Mad Jack's 4th Year AMA Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
what's your opinion on psychoanalysis.
oh-no-im-not-brave-enough-for-politics-three-drinks-29787130-1.png

It is a very complicated topic. I think there is value in psychoanalysis but that there are obviously some glaring flaws in psychoanalytical models. Regardless of whether the models themselves are correct or not, decent results can be had from some of the concepts and understanding them can augment other therapeutic modalities.
 
What video games are you playing?

I bought Playdead's Inside this year and it blew me away, have been looking to find more games like it ever since.
 
What video games are you playing?

I bought Playdead's Inside this year and it blew me away, have been looking to find more games like it ever since.
I'm a all over the map, but tend to be really into RPGs. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided is my next project after I finish Persona 4, which I only started playing because I was struggling to deal with the withdrawals after a friend conned me into playing Persona 5. Rimworld is a favorite of mine when I'm on the go, The Forest is the game I play most with friends, and I'm really looking forward to getting in some XCOM 2.
 
I'm a all over the map, but tend to be really into RPGs. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided is my next project after I finish Persona 4, which I only started playing because I was struggling to deal with the withdrawals after a friend conned me into playing Persona 5. Rimworld is a favorite of mine when I'm on the go, The Forest is the game I play most with friends, and I'm really looking forward to getting in some XCOM 2.

I haven't played any of the new XCOMs yet but the OG was my favorite game since I was 7 years old or something. People say they're great so I'll probably give them a shot (if you haven't played the old UFO/Terror from the Deep they're some of the most magically addicting games ever IMO).
 
I haven't played any of the new XCOMs yet but the OG was my favorite game since I was 7 years old or something. People say they're great so I'll probably give them a shot (if you haven't played the old UFO/Terror from the Deep they're some of the most magically addicting games ever IMO).
If you liked them you'll love the new ones. I was a huge XCOM fan as a kid and these games don't disappoint. I'd recommend playing the first game without the Enemy Within expansion initially, as it's a totally different experience that I don't feel you can fully appreciate unless you played the first game without it.
 
Will I be an outcast if I don't play video games? I haven't played video games in years. I played Mass Effect 3 for about a week right after deployment when I was waiting for my wife to move to where I was, but other than that, it's been like 8 years since I've played.
 
Will I be an outcast if I don't play video games? I haven't played video games in years. I played Mass Effect 3 for about a week right after deployment when I was waiting for my wife to move to where I was, but other than that, it's been like 8 years since I've played.
It's fine, most medical students don't seem to game
 
I'm a all over the map, but tend to be really into RPGs. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided is my next project after I finish Persona 4, which I only started playing because I was struggling to deal with the withdrawals after a friend conned me into playing Persona 5. Rimworld is a favorite of mine when I'm on the go, The Forest is the game I play most with friends, and I'm really looking forward to getting in some XCOM 2.

Fellow MS4 here, Deus Ex: Mankind Divided was absolutely excellent; it was my personal 2016 GOTY, beating out Dishonored 2. It sounds like we have similar tastes in games, so once you finish Deus Ex, I would very strongly recommend the new Prey if you haven't played that yet. It's like Bioshock meets Deus Ex in space.
 
I was the same way until I had them.
Yeah, I hear that a lot. But like, I know myself and children just wouldn't bring any joy to my life. I have been very up front about that in dating, and exclusively date those that are in the same boat. Nothing wrong with having kids, but it's certainly not for me
 
Fellow MS4 here, Deus Ex: Mankind Divided was absolutely excellent; it was my personal 2016 GOTY, beating out Dishonored 2. It sounds like we have similar tastes in games, so once you finish Deus Ex, I would very strongly recommend the new Prey if you haven't played that yet. It's like Bioshock meets Deus Ex in space.
I'll give it a shot. Honestly waiting for it to hit a Humble Bundle or PS Plus deal.
 
Yeah, I hear that a lot. But like, I know myself and children just wouldn't bring any joy to my life. I have been very up front about that in dating, and exclusively date those that are in the same boat. Nothing wrong with having kids, but it's certainly not for me

Nothing wrong with that!
 
Yeah, I hear that a lot. But like, I know myself and children just wouldn't bring any joy to my life. I have been very up front about that in dating, and exclusively date those that are in the same boat. Nothing wrong with having kids, but it's certainly not for me
I wish everyone was as self-reflective regarding this issue. It seems to be that knocking-up is the thing to do if you have nothing else going for you (obviously there are amazing parents who are passionate about their kids!). It boggles my mind that so many people have kids and (1) do not plan for the resources it truly requires, (2) do not truly invest their life into this new creation and just feed them iPads and junk food, and (3) see it as some sort of civil duty--as if reproducing without much reflection in our already overpopulated world is somehow going to make things better. I find all of this disturbing and discouraging because I myself would absolutely love raising a kid, but would never do so until I could guarantee I won't fail at it.

Edit: since this is a madjack thread I feel fully inclined to go off the deep-end on any topic--sorry not sorry 😉
 
I wish everyone was as self-reflective regarding this issue. It seems to be that knocking-up is the thing to do if you have nothing else going for you (obviously there are amazing parents who are passionate about their kids!). It boggles my mind that so many people have kids and (1) do not plan for the resources it truly requires, (2) do not truly invest their life into this new creation and just feed them iPads and junk food, and (3) see it as some sort of civil duty--as if reproducing without much reflection in our already overpopulated world is somehow going to make things better. I find all of this disturbing and discouraging because I myself would absolutely love raising a kid, but would never do so until I could guarantee I won't fail at it.

Edit: since this is a madjack thread I feel fully inclined to go off the deep-end on any topic--sorry not sorry 😉

I believed this before I had kids, but being a parent has only reinforced my belief that you should be required to pass an exam before being allowed to procreate.
 
I wish everyone was as self-reflective regarding this issue. It seems to be that knocking-up is the thing to do if you have nothing else going for you (obviously there are amazing parents who are passionate about their kids!). It boggles my mind that so many people have kids and (1) do not plan for the resources it truly requires, (2) do not truly invest their life into this new creation and just feed them iPads and junk food, and (3) see it as some sort of civil duty--as if reproducing without much reflection in our already overpopulated world is somehow going to make things better. I find all of this disturbing and discouraging because I myself would absolutely love raising a kid, but would never do so until I could guarantee I won't fail at it.

Edit: since this is a madjack thread I feel fully inclined to go off the deep-end on any topic--sorry not sorry 😉
Derailing is the most Mad Jack thing you could do lol
 
I believed this before I had kids, but being a parent has only reinforced my belief that you should be required to pass an exam before being allowed to procreate.
Glad I'm not the only one--I swear to most my beliefs on this issue would seem fascist or something. Baseline abilities to function should be a pre-requisite in order to have a child--god forbid we wish to improve society with such ideals :nono:
 
I can't grow the psych beard yetttt

FWIW, I buzzed off a lacrosse ball-sized amount of hair off my face last night (and a similar sized ball off my head on Friday). I came into work and our most-senior desk staff told me when I came in this morning, "Dr, WingedOx, you know you look like you're 12 years old now, right?"

Perhaps next winter I'll have the guts to go with the full Shel Silverstein look for more than the two days I had it... of course genetics is slowly making that my only option.
 
Just wanted to wish you good luck in the match and in your future career as a psychiatrist. I've read your posts since you were applying to med school and continued to read your progression as a medical student. I pretty much just lurk and read posts for my own pleasure and knowledge. I wanted to tell you that you have been one of my favorite posters and I don't think you even realize the impact you have had on other pre-meds and medical students.
 
Just wanted to wish you good luck in the match and in your future career as a psychiatrist. I've read your posts since you were applying to med school and continued to read your progression as a medical student. I pretty much just lurk and read posts for my own pleasure and knowledge. I wanted to tell you that you have been one of my favorite posters and I don't think you even realize the impact you have had on other pre-meds and medical students.
That really means a lot, thank you so much!
 
I wish everyone was as self-reflective regarding this issue. It seems to be that knocking-up is the thing to do if you have nothing else going for you (obviously there are amazing parents who are passionate about their kids!). It boggles my mind that so many people have kids and (1) do not plan for the resources it truly requires, (2) do not truly invest their life into this new creation and just feed them iPads and junk food, and (3) see it as some sort of civil duty--as if reproducing without much reflection in our already overpopulated world is somehow going to make things better. I find all of this disturbing and discouraging because I myself would absolutely love raising a kid, but would never do so until I could guarantee I won't fail at it.

Edit: since this is a madjack thread I feel fully inclined to go off the deep-end on any topic--sorry not sorry 😉

I don’t want to repeat myself as this has been debated ad nauseum, but the myth of overpopulated world drained by endless supply of babies produced by “irresponisble” parent is a fallacy stemming from previously debunked Malthusian economic theories that have been completely of for majority of 20th century and are more off recently. These theories are frequently used to push certain agenda by some prominent fringe groups in our society...

Glad I'm not the only one--I swear to most my beliefs on this issue would seem fascist or something. Baseline abilities to function should be a pre-requisite in order to have a child--god forbid we wish to improve society with such ideals :nono:

The world would much more likely be significantly worse off if any such policy was ever implemented.

Now, back to OP, Mad Jack, what are your thoughts on Viktor Frankl?
 
I don’t want to repeat myself as this has been debated ad nauseum, but the myth of overpopulated world drained by endless supply of babies produced by “irresponisble” parent is a fallacy stemming from previously debunked Malthusian economic theories that have been completely of for majority of 20th century and are more off recently. These theories are frequently used to push certain agenda by some prominent fringe groups in our society...



The world would much more likely be significantly worse off if any such policy was ever implemented.

Now, back to OP, Mad Jack, what are your thoughts on Viktor Frankl?
Frankl is a guy I haven't really looked into since undergrad. Given that my personal views are more absurdist than existentialistic in nature, I understand where he's coming from but have a slightly different take on the philosophy side. His therapy methods sounded more like applied philosophy than therapy, which seems interesting but likely to work on only the most high-functioning of clients. Maybe I'll add some of his work to my summer reading list, he sounds quite interesting.

As to how many people is too many- economics would argue infinite growth is ideal, but realistic estimates have the global population beginning to naturally decline due to changes in family planning before we reach any true capacity beyond which the earth can sustain us. I don't really care about the planet or anything like that- from an evolutionary perspective, life will continue no matter how much damage we cause, it is only a matter of what form that life will take in our wake.
 
Last edited:
View attachment 230136

I don’t believe in gaia but I thought that was apropos.
Totally how I view things lol. We're so self-centered that we believe we're destroying the planet, when we're really just making it harder for ourselves to ultimately survive and creating ecological niches that will be filled in the millions of years beyond our passing as a species
 
Frankl is a guy I haven't really looked into since undergrad. Given that my personal views are more absurdist than existentialistic in nature, I understand where he's coming from but have a slightly different take on the philosophy side. His therapy methods sounded more like applied philosophy than therapy, which seems interesting but likely to work on only the most high-functioning of clients. Maybe I'll add some of his work to my summer reading list, he sounds quite interesting.

As to how many people is too many- economics would argue infinite growth is ideal, but realistic estimates have the global population beginning to naturally decline due to changes in family planning before we reach any true capacity beyond which the earth can sustain us. I don't really care about the planet or anything like that- from an evolutionary perspective, life will continue no matter how much damage we cause, it is only a matter of what form that life will take in our wake.

E.O. Wilson has been a proponent of the theory that reforms in societies globally, due to sociological changes as much as technological ones will lead to an eventual population peak. I'm not sure I share his optimism..
 
E.O. Wilson has been a proponent of the theory that reforms in societies globally, due to sociological changes as much as technological ones will lead to an eventual population peak. I'm not sure I share his optimism..
It has held firm that birth rates decline with increasing prosperity in every nation studied. So long as poverty continues to decline, so should birth rates if trends continue unabated.
 
It has held firm that birth rates decline with increasing prosperity in every nation studied. So long as poverty continues to decline, so should birth rates if trends continue unabated.

While I agree there I'm not discounting the possibility of widespread political/economic catastrophe in multiple populous nations in the next 100 years. Western liberal democracy seems to be backsliding worldwide. It remains to be seen if the "benevolent authoritarianism" of people like Xi can maintain consistent economic growth and prosperity.
 
I agree with the first part of your post but disagree with this.
That's fair. It was a speculation on my end anyway.
While I agree there I'm not discounting the possibility of widespread political/economic catastrophe in multiple populous nations in the next 100 years. Western liberal democracy seems to be backsliding worldwide. It remains to be seen if the "benevolent authoritarianism" of people like Xi can maintain consistent economic growth and prosperity.
I am worried more about how our population growth is actually reflective of increased longevity, even in developing nations, rather than birth rates. In simple terms, we may end up with quickly dwindling numbers of the young while the numbers of old people requiring resources but being unable to work are growing.

On the topic of China, I tend to agree with this recent interview: China Is Not a Garden-Variety Dictatorship
 
Hi Mad Jack, thank you for doing this. I’m fairly new to this forum so am not familiar with the more insider things but I’ve read some of your posts and your supportiveness comes through. I’m glad to know the medical field is getting people like you. (Sorry I’m bad with words. I’m only a second year undergrad )

You’ve mentioned that you had a health care career before med school. Was that the career you had in mind during undergrad, or did you start that career with the ultimate goal of going into medicine?

I ask because as a premed it sometimes feels like my life doesn’t even start till I get into med school, for there to be even the possibility of becoming a doctor. Not to mention some premeds around me have career tunnel vision and idealized views on med school and the road beyond. My non-premed friends are already getting started on their long term careers and relationships it feels like I’m working towards a career that I have a vague idea about (I’ve done shadowing and volunteering) but am not entirely clear on the process of getting there.
 
Hi Mad Jack, thank you for doing this. I’m fairly new to this forum so am not familiar with the more insider things but I’ve read some of your posts and your supportiveness comes through. I’m glad to know the medical field is getting people like you. (Sorry I’m bad with words. I’m only a second year undergrad )

You’ve mentioned that you had a health care career before med school. Was that the career you had in mind during undergrad, or did you start that career with the ultimate goal of going into medicine?

I ask because as a premed it sometimes feels like my life doesn’t even start till I get into med school, for there to be even the possibility of becoming a doctor. Not to mention some premeds around me have career tunnel vision and idealized views on med school and the road beyond. My non-premed friends are already getting started on their long term careers and relationships it feels like I’m working towards a career that I have a vague idea about (I’ve done shadowing and volunteering) but am not entirely clear on the process of getting there.
Thanks for the kind words!

Medicine was a huge accident for me. I actually dropped out of high school and had to go to community college due to my having a GED. I picked respiratory therapy as my major because the field had a good amount of demand, I could keep people, and it was fairly technical which I enjoyed as a person who is very into tech. Over the years being a RT kind of felt limiting and I wanted time do more, so I hemmed and hawed over other potential routes to expanding my career, ultimately deciding on medicine. Being older gave me a lot of perspective, and working in the hospital have me a realistic expectation of what medicine would be like. It isn't some glorious job, it's often tedious, frustrating, and difficult and you feel like you're working against your employer, insurers, and often the patients themselves. But if you're not in it for the wrong reasons and you've got realistic expectations it's a great career.
 
Hi Mad Jack, thank you for doing this. I’m fairly new to this forum so am not familiar with the more insider things but I’ve read some of your posts and your supportiveness comes through. I’m glad to know the medical field is getting people like you. (Sorry I’m bad with words. I’m only a second year undergrad )

You’ve mentioned that you had a health care career before med school. Was that the career you had in mind during undergrad, or did you start that career with the ultimate goal of going into medicine?

I ask because as a premed it sometimes feels like my life doesn’t even start till I get into med school, for there to be even the possibility of becoming a doctor. Not to mention some premeds around me have career tunnel vision and idealized views on med school and the road beyond. My non-premed friends are already getting started on their long term careers and relationships it feels like I’m working towards a career that I have a vague idea about (I’ve done shadowing and volunteering) but am not entirely clear on the process of getting there.
I'll also say don't put your life on hold for medicine. You need to be a person to be a good doctor and it's hard to do that if you're not engaging with the world in normal ways and making medicine the entirety of your life experience. Make time for fun, love, and experiences along the way. You could die any day, after all, so try and live a life in which you would have as few regrets as possible if your time were to come tomorrow
 
What video games are you playing?

I bought Playdead's Inside this year and it blew me away, have been looking to find more games like it ever since.
Hope you've played Limbo as well!
 
Totally how I view things lol. We're so self-centered that we believe we're destroying the planet, when we're really just making it harder for ourselves to ultimately survive and creating ecological niches that will be filled in the millions of years beyond our passing as a species
Does this line of reasoning lead you to therefore care a little more about 👍our impact on the planet? Or do you take more of an "if it doesn't impact our generation, it is less important" approach?
 
That's fair. It was a speculation on my end anyway.

You wouldn't be the first to speculate about it. I actually wouldn't be surprised if that line of reasoning logically led to genetically altering humans at birth to be sterile until they reached a certain age and passed certain tests. Not too far off Brave New World.
 
Does this line of reasoning lead you to therefore care a little more about 👍our impact on the planet? Or do you take more of an "if it doesn't impact our generation, it is less important" approach?
I'm ambivalent. I try to be responsible but also feel it doesn't much matter, I'm doing it because I like the idea of future generations experiencing the planet we do, not because current ecosystems have any inherent value.
 
I'm ambivalent. I try to be responsible but also feel it doesn't much matter, I'm doing it because I like the idea of future generations experiencing the planet we do, not because current ecosystems have any inherent value.

I don't have that nihilistic approach to things, but the result ends up being the same.
 
Yes, which is why I have a less nihilistic approach.
I was more curious about you agreeing with MadJack's statement "I try to be responsible but also feel it doesn't much matter", because I would think your belief system would cause your end result to be that you try to be responsible while feeling it matters.

But then again I was neither clear in my actual question nor is this particularly appropriate in MadJack's AMA.


Not everyone subscribes to such beliefs
I understand this well, as I do not subscribe to such beliefs.
 
Thanks for the kind words!

Medicine was a huge accident for me. I actually dropped out of high school and had to go to community college due to my having a GED. I picked respiratory therapy as my major because the field had a good amount of demand, I could keep people, and it was fairly technical which I enjoyed as a person who is very into tech. Over the years being a RT kind of felt limiting and I wanted time do more, so I hemmed and hawed over other potential routes to expanding my career, ultimately deciding on medicine. Being older gave me a lot of perspective, and working in the hospital have me a realistic expectation of what medicine would be like. It isn't some glorious job, it's often tedious, frustrating, and difficult and you feel like you're working against your employer, insurers, and often the patients themselves. But if you're not in it for the wrong reasons and you've got realistic expectations it's a great career.
Thank you for sharing about your journey this far! It is very inspiring that you became interested in medicine because you wanted to do more after first experiencing the practical side — many traditional students are the opposite, they pursue medicine because of the fulfilling name and prestige of challenge without considering what they’ll actually end up doing. I see that getting into medicine for the right reasons and having realistic expectations are important to having a comfortable career (and in any other field too I guess). I happy that you found what you want and that things are working out for you. I haven’t exactly figured it out yet but I’ll be patient with myself.
 
I'll also say don't put your life on hold for medicine. You need to be a person to be a good doctor and it's hard to do that if you're not engaging with the world in normal ways and making medicine the entirety of your life experience. Make time for fun, love, and experiences along the way. You could die any day, after all, so try and live a life in which you would have as few regrets as possible if your time were to come tomorrow
Haha very true. Life is about personal growth and experiencing new things and enjoying things I like. Definitely will keep things in perspective and try to live everyday without regrets.
 
Top