Milkshake - Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
Kota1000 said:
Since I moved Alissa neutral, I decided to do some rereading.
So looking back at posts, I am going to switch my lynch off Genny for now. Though she is still a suspect,

unlynch genny
Lynch Bc

BC has initially lynched SAR but then unlynched her and lynched suni. They then said they didn’t feel comfortable about the SAR lynch and felt that SAR had a good level of suspicion to make BC feel good about them.
Today, BC started out on a short rant regarding failure to lynch SAR, which is fine, but it seems a little too loud with the caps and punctuation. She did give rather good reads regarding other people and their interaction with SAR yesterday, but it also had a lot of punctuation and just sort of blabbed it all out in one long paragraph.

I know a lot of people have suspicions about Paws, but I don’t really agree at the moment.
Click to expand...
Lol I know, I literally can't even defend any of that because it just looks so bad. Totally agree with you. I guess the only thing I can say is why would I be saying those things right around lynch close? Like I already said "hey I don't like the Doggo lynch given her post 10 minutes before close and given the way that people are reacting- rather, not reacting- to it", SAR is already going down, what possible purpose does it serve me as a wolf to say 3 minutes before close "gee I don't know if I like the SAR lynch either"? Clearly I didn't want anyone to switch from SAR to Doggo or something since I really didn't like the Doggo wagon, so what would the point of me being like "wow this feels like a v/v lynch" have been if I knew that in 3 minutes, SAR was going to flip wolf? Like I just can't see how it would benefit me as a wolf to be commenting like that unless it was for the specific reason of being able to make this post right now lol.

(also on a side note I'm prone to long rambly paragraphs in general so that's just me lol)
 
Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (2) - Paws, 3m
genny () -
Paws (1) - mpm
BC (1) - Kota
Doggo (1) - Coop

5/13
lynch close in ~6 hours
 
BigCats said:
Lol I know, I literally can't even defend any of that because it just looks so bad. Totally agree with you. I guess the only thing I can say is why would I be saying those things right around lynch close? Like I already said "hey I don't like the Doggo lynch given her post 10 minutes before close and given the way that people are reacting- rather, not reacting- to it", SAR is already going down, what possible purpose does it serve me as a wolf to say 3 minutes before close "gee I don't know if I like the SAR lynch either"? Clearly I didn't want anyone to switch from SAR to Doggo or something since I really didn't like the Doggo wagon, so what would the point of me being like "wow this feels like a v/v lynch" have been if I knew that in 3 minutes, SAR was going to flip wolf? Like I just can't see how it would benefit me as a wolf to be commenting like that unless it was for the specific reason of being able to make this post right now lol.

(also on a side note I'm prone to long rambly paragraphs in general so that's just me lol)
Click to expand...

I understand that it was rather late in the game, but if doggo also flips wolf like others seem to be suspicious off, it may not look that good for you since you defended both of them. Also, your initial SAR lynch was a joke, which sort of set off your string of joking posts D1 which I thought wasn’t in character for you. Your usually more calculating and calm then outright joking and loud in posts, based on they games I’ve played before.
 
Coopah said:
Then that's my fault for not being clear. Doggo just got a flurry of votes. If SAR votes Sunni then later flips wolf it might look like she was actively protecting doggo, then doggo gets lynched.
Click to expand...
I guess that's fair but I've learned that if you can protect a wolf without arousing undue suspicion then you should. Feels like a stretch for D1 wolf thinking, like if Doggo and SAR were wolves then instead of self prezzing on each other they could have both hopped on sunni, and no one would know for days and then its wifom if one of them flip.

But I hear you and I agree its possible, I just don't find it likely.

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
 
mypetmoose said:
What are your current thoughts on bc and genny?
Click to expand...
I need to look at yesterday again but bc seems sketchy to me based mostly on her post about SAR flipping wolf because it didn’t feel totally genuine to me. Her posts today about why would a wolf do that haven’t really been convincing to me either.
i feel okay about genny right now, she feels village to me and I don’t understand some of the things people have been pointing out as sketchy
 
Coopah said:
Then that's my fault for not being clear. Doggo just got a flurry of votes. If SAR votes Sunni then later flips wolf it might look like she was actively protecting doggo, then doggo gets lynched.
Click to expand...
So who are the wolves in this scenario, sar and doggo but not sunni?
 
I really don't see why Doggo would be a wolf. 9:50 last night, Doggo is in the lead with four votes, Doggo is voting for SAR who has three votes, Sunbodi also has three votes. If she and SAR were exactly two wolves, why would Doggo not have switched to Sunbodi to self-prez? I even suggested that she do so in order to at least give herself a fighting chance but she stayed on SAR's vote. Unless y'all think she did so for the ultimate bus, I'm just not seeing it.
 
Like unless Doggo, SAR, and Sunbodi are exactly three wolves, I'm not buying it.
 
I do think Coop is village based on vote position and general tone but I just really don't agree with the Doggo vote.
 
mypetmoose said:
I guess that's fair but I've learned that if you can protect a wolf without arousing undue suspicion then you should. Feels like a stretch for D1 wolf thinking, like if Doggo and SAR were wolves then instead of self prezzing on each other they could have both hopped on sunni, and no one would know for days and then its wifom if one of them flip.

But I hear you and I agree its possible, I just don't find it likely.

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
Click to expand...
That's a fair assessment.
 
mypetmoose said:
I want to hear your thoughts on paws

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
Click to expand...
I’ve already given my thoughts on paws today, too lazy to find and quote it but it exists. I don’t think she and 3m are w/w and 3m seems to be throwing crap at the wall to see what sticks, the SAR link is still weirding me out, idk.
 
Coopah said:
The SAR link?
Click to expand...
SAR commenting on Paws being village as well as saying she was furthering her village meta through a self-inflicted post restriction. A lot of WIFOM there for me
 
And I especially don’t think it’s exactly Sunbodi/SAR/Doggo because both SAR and Doggo could’ve prezzed to Sunbodi, Sunbodi flips wolf, yay both cleared!! SAR/Sunbodi would make more sense to me as a possible pair. Also where is @Sunbodi ?
 
BigCats said:
I really don't see why Doggo would be a wolf. 9:50 last night, Doggo is in the lead with four votes, Doggo is voting for SAR who has three votes, Sunbodi also has three votes. If she and SAR were exactly two wolves, why would Doggo not have switched to Sunbodi to self-prez? I even suggested that she do so in order to at least give herself a fighting chance but she stayed on SAR's vote. Unless y'all think she did so for the ultimate bus, I'm just not seeing it.
Click to expand...

I agree with you on this, I would feel better about a Sun lynch as opposed to a doggo, but I also don’t think a sun lynch is a good idea just cause they’re not here to defend themselves
 
Kota1000 said:
I also don’t think a sun lynch is a good idea just cause they’re not here to defend themselves
Click to expand...
This is a terrible reason not to lynch someone. Imagine if we adopted the policy of not lynching people who aren't around. Wolves could just shut up and coast.

I think a Suni lynch is a bad idea because she seems to be headed for a mod kill. Same thing for a Sporty lynch, unless she actually does come back and talk more.
 
BigCats said:
And I especially don’t think it’s exactly Sunbodi/SAR/Doggo because both SAR and Doggo could’ve prezzed to Sunbodi, Sunbodi flips wolf, yay both cleared!! SAR/Sunbodi would make more sense to me as a possible pair. Also where is @Sunbodi ?
Click to expand...
You sound so village, and yet I also want to vote for you. It's unsettling.
 
genny said:
This is a terrible reason not to lynch someone. Imagine if we adopted the policy of not lynching people who aren't around. Wolves could just shut up and coast.

I think a Suni lynch is a bad idea because she seems to be headed for a mod kill. Same thing for a Sporty lynch, unless she actually does come back and talk more.
Click to expand...

Well if they posted occasionally, like more then the 3 posts early D1, I would consider them a wolf, but I think it doesn’t warrant a lynch. Especially as you pointed out she will probably be mod killed, and if she was a wolf she probably would be more concerned with the game
 
Coopah said:
Then that's my fault for not being clear. Doggo just got a flurry of votes. If SAR votes Sunni then later flips wolf it might look like she was actively protecting doggo, then doggo gets lynched.
Click to expand...
So if you go back and look at when Doggo placed her vote, the tally was SAR and Suni tied at 3 apiece, with Dubz and Doggo close behind with 2 each. The flurry of votes on Doggo happened after she voted, not before. Doggo's vote pushed SAR ahead in the tally. Do you think she'd try a bus like that on Day 1, when she could have voted Dubz or Suni?
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
I think you usually read WZ well and I thought she was village so I find it weird that you were struggling. It could be a village mistake, sometimes I have trouble with AM D1 or d2 also. What have you contributed that has been village? A bunch of hmmm reactions?
Click to expand...
I don't think I've ever read Dubz well, so idk what you're talking about.
 
genny said:
So if you go back and look at when Doggo placed her vote, the tally was SAR and Suni tied at 3 apiece, with Dubz and Doggo close behind with 2 each. The flurry of votes on Doggo happened after she voted, not before. Doggo's vote pushed SAR ahead in the tally. Do you think she'd try a bus like that on Day 1, when she could have voted Dubz or Suni?
Click to expand...
Ok good point. I'll put away my shiny tinfoil for now.

Unlynch doggo
 
Coopah said:
Let me pull out my crystal ball...

I don't know. I'm thinking SAR and doggo, but I'm sure as hell not ruling out all three.
Click to expand...
This is so frustrating. I am asking about the specific example that you gave and who you meant as wolves in that specific example that you gave jfc
 
genny said:
This is a terrible reason not to lynch someone. Imagine if we adopted the policy of not lynching people who aren't around. Wolves could just shut up and coast.

I think a Suni lynch is a bad idea because she seems to be headed for a mod kill. Same thing for a Sporty lynch, unless she actually does come back and talk more.
Click to expand...
You really think sporty is not going to talk knowing she will get mod killed? Do you also realize you are repeating my argument about sunni being a bad vote?
 
We haven’t seen wolf!sunbodi before but eh sunbodi being MIA and divulging info they shouldn’t (assuming their claim as vanillavillager is truthful) doesn’t seem outside of the realm of village!sunbodi based on their gameplay in the past. I did have to keep telling them in WWarriors to stop putting on thread info. Until sunbodi shows up and gives us something else, they’re neutral for me

SARdoghandler said:
unlynch Kota, lynch doggo

Equally good moving here, and it's a much better option for self prez
Click to expand...
It is interesting that SAR moved her lynch vote to doggo over Sunbodi but it would have been more strange for her to vote Sunbodi over doggo since SAR already voiced concerns about doggo. I agree that unless SAR, Sunni and Doggo are all the wolves then Doggo probably isn't a wolf just based on voting patterns.
 
What is everyone's opinion on how BC was around at lynch close but didn't join either of the main wagons? I think I'm happy with either a BC or Paws lynch today...

Also, this interaction feeling interesting...
StayingPositive2017 said:
Thank you!!!!!!! So far:
genny N
BC v
Paws Very Vill!!!!!!!!
Everyone else missing!!!!!!!!!!
Click to expand...
SARdoghandler said:
Rereading now and picking out a few things. Probably going to break it up by what stands out per page because post mins, yaknow?



Curious as to what made you read BC as village so early when you sat Genny neutral.
Click to expand...
StayingPositive2017 said:
Haha it was more a joke post for AM about Ara!!!!!!!!! There were only 5 posts besides me, too early for reads don't you think?
Click to expand...
SARdoghandler said:
Ok that makes more sense. I was wondering if you had seen something I didn't since it did feel very early to make that sort of separation
Click to expand...
So the above is one interaction that made me feel odd, even though it is framed as a joke that SAR responded seriously to...and then below are some other quotes I pulled that lean me towards paws. I bolded the important parts
SARdoghandler said:
lynch Kota

didnt like their comments around Paws's exclamation marks. Felt very wishy washy over a short period of time between throwing shade and then thinking more villager. Then putting both Coop and 3m into their village pile. Idk, gave me feels
Click to expand...
defense
SARdoghandler said:
There are a whole lot of people still missing

And who need to meet a post minimum
Click to expand...
this made me think there is a potential absentee, which is unrelated to the paws argument but ended up in my quotes anyways lol oops

SARdoghandler said:
Feeling village on paws, Coop, Genny. Susp on Kota and you for the most part. Everyone else files into a neutral category

Any particular reason it's felt like you're lying low today and trying to blend into the background?
Click to expand...
SARdoghandler said:
Because in what world does wolf!Paws give herself a posting restriction?
Click to expand...
More defense

As for BC, there's that creation of a lighthearted interaction early --"I'm gonna vote for you bc you got me good recently," being thrown into paws' joke post early, last night wishy wishy, and tbh I reallllly didn't like her long post earlier today. Made me feel worse about her...

Again, happy to vote in either category to see their flips
 
mypetmoose said:
What is everyone's opinion on how BC was around at lynch close but didn't join either of the main wagons? I think I'm happy with either a BC or Paws lynch today...

Also, this interaction feeling interesting...




So the above is one interaction that made me feel odd, even though it is framed as a joke that SAR responded seriously to...and then below are some other quotes I pulled that lean me towards paws. I bolded the important parts

defense

this made me think there is a potential absentee, which is unrelated to the paws argument but ended up in my quotes anyways lol oops



More defense

As for BC, there's that creation of a lighthearted interaction early --"I'm gonna vote for you bc you got me good recently," being thrown into paws' joke post early, last night wishy wishy, and tbh I reallllly didn't like her long post earlier today. Made me feel worse about her...

Again, happy to vote in either category to see their flips
Click to expand...
Should I pull WZs quotes that are like these from sar?
 
mypetmoose said:
What is everyone's opinion on how BC was around at lynch close but didn't join either of the main wagons? I think I'm happy with either a BC or Paws lynch today...

Also, this interaction feeling interesting...




So the above is one interaction that made me feel odd, even though it is framed as a joke that SAR responded seriously to...and then below are some other quotes I pulled that lean me towards paws. I bolded the important parts

defense

this made me think there is a potential absentee, which is unrelated to the paws argument but ended up in my quotes anyways lol oops



More defense

As for BC, there's that creation of a lighthearted interaction early --"I'm gonna vote for you bc you got me good recently," being thrown into paws' joke post early, last night wishy wishy, and tbh I reallllly didn't like her long post earlier today. Made me feel worse about her...

Again, happy to vote in either category to see their flips
Click to expand...
And additionally, I fee like I've been hearing a bit of an echo from BC, so that doesn't help her case...
 
mypetmoose said:
Sure! If you think that will mean something, I'm all ears
Click to expand...
WildZoo said:
Yes lol acting bizarre /= wolf and it's quite often the opposite. Hence my low-hanging fruit comment.
Click to expand...
WildZoo said:
what reason does a wolf have to post so obviously different from their normal?
Click to expand...
WildZoo said:
Paws shouting that things she's doing are NAI is also fairly well within her village range, so she's only giving herself more points here :laugh:
Click to expand...
Did it occur to you that SAR was trying to pocket either me or WZ by agreeing/defending?
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
Should I pull WZs quotes that are like these from sar?
Click to expand...
But I will say that I totally still had WZ in my potentially wolfy pile when she was killed so if you are trying to say she is also suspicious I may be inclined to agree lol
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
Did it occur to you that SAR was trying to pocket either me or WZ by agreeing/defending?
Click to expand...
It did occur to me, and it is still possible (one of those distraction tactics by talking but talking about unimportant things), but I still am really liking you and bc as a pack.

Do you have ideas for packs yet? You're on sporty right? Who else is her buddy?
 
mypetmoose said:
But I will say that I totally still had WZ in my potentially wolfy pile when she was killed so if you are trying to say she is also suspicious I may be inclined to agree lol
Click to expand...
I'm definitely not saying she was suspicious. I thought she was village that's why I asked her right before lynch why doggo to make sure I wasn't crazy
 
mypetmoose said:
It did occur to me, and it is still possible (one of those distraction tactics by talking but talking about unimportant things), but I still am really liking you and bc as a pack.

Do you have ideas for packs yet? You're on sporty right? Who else is her buddy?
Click to expand...
I have only been scanning today. Its mothers day, a sunday, and I have a family. If you want to lynch me today then whatever but i will actually take a look tomorrow and get back to you
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
57K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
40K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
57K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
90K
samac
samac
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
61K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top