Matching question from concerned parent

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

CP2

New Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2007
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
My child is MS3 at a state med school. Her Step 1 is 240+ (I don't remember the last digit). She wants to be an eye doctor. I understand she has to get a match to enter residency. I have a few questions about the match.

1) She said she would apply to about 30 places. Is she applying to that many programs in order to get ONE match? Or to get a BETTER match?

2) I checked SF Match statistics. Apparently, many are not matched. Can one improve match probability by ranking lower programs high? In other words, is match outcome determined by careful ranking or her overall standing in the competition? Is she likely to get a match in your opinion (soley based on Step 1 score)?

3) She has applied for externship at 5 places and received acceptance from 2 places. Are the programs that didn't offer externship not likely offer residency? Or are residency and externship two different things?

Thank you in advance for your answer(s). I am not trying to educate myself so that I can counsel my child. I just want to be able to understand the process a little better and understand her stress level.
 
CP2,

Your daughter has a competitive step 1 score. The average for those that match in ophtho is around 230.

1. The average amount of programs people apply to are 35-45...just getting interviews in this field is hard enough.

2. No, the way the match works is that the algorithm tentatively places her in her #1 if that program ranked her...unless higher ranked applicants bump her down. Then the algorithm places it in her #2, and so on and so forth. So it is really to her advantage to rank the programs SHE wants to go, higher.

3. Externships and residency are 2 different things. Doesn't mean she won't get an interview for residency. Many times, they can't accomodate visiting students because their rotations fill up with students from their home program.

4. Will she match? No idea...she would benefit from having a well rounded application (board score, AOA/class rank, strong recommendation letters from well known ophthalmologists, some ophtho research, community service stuff, interview/externship skills).

Good luck.
 
Thank you for kindly answering my questions. I bookmarked and saved Dr. Albert Lin's link for my child. I understand the selection process a little better now, and can have more compassion for my child (and others who are going through the same process). Thank you again.
 
PS: V05, it's a small world. i just presented your PTC/CVST paper at our grand rounds today. 👍

I hope the paper was not ripped to threads... 😀
 
Top