Milkshake - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Did you already explain this and I missed it?
It's mostly the push to Doggo and away from SAR. And the SAR WIFOM.

I am also tempted by Wondering and BC, but they are both sounding village in their posts. I could go for Barks too, I suppose, since she has not sounded as villagey.
 
Please confirm you think sporty is a bad lynch cuz shes going to get modkilled. If that is true then who do you think I should vote for besides myself
Yes, if she doesn't post anything in the next 3 hours, she's going to face consequences, whatever those are.

I believe it is up to you to find more than one person suspicious in this game, since we know we have more than 1 wolf left. If your POE contains one player only right now, you are doing it wrong.
 
Yes, if she doesn't post anything in the next 3 hours, she's going to face consequences, whatever those are.

I believe it is up to you to find more than one person suspicious in this game, since we know we have more than 1 wolf left. If your POE contains one player only right now, you are doing it wrong.
No my poe contains everyone except the couple I mentioned as village. I have not narrowed it down yet.

Please quote where I pushed away from sar
 
I'm so glad the third maybe 4th person explaining it could get it through to you
I said I thought it was worth discussing, it was discussed. Several people pointed out counterarguments to my argument. I don't know if I'm right or wrong, I found those arguments persuasive and changed my vote. Which is what you wanted, so I'm honestly not sure where this excess of eye rolling is coming from unless it's a version of MU posting style again. This doesn't mean I discounted you opinion or whatever. I'm starting to get very annoyed by you.
 
What is everyone's opinion on how BC was around at lynch close but didn't join either of the main wagons? I think I'm happy with either a BC or Paws lynch today...

Also, this interaction feeling interesting...




So the above is one interaction that made me feel odd, even though it is framed as a joke that SAR responded seriously to...and then below are some other quotes I pulled that lean me towards paws. I bolded the important parts

defense

this made me think there is a potential absentee, which is unrelated to the paws argument but ended up in my quotes anyways lol oops



More defense

As for BC, there's that creation of a lighthearted interaction early --"I'm gonna vote for you bc you got me good recently," being thrown into paws' joke post early, last night wishy wishy, and tbh I reallllly didn't like her long post earlier today. Made me feel worse about her...

Again, happy to vote in either category to see their flips
Lol I literally voted for SAR in SIGNUPS. That's not the "creation of a lighthearted interaction"- that's the continuation of something I'd already said I was going to do.
And additionally, I fee like I've been hearing a bit of an echo from BC, so that doesn't help her case...
What have I been echoing?
 
You were annoyed by me yesterday so I dont think it's just now starting. The last time you went after everything I said you were a wolf driving my lynch so this is noted
:laugh: which game was this? Also I wish AM was playing so I could ask her how many times I've been a wolf on your lynch versus how many times I've been a villager on your lynch. Come on now, you should know that arguments like that aren't very effective.
 
And additionally, I fee like I've been hearing a bit of an echo from BC, so that doesn't help her case...
I agree with this. She has provided a few reads, but a lot of it is repetition.

Yes. Also yes. Kota doesn't always get things the first time someone says them, hence the repetition.
It wasn't really repetition, it was more you disagreeing with why I don't think a sun Lynch is a good thing, and you giving your input as to why the Lynch wouldn't be useful... not that this matters at all, I just wanted to put it out there. I did see other peoples comments earlier about sun and sporty getting mod killed, I just didn't mention it.
 
It's mostly the push to Doggo and away from SAR. And the SAR WIFOM.

I am also tempted by Wondering and BC, but they are both sounding village in their posts. I could go for Barks too, I suppose, since she has not sounded as villagey.

Hasn't wondering only posted a few posts in the beginning? why are you tempted?

Also, what makes you think bark's is not sounding villagey?
 
I am also tempted by Wondering and BC, but they are both sounding village in their posts. I could go for Barks too, I suppose, since she has not sounded as villagey.
Why are you tempted to go for BC or me if we sound village in posts?
 
Hasn't wondering only posted a few posts in the beginning? why are you tempted?

Also, what makes you think bark's is not sounding villagey?
Not that Barks specifically sounds wolfy, but that she hasn't sounded as villagey as BC and Wondering have in their posts today. Barks also did some light questioning of the SAR lynch yesterday.

Wondering subbed for the absent Stagg, so we have no data for that player for day 1. That's why lynching there is tempting - an absent wolf on day 1 could have made it easier for village to lynch SAR. The things that Wondering has posted today kind of align with the way I was thinking after day 1, so either I'm being misled by wolves, or Wondering is having the same village thoughts that I am.
 
unlynch BC
Lynch Paws


I am feeling better about the Paw's Lynch now. I know I said I was leaning more village on them earlier; however, I feel like they have been rather shallow in their posts recently and they haven't provided a whole lot of substantial evidence to their defense, and rather have been trying to redirect the focus to others, i.e. doggo. Also their mention about who else they should vote for rather then themselves seems very odd. Additionally, I don't like the fact that they only have enough suspicion on Sporty to vote their, and they aren't changing the Lynch despite it being pointed out that sporty will probably be mod killed anyways
 
What does the majority have to lead by to close the Lynch?
 
Yes, thanks for your concern.
I said I would be back. I’ve been working on my rotation all day. I have a few quizzes left and then I will do the analysis I need to do to sort something out in my head

TL;DR: what if Coop is a wolf
Welcome back! Glad you got some work done.

What makes you think coop is a wolf? I've been reading them village
 
lynch barks
So are paws and barks your top suspects? or did you change your mind about paws? I know you unlynched for majority, just wondering if you still feel the same about paws.
 
So are paws and barks your top suspects? or did you change your mind about paws? I know you unlynched for majority, just wondering if you still feel the same about paws.
Yes, I will still vote for paws. I like to see what happens when people are offered more than 2 choices for lynch though.
 
Lynch Tracker
SAR - BC
WZ - paws
Sunni - genny
doggo - bark
WZ - paws
WZ - sporty
stagg - WZ
3m - paws
paws - coop
paws - coop, 3m
WZ - sporty, kota
paws - coop, 3m
sporty - 3m
bc - alissa
SAR - bc
sunbodi - genny, bc
bc - alissa
sunbodi - genny, bc, alissa
3m - paws
kota - SAR
stagg - WZ
SAR - WZ
SAR - WZ, mpm
doggo - bark, paws
paws - coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
doggo - bark, paws, WZ
kota - SAR
doggo - bark, paws, WZ, SAR
WZ - sporty, kota
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota
sunni - genny, bc, alissa
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota, alissa
 
Lynch Tracker
SAR - BC
WZ - paws
Sunni - genny
doggo - bark
WZ - paws
WZ - sporty
stagg - WZ
3m - paws
paws - coop
paws - coop, 3m
WZ - sporty, kota
paws - coop, 3m
sporty - 3m
bc - alissa
SAR - bc
sunbodi - genny, bc
bc - alissa
sunbodi - genny, bc, alissa
3m - paws
kota - SAR
stagg - WZ
SAR - WZ
SAR - WZ, mpm
doggo - bark, paws
paws - coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
doggo - bark, paws, WZ
kota - SAR
doggo - bark, paws, WZ, SAR
WZ - sporty, kota
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota
sunni - genny, bc, alissa
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota, alissa
(For D1)
 
Lynch Tracker
SAR - BC
WZ - paws
Sunni - genny
doggo - bark
WZ - paws
WZ - sporty
stagg - WZ
3m - paws
paws - coop
paws - coop, 3m
WZ - sporty, kota
paws - coop, 3m
sporty - 3m
bc - alissa
SAR - bc
sunbodi - genny, bc
bc - alissa
sunbodi - genny, bc, alissa
3m - paws
kota - SAR
stagg - WZ
SAR - WZ
SAR - WZ, mpm
doggo - bark, paws
paws - coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
doggo - bark, paws, WZ
kota - SAR
doggo - bark, paws, WZ, SAR
WZ - sporty, kota
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota
sunni - genny, bc, alissa
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota, alissa
I did that earlier today, but I also colored WZ green.
 
Ahhhhhh that's right!!!
Unlynch WZ for her graduation. There us always tomorrow!!!!
Think about MU and you will understand!!!!!!!!!!
So what will you contribute to the conversation??!!!!!!!
You are lynch proof for a bit cuz it's your practice!!!!!!!
TTTH cuz the FAL!!!!!!!
I think it's fine to not lynch you d1!!!!!
I know this was only D1 but I found Paws behavior a bit weird. nothing like the warriors game I played with them.
 
Thankfully only 10 pages behind. Will post as I read through rather than posting after all of my analysis because only 3 hours until lynch close.
 
Top