Hi ...I guess this is a stupid question but what the heck...I'll ask anyway. Can an MD/DO decide to work as a PA? They almost have the same qualifications, right?
Thanks
Nev
Thanks
Nev
nev said:Hi ...I guess this is a stupid question but what the heck...I'll ask anyway. Can an MD/DO decide to work as a PA? They almost have the same qualifications, right?
Thanks
Nev
there used to be a loophole in the state of florida laws that allowed this but it no longer exists.no other state has ever allowed this to the best of my knowledge.NRAI2001 said:I ve heard stories of foreign doctors who couldnt pass exams or couldnt pass exams right away working as PAs for some time.
OSUdoc08 said:Why? Would an MD work as an RN? No.
It doesn't matter if an MD knows when at RN can do. They aren't licensed as an RN, and it wouldn't make any sense to do it anyway.
rsfarrell said:And BTW, they couldn't do it. Anyone who has ever worked in a hospital can tell you that if you replaced all the nurses with doctors, half the patients would be dead within the week.
Praetorian said:Because most doctors have far less of a clue as to what is really going on than most decent nurses. But you should also keep in mind that it was probably meant as a tongue in cheek comment.
NRAI2001 said:I really highly doubt that.
rsfarrell said:Which part?
Half the patients are not going to die; most of them are not mortally ill to begin with. But all the critical elements to making a hospital run -- managing flow, staffing, starting IVs, wound management, obtaining and pushing meds, dealing with monitors, pumps, and other equipment, and handling patients -- are done by CNAs and RNs. It is the exceptional doctor who has a clue how to deal with these issues.
If I had to chose, I'd far rather run a hospital without doctors, rather than one without nurses.
NRAI2001 said:I think most doctors could start an IV and manage wounds. It is the doctor who gives the order and decides the course of treatment. Nurses follow orders.
OSUdoc08 said:It has nothing to do with skills.
Put a bunch of supervisors alone in a factory, and nothing will be manufactured.
NRAI2001 said:Of course nurses are important, but to say that nurses know more about medicine than a Medical Doctorate is dumb. Most doctors wouldnt be happy doing some of the work that nurses do, but to say that they would be clueless on how to start IVs and read monitors is also dumb.
You've obviously never spent a large amount of time on the wards. Most of the time the docs (at least the ones I would want treating me) look at the nurses and go "What's up with Mr. -----? What do you think we should do?". Either that or the nurses (or RT's ) call the doc, tell them what's up, what they want to do and the doc goes "OK, write the order and I'll sign it later."NRAI2001 said:I think most doctors could start an IV and manage wounds. It is the doctor who gives the order and decides the course of treatment. Nurses follow orders.
NRAI2001 said:Of course nurses are important, but to say that nurses know more about medicine than a Medical Doctorate is dumb.
Praetorian said:Experience with some education trumps education alone any day of the week. So I guess you're going into medicine at least partly for the "prestige"?
rsfarrell said:Which part?
Half the patients are not going to die; most of them are not mortally ill to begin with. But all the critical elements to making a hospital run -- managing flow, staffing, starting IVs, wound management, obtaining and pushing meds, dealing with monitors, pumps, and other equipment, and handling patients -- are done by CNAs and RNs. It is the exceptional doctor who has a clue how to deal with these issues.
If I had to chose, I'd far rather run a hospital without doctors, rather than one without nurses.
MacGyver said:Uhh all that stuff is EASY to do..... you do know that you can get an LPN straight out of high school right?
Doctors could handle that stuff fine, its just they prefer not to deal with the more trivial issues.
Praetorian said:You've obviously never spent a large amount of time on the wards. Most of the time the docs (at least the ones I would want treating me) look at the nurses and go "What's up with Mr. -----? What do you think we should do?". Either that or the nurses (or RT's ) call the doc, tell them what's up, what they want to do and the doc goes "OK, write the order and I'll sign it later."
Praetorian said:You've obviously never spent a large amount of time on the wards. Most of the time the docs (at least the ones I would want treating me) look at the nurses and go "What's up with Mr. -----? What do you think we should do?". Either that or the nurses (or RT's ) call the doc, tell them what's up, what they want to do and the doc goes "OK, write the order and I'll sign it later."