 years) --> BSN (just under 1 year)--> DNP (2 years) = 5 years. That doesn’t add up to 6-7 just to get into a DNP program or 8-9 to graduate from one.

Don't forget that RN's work their way up the ladder, whereas PA's can get a bachelor degree in English/Bio/Chem/BasketWeaving/HealthStudies/etc and throw in some patient contact hours in order to get into a two year Masters Degree program. And on top of that complain that they do "4 years of med school in 2 years". Complete BS! Nurse practitioners come out of school with vast amounts of knowledge and hit the floor running. PA's on the other hand need to be taken under the wing of a physician and be told what to do.

The only clinical experiences people going straight from undergrad into a DNP program will have are RN/BSN clinicals and whatever clinicals are arranged for the DNP program. That doesn’t really seem to entail “ladder climbing”, nor does it seem like enough clinical experience and knowledge to “hit the floor running” compared to PAs. Also, pretty much every nurse I've talked to has said that nursing clinicals do very little to prepare them and that most of their clinical learning occurs once they start actually working as an RN.

As far as a DNP not having any pre-requisite you're absolutely wrong... so please educate yourself on the topic. You must be an Advanced Practice Nurse or enroll in a BS-DNP (meaning they acquire an MS in an advanced practice role while in the program and graduate with two degrees) or MS -DNP. Don't tell me I don't know my own profession. You don't see me rambling off about what physicians can and cannot do.

Some programs may have extra requirements (e.g., Stony Brook like you mentioned), but many don’t – hence the issue with inconsistent standards, education, and training.

http://www.umary.edu/academics/programs/doctorate-family-nurse-practitioner.php

https://www.ndsu.edu/nursing/bsn_to_dnp/admission_requirements/

People that graduate from programs like the ones above will have the exact same privileges as someone from a program with more stringent admission requirements, so long as they pass the licensing exam.

Oh, and good for your wife! That's a great way to advance the professionalization of nursing, not! Go become a PA, it'll be like a slap in the face to the nursing profession.

That’s part of her reasoning behind choosing the PA route should she decide to go back to school.

Although our profession has it's issues so do the medical doctors and many others. For example, we must do "Time Out's" and fill out a checklist before we let a physician do any type of procedure or surgery on a patient...

Not really sure what your point is here, “time-outs” aren't just a nursing thing and often involve physicians.

Regarding the certifications you keep mentioning, as others have pointed out those are a joke and pretty meaningless beyond being able to throw some additional letters after your name. My wife has taken the "certification" exams for psych and med-surg only because her employer at the time covered the costs and she got a slight pay increase for doing so. She took both exams cold without studying and passed the first time.

Edit - You also liked a post of someone agreeing with what I said regarding how long it takes to earn a DNP and issues regarding nursing education. Not sure if that point belongs under the troll category or reading comprehension deficits category.
 
Last edited:
It won't be that long before NP start demanding 'equal pay for equal work' because they are board certified just like physicians. The CRNA militants are already demanding that.
That would just bite them in the @ss though. A hospital would just hire a doctor if it will cost the same as a NP. Why pay someone with the partial knowledge and training of a MD, a MD salary when you can just hire a full MD with that money?
 
@Ho0v-man

What?! Are you really putting all Nurse Practitioners in one category, based on what seems like your little experience and bizarre interactions from within your state? What state are you in? I've never heard anything of the sort.


First of all, BSN nurses need at least one year of nursing experience in the field of study they choose to pursue (i.e. Pediatrics, Critical Care, ER/Trauma, Medical/Surgical, Anesthesia, Psych, Mother/Baby, Neonatal, etc…). It’s not solely based on critical care experience, although that would be nice, it just makes no sense.


If you get below a B+ in any subject in my NP program (in New York) you’ll get kicked out. The ANCC and AANP board certification accredited agencies DO NOT allow any paper work or open book nonsense that you’ve described above.


Associate degree RN’s, who are working towards their BSN have taken most of their clinical rotations and classes already including, chem 101, bio 101, English 101, psych 101, soc 101, physiological chem, anatomy and phys 1 and 2, microbiology, pathophysiology, pharmacology, and etc. But like YOUR undergrad bachelor degree, and ALL other undergrad degrees (thanks to our ancient Greek friends) we must take liberal arts classes; like history, math, music/art, gym, and more philosophical nursing courses in leadership, health promotion and patient education, community health, research, and so on. I’m not going to lie, some of it was complete BS, but interesting in itself.


The fact that you talk down about a fellow health care profession is quite honestly deplorable. Nursing’s scope of practice is very different than that of medicine; actually, it’s completely different and not comparable. The BSN focuses more on leadership, management, research, and education. Licensed registered nurses already know, or should know, what lab values, medication treatment, and technical skills required to do their job.


Nurses do not truly learn medicine until their Masters education begins. But kudos to those nurses who had to work part time/full time while in school, who probably had to ensure their priorities were in order, like for example, raising a family, a mortgage to worry about paying, or even if they wanted to simply pay out of pocket for their schooling. I’m proud of them and their ambitious endeavor to better themselves while also helping to facilitate the movement towards professionalization in nursing!


Then after at least one year of experience, (almost no one gets accepted into the program with only ONE year of experience) you get to graduate school. There you’ll have to submit three letters of recommendation from nurse leaders, physicians, or other nurse practitioners. You’ll also need to write a five-page paper that includes all of the following below;


“The mission of the School of Nursing is to provide accessible, high quality undergraduate and graduate education to diverse student populations for the development of nurse leaders at all entries of practice. The mission will be accomplished through:

• Innovative programs that reflect the needs and current trends in healthcare of neighboring communities and the wider geographic regions;

• Provision of state-of-the-art healthcare and serve as a resource to the surrounding and global communities;

• Research that advances the scientific and theoretical foundations of nursing.


The essay question or personal response, needs to address the following topics:

• Discuss the personal qualities and attributes that you think will be useful as well as those that you feel need further development in preparation for the nursing profession.

• Provide your own definition of cultural competence, ethical sensitivity, leadership and life-long learning as well as how you may incorporate these concepts in your professional practice.

• Discuss how a graduate education in nursing will impact your future career goals.”


Then go through an extensive interview process because Stony Brook University is one of the top ranking universities in the world and they only accept the best of the best. The university gets around 34,110 applications a year and only 13,981 were accepted.

Here’s the link if you don’t believe me, http://www.stonybrook.edu/sb/fastfacts/



We’re also recommended to continue working as RN’s, so that we keep learning and growing as a profession. So we can take a part time or full time route but the program must be completed within 5 years. Just look up the NP programs at Stony Brook and what they require... You most definitely cannot compare our program to med school and residency but it’s not easy. Then after taking 46-56 credits and graduating we can sit for our national board certification and hopefully pass the first time.


After we pass our exam we can either work for a few years or go back for our doctoral degrees; write another big essay, and more interviewing, along with 42 more credits of doctoral work, clinical hours, and handing in an evidence based clinical project and which requires tireless hours of research, which will take about another 3-5 years to complete. But I think you get the point… I’m done writing everything out. But please do look up the requirements for the NP -DNP/PhD program at Stony Brook University as it’s quite intense, but again, not as intense as medical school, I’ll give you that!


All I know is that nurses need doctors like doctors need nurses, whether in the advanced practice role or as a floor nurse. Our education goes way beyond what you falsely describe in your failed attempt to belittle nurse practitioners. There is evidence based studies and journals out there that show positive patient outcomes based on the role of a nurse practitioner and that they can provide just as effective care as a physician.


I would never slander a medical doctor, even if they were horrible and made the profession look bad. You shouldn’t let your opinions of the select few incidences you've "heard of" or encountered define the profession as a whole. If nurse practitioner's weren't doing so well then I'm sure our malpractice insurance would be higher than $1500-$1700/year and the IOM would have nurse practitioners discontinued and relieved of their duties to practice medicine. After all it was MD's who initiated the start of the NP program in the 1960’s due to the great health care disparities among our nation that we’re seeing again now.


All in all I do agree that NP programs should require more clinical hours and most definitely a residency type program, but NP's, well most of them, are not idiots. I know many NP's who are well respected by physicians and other medical professions.


I've personally worked with some of the most fragile and sickest patients in New York. My five years of experience in ER/Trauma, ICU/CCU/PICU, Cardiac/Stroke and Hospice specialties have really prepared me to move up in the nursing profession. I also think the education that is afforded to us is what we make of it. I plan on reading vast amounts of medical journals and studying along side other NP’s, PA’s, medical students, and physicians who I call my friends and colleagues.

I'm citing the most rigorous NP program in my state.

That nursing experience is easily accumulated during and ADN-->BSN online bridge.

I know NPs who've gotten Ds in the fluff courses and still graduated just fine. How hard is it to get less than a B+ in an online unproctored course? Are you losing points for not citing the bogus research papers or something? It does say that collaboration with peers and using notes, etc is not allowed, but it's all online and not enforced.

The next paragraph was about how ADNs have to take classes to get a bachelors degree. Well...yeah. Also, with the exception of chem101, those can all be taken online.

While good nurses know what different labs mean, most just know if something is out of the reference range (because it says so in the corner) and that they might need to ask someone a question. I've seen a resident lose his mind when he got woken up in the middle of the night by a BSN with >5 years experience because a patients BUN was too low and she wanted to know if she could give him some.

I've seen plenty get accepted with less than one year of experience. Between your alma mater and the fact that >50% of administration at a hospital is probably nursing, you'd have to be pretty awful to not get those LOR. Also, letters and essay/papers are a common part of applying to any graduate program in any field so I don't see why you think having to do what everyone else does makes you special.

Oh you're encouraged to work while in school? Because any other path to having a prescription pad is too rigorous to involve a job on the side. And that goes for former nurses who go to PA school.

NPs have low malpractice because they take on less responsibility, and everything can fall on the doc if they mess up. The cases they handle independently are things most experienced nurses could handle without the NP education all together.

Congrats on going to such a prestigious NP program. You know it's tough because they only accept 40% of the people who apply.

My favorite "mid level provider" is actually an NP. But she had decades of critical care experience prior to going back to school. Whereas one year of experience is a joke. Most good nurses will tell you the first 3-4 years of nursing taught them more than nursing school ever did. But NPs get a pass on an academically rigorous education because of nursing school? I call BS. I'm friends with plenty of RNs who went NP. I've seen the coursework, and it's just garbage. They've even told me themselves that most of the classes are just applied English classes.

Even if you go to a "top-tier" NP program, it pales in comparison to ANY PA program.

Enjoy your kool-aid.
 
@Walter Lance

I'm sure that when you add up all the degrees, a 4 year undergrad, plus 2-3 years masters, then 2-3 years doctoral program you get more than that. I'm sorry you needed to take calculus in order to get simple elementary math.


As far as a DNP not having any pre-requisite you're absolutely wrong... so please educate yourself on the topic. You must be an Advanced Practice Nurse or enroll in a BS-DNP (meaning they acquire an MS in an advanced practice role while in the program and graduate with two degrees) or MS -DNP. Don't tell me I don't know my own profession. You don't see me rambling off about what physicians can and cannot do.

Oh, and good for your wife! That's a great way to advance the professionalization of nursing, not! Go become a PA, it'll be like a slap in the face to the nursing profession. Although she'd actually be a great PA with her undergrad in nursing. 🙂

Although our profession has it's issues so do the medical doctors and many others. For example, we must do "Time Out's" and fill out a checklist before we let a physician do any type of procedure or surgery on a patient because they make/made mistakes, like so many humans do, and remove the wrong body part or organ, and perform surgeries/procedures on the wrong patient. Nurses make mistakes too, they might give the wrong medication whether it be the wrong dose, med, time, route, or patient.

Thanks for your response.

Your math is so skewed and tampered with, you would make a great salesman. The educational time required to become an NP is 6-7 years total, not the 8-10 years you are advertising it to be in order to mislead others into thinking your education is on par with MDs. For brevity, I will not even touch the quality of classes in the DNP curriculum in this post.

4 years BSN + 2 years = 6 years = Master's degree, APNP
4 years BSN + 3 years = 7 years = DNP
No residency, or any sort of post graduate training.

Why are you assuming that part time educational years are the equivalent of full time educational years? If I completed my bachelor's degree in 8 years, does that mean my "8 year education" is superior to a 4 year bachelor's of the same concentration, or equivalent to a bachelor's + a 4 year graduate degree? Should I start running around and yelling to everyone how much more "learned" I am based on these extra 4 years? Should I advertise to everyone that a bachelor's takes 8 years to complete?

Maybe if you had taken that calculus class, you may have been able to do this simple math, and perhaps with quality research and statistics classes, you would have been able to gather and utilize the right information.
 
@Walter Lance Okay look. For your wife's sake. If she is really into the PA aspect of general surgery/emergency medicine/primary care and not so much into the ANP aspect of anesthesiology + other ANP/DNP fields then by all means, go ahead. But the fact that you convey she's going to go for a PA just because she thinks the educational curriculum of the DNP/MSN programs are vacuous is such a BAD reason to ostracize yourself from the NP field of practice. One current problem with the PA route is that PAs are required to take PANRE every ten years. That sounds like a lot of time, but the catch is that you have to cover all specialties and the questions on the exam don't necessarily correlate to the appropriate clinical answer. This forces most PAs to pay a lot of money for a crash course e.g. Lange or CME4Life and forces them to stress out over their ability to pass. Yes, you may pass the first time, the second time, and the third time. But every iteration of the exam gets a bit harder, therefore you have PAs who have had no trouble passing on the first try suddenly going into their third/fourth tries which causes unnecessary anxiety and stress. Currently the ANP model is the most sensible one. Perform sufficient CME in order to renew the license without having to take a nationalized recertification exam or the boards.

Does it make any sense that doctors before 1990 get grandfathered in and don't have to retake certification every ten years while younger doctors do? No. In addition the association of board examiners and the NCCPA have an absolute hold over the market. They could jack up prices or standards on the boards for no reason. Currently they are trying to completely revamp the PA requirements, but it will still involve a standardized test and the NCCPA is currently making $$$ on the current model so there is no reason to drastically change the system. I'm not arguing that it's impossible for someone to pass PANRE, I'm stating that there's no guarantee that you can pass the exam 10, 20, or 30+ years down the road and if you are an NP and have the choice to not subject yourself to a standardized test for a similar payout as an advanced practitioner, then why would you expose yourself to the risk? PAs are fighting to end the current format of PANRE, much like the 20,000 cardiologists petitioning against the boards. If she is interested in the PA scope of practice then sure it's probably worth the small turmoil down the road. However, just to do it because she is scoffing at the MSN/DNP system is ludicrous.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You said –


I provided examples of people I personally know who went from BSN straight into DNP programs without ever working as a RN. 4 years of undergrad + 2 years in a DNP program (yes 2 year DNP programs do exist) = 6 years total. In the case of the person who went AA in nursing (2 years) --> BSN (just under 1 year)--> DNP (2 years) = 5 years. That doesn’t add up to 6-7 just to get into a DNP program or 8-9 to graduate from one.



The only clinical experiences people going straight from undergrad into a DNP program will have are RN/BSN clinicals and whatever clinicals are arranged for the DNP program. That doesn’t really seem to entail “ladder climbing”, nor does it seem like enough clinical experience and knowledge to “hit the floor running” compared to PAs. Also, pretty much every nurse I've talked to has said that nursing clinicals do very little to prepare them and that most of their clinical learning occurs once they start actually working as an RN.



Some programs may have extra requirements (e.g., Stony Brook like you mentioned), but many don’t – hence the issue with inconsistent standards, education, and training.

http://www.umary.edu/academics/programs/doctorate-family-nurse-practitioner.php

https://www.ndsu.edu/nursing/bsn_to_dnp/admission_requirements/

People that graduate from programs like the ones above will have the exact same privileges as someone from a program with more stringent admission requirements, so long as they pass the licensing exam.



That’s part of her reasoning behind choosing the PA route should she decide to go back to school.



Not really sure what your point is here, “time-outs” aren't just a nursing thing and often involve physicians.

Regarding the certifications you keep mentioning, as others have pointed out those are a joke and pretty meaningless beyond being able to throw some additional letters after your name. My wife has taken the "certification" exams for psych and med-surg only because her employer at the time covered the costs and she got a slight pay increase for doing so. She took both exams cold without studying and passed the first time.

Edit - You also liked a post of someone agreeing with what I said regarding how long it takes to earn a DNP and issues regarding nursing education. Not sure if that point belongs under the troll category or reading comprehension deficits category.
The 9 yrs for a DNP isn't off.

My sister did 3 yr community college RN program + 1yr BSN (while working as RN) + 1yr working on a telometry unit while applying to NP school + 2yrs in NP school= 7yrs to get NP.

My sister worked full-time throughout schooling and the NP classes are 8hrs 1 day/wk (she went to a SUNY program), so the level of work and clinical experience they get is nowhere near medical school but it does take over 7 yrs to get a DNP.
 
The 9 yrs for a DNP isn't off.

My sister did 3 yr community college RN program + 1yr BSN (while working as RN) + 1yr working on a telometry unit while applying to NP school + 2yrs in NP school= 7yrs to get NP.

My sister worked full-time throughout schooling and the NP classes are 8hrs 1 day/wk (she went to a SUNY program), so the level of work and clinical experience they get is nowhere near medical school but it does take over 7 yrs to get a DNP.

So your sister took 6 years?? Why would you count the year she was working and applying to the total of her education??
 
So your sister took 6 years?? Why would you count the year she was working and applying to the total of her education??
I may be mistaken, but many ANP programs used to require you to have RN clinical experience. However, the fact that healthcare education is padding their pockets with the current education bubble market is making many institutions realize that offering accelerated credentialing programs is a huge cash cow in targeting non-trads who wouldn't go through nursing for just a second viable Bachelor's degree with a starting payout for approx. $40,000k+. Now you go through the pain of getting the second Bachelor's but the carrot on the stick is the direct pathway to an MSN/DNP.
 
The 9 yrs for a DNP isn't off.

My sister did 3 yr community college RN program + 1yr BSN (while working as RN) + 1yr working on a telometry unit while applying to NP school + 2yrs in NP school= 7yrs to get NP.

My sister worked full-time throughout schooling and the NP classes are 8hrs 1 day/wk (she went to a SUNY program), so the level of work and clinical experience they get is nowhere near medical school but it does take over 7 yrs to get a DNP.

That adds up to 6 years of school total, not 7+. I didn't pull the numbers out of the air in the post you quoted, they were all based on people I personally know (also examples showing that you don't need clinical experience to be accepted into DNP programs). Including time spent working as an RN and not actually in school is misleading.
 
@Mansamusa Some programs have a joint BSN+DNP program where you begin the DNP program right after finishing the BSN.
How many years is the DNP in these programs? My sister is trying to avoid getting a DNP as long as possible just because it adds literally no value to a NP.

@Benjoe11 6yrs isn't abnormal. My sister graduated this past year, so it's not even old school training. It takes 4yrs to get a BSN and 2 for NP. Then I know the SUNYs at least require 1yr clinical experience.

My sister is actually probably near the top in terms of training for NPs. She works at NYP where nurses have 6months of observed training and have to pass an in-house exam before going off on their own. And she is very aware of where a doctor is needed and no desire to expand her scope.

That's really the big problems with NPs: non-uniform training and the ones who try to overreach
 
Just a reminder that while it's lovely that this discussion is going civilly, we've gone very far away from the original point of the thread. In the pre-allo forum, all discussion should be related to allopathic medical school. If you want to discuss the difference between different midlevel training programs, we have forums for that.
 
@Ho0v-man
Stony Brook University is one of the top ranking universities in the world and they only accept the best of the best. The university gets around 34,110 applications a year and only 13,981 were accepted.

Here’s the link if you don’t believe me, http://www.stonybrook.edu/sb/fastfacts/


Well that changes everything. Please rescind my earlier comments. I didn't realize you went to such a powerhouse like Stony Brook. It really is a top program in the world... this mus be why Stony Brook Hospital doesn't even rank in the top 25 in it's own metro area... Realize you're not talking on a forum where people got their medical degree at University of Phoenix online
 
The 9 yrs for a DNP isn't off.

My sister did 3 yr community college RN program + 1yr BSN (while working as RN) + 1yr working on a telometry unit while applying to NP school + 2yrs in NP school= 7yrs to get NP.

My sister worked full-time throughout schooling and the NP classes are 8hrs 1 day/wk (she went to a SUNY program), so the level of work and clinical experience they get is nowhere near medical school but it does take over 7 yrs to get a DNP.
I worked for 7 years as a RN before starting med school... Do i have to count that 7 years as part as med school too?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top