More Women Than Men Enrolled in U.S. Medical Schools in 2017

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Texas124

New Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2018
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
I think this is the first time this has happened. However, more men did apply to medical school than women as always. But more women have actually been enrolled.

Edit: I have posted the link but not really sure when it’s not showing up.

Members don't see this ad.
 
Let's hope this imbalance doesn't worsen. Fields predominantly made up of women have traditionally enjoyed lower prestige in the eyes of the public. Teaching as an example used to be an almost exclusively male preserve and was very respected, now it's predominantly female and coincidentally or not, is seen as the refuge of people not good enough to hack it in the real world. Not saying it's right or wrong, it just is. Furthermore, men working in female dominated fields are usually looked at with raised eyebrows, consider male nurses or kindergarten teachers. I'd hate to end up as a "male doctor" 20 years from now if the gender ratio becomes too skewed.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Let's hope this imbalance doesn't worsen. Fields predominantly made up of women have traditionally enjoyed lower prestige in the eyes of the public. Teaching as an example used to be an almost exclusively male preserve and was very respected, now it's predominantly female and coincidentally or not, is seen as the refuge of people not good enough to hack it in the real world. Not saying it's right or wrong, it just is. Furthermore, men working in female dominated fields are usually looked at with raised eyebrows, consider male nurses or kindergarten teachers. I'd hate to end up as a "male doctor" 20 years from now if the gender ratio becomes too skewed.

WOW solid attempt
 
Let's hope this imbalance doesn't worsen. Fields predominantly made up of women have traditionally enjoyed lower prestige in the eyes of the public. Teaching as an example used to be an almost exclusively male preserve and was very respected, now it's predominantly female and coincidentally or not, is seen as the refuge of people not good enough to hack it in the real world. Not saying it's right or wrong, it just is. Furthermore, men working in female dominated fields are usually looked at with raised eyebrows, consider male nurses or kindergarten teachers. I'd hate to end up as a "male doctor" 20 years from now if the gender ratio becomes too skewed.

You're welcome to leave medical school now if you're that worried about being a female dominated field. 😵
 
Let's hope this imbalance doesn't worsen. Fields predominantly made up of women have traditionally enjoyed lower prestige in the eyes of the public. Teaching as an example used to be an almost exclusively male preserve and was very respected, now it's predominantly female and coincidentally or not, is seen as the refuge of people not good enough to hack it in the real world. Not saying it's right or wrong, it just is. Furthermore, men working in female dominated fields are usually looked at with raised eyebrows, consider male nurses or kindergarten teachers. I'd hate to end up as a "male doctor" 20 years from now if the gender ratio becomes too skewed.

The fact that more women are becoming doctors and challenging outdated and sexist status quo is a great thing. Maybe the fact that proportionally there aren't as many dudes matriculating as there are applying speaks to the fact that just maybe they're not med school caliber themselves, and their matriculating female counterparts are.

The declining popularity/competitiveness of the teaching field is because of the crappy funding for public schools and terrible pay for most teachers.

Edit: in response to the post below. Admittedly I got a little overzealous about my response. I can see not wanting to be viewed as an anomaly. But that's a society problem.
 
Last edited:
Are we seriously having this conversation in this day and age? The fact that more women are becoming doctors and challenging outdated and sexist status quo is a GREAT thing. Maybe the fact that proportionally there aren't as many dudes matriculating as there are applying speaks to the fact that just maybe they're not med school caliber themselves, and their matriculating female counterparts are.

And the teacher example you gave has nothing to do with women or prestige. It's a YOU and a society problem.


Yo listen, I'm already in med school, and closer to graduation than matriculation. Thus I couldn't care less if zero dudes got accepted to med school going forward as I don't feel any kind of "loyalty" to the 3.5 billion people who encompass the world's male population, a group that encompasses the spectrum from ISIS subhumans to US astronauts. However, I do care about my prestige and my $$$, both of which could be affected if medicine becomes as female dominated as nursing and low level teaching. Whether medicine should take such a hit in a "just society" just because it's more female is utterly irrelevant to me, only the likelihood that it will take such a hit matters. I leave the debate over the justice or injustice therein to the SJW losers.

Aside from that, as OrthoTraumaMD explained, as a man I'd rather be in a field associated with masculinity than femininity. When I talk to a chick, I'd like my occupation to have a closer association with "firefighter" or "lumberjack" than with "nurse" or "hair stylist."
 
Last edited:
Yo listen, I'm already in med school, and closer to graduation than matriculation. Thus I couldn't care less if zero dudes got accepted to med school going forward as I don't feel any kind of "loyalty" to the 3.5 billion people who encompass the world's male population, a group that encompasses the spectrum from ISIS subhumans to US astronauts. However, I do care about my prestige and my $$$, both of which could be affected if medicine becomes as female dominated as nursing and low level teaching. Whether medicine should take such a hit in a "just society" just because it's more female is utterly irrelevant to me, only the likelihood that it will take such a hit matters. I leave the debate over the justice or injustice therein to the SJW losers.

Aside from that, as OrthoTraumaMD explained, as a man I'd rather be in a field associated with masculinity than femininity. When I talk to a chick, I'd like my occupation to have a closer association with "firefighter" or "lumberjack" than with "nurse" or "hair stylist."

While data might argue that gender predominance shifts salaries within a field, I still don't think more females in the field 20 years from now will significantly hurt your doctor image or stop you from making enough $$$ in a lifetime. If we move to eliminate that kind of thought in society to begin with, you wouldn't even have to worry about that.

While Money's attitude is also less than pleasant to me...he's actually not wrong re: declining salaries. Interestingly, there are multiple examples of salaries changing as fields shifted gender predominance. Teaching salaries declined as women started teaching in higher numbers, computer science salaries increased as more men started working in the field, OBGYN salaries have dropped as women have become the majority. But yeah, seems like the more appropriate response would be to move towards eliminating gender bias rather than to just avoid career fields you genuinely enjoy because people might perceive you as being too girly. 🙄

Well said. That data is unfortunate but true. And I took issue with his intention mostly, I just personally would like to think doctors went into their fields because they love it, not because they wanna look manly or impressive haha
 
Doctors historically have not made a lot of money because of male dominance.

Now let’s ensue the 5 page long sheitstorm about the myth of the sex wage gap before this gets dumped to spf to die...
 
Wow. 1 year where female matriculates slightly exceed males in the entire history of medical education and people lose their ****. Let's use our critical thinking here.

First: Currently only 34% of US physicians are female. There is no state where females make up 50% of the physician workforce (DC is closest, and incidentally has one of the highest average generalist incomes in the country). (1, 2) This disparity is because of:

upload_2018-8-17_10-48-10.png

Source

Medical schools as a whole only became 50:50 in 2006. Even if every year since '06 were perfectly 50:50, medicine as a field wouldn't reach parity until all the physicians that matriculated prior to '06 retired. This is assuming that attrition rates between male and female physicians entering since '06 are equal, which they're likely not. It's going to be a long time before gender parity is reached in medical practitioners, and if that prospect is too scary for some then there are plenty of male-dominated specialties.

If anyone is worried about hits to salary and prestige due to female participation, I might suggest advocating for equal pay and respect for women.
 

Attachments

  • upload_2018-8-17_10-47-48.png
    upload_2018-8-17_10-47-48.png
    37.5 KB · Views: 96
Members don't see this ad :)
Calm down, trigglypuffs.
All he’s saying is that he doesn’t want to be viewed as a weird anomaly. All people have a natural drive to “fit in” and he’s expressing it.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
He also wrote:
Fields predominantly made up of women have traditionally enjoyed lower prestige in the eyes of the public.
However, I do care about my prestige and my $$$,


If one is going into Medicine for prestige, I suggest that they stop now and get out.
 
I have no issue with this unless affirmative action played a role.

Affirmative action needs to go and die in a fire.
 
I have no issue with this unless affirmative action played a role.

Affirmative action needs to go and die in a fire.
doubt it was affirmative action tbh. It's just mimicking what is occurring in undergraduate institutions as well as high schools. I personally think this is a more broader issue with lack of male role models now, especially during youth.

Most boys don't see men in a role of power in school unless they hit university. I can count the number of male teachers I had growing up. Not to mention I think a bigger issue is how do we tackle this when it comes to black men.

AAMC even talked about this since it seems like black men are the only demographic cross-section that actually is decreasing in attendance into medical school

(Product Detail)
 
He also wrote:
Fields predominantly made up of women have traditionally enjoyed lower prestige in the eyes of the public.
However, I do care about my prestige and my $$$,


If one is going into Medicine for prestige, I suggest that they stop now and get out.

Lol, yep.

Med students, your future boss will be a nurse or respiratory therapist or somebody else with a community college degree. If they don’t like you, they can get you fired. Seen it happen multiple times already.

The respect from midlevels and nurses is not there. Maybe it was before, but it sure as hell is not now.
 
Lol, yep.

Med students, your future boss will be a nurse or respiratory therapist or somebody else with a community college degree. If they don’t like you, they can get you fired. Seen it happen multiple times already.

The respect from midlevels and nurses is not there. Maybe it was before, but it sure as hell is not now.
Scary times out here.
 
doubt it was affirmative action tbh. It's just mimicking what is occurring in undergraduate institutions as well as high schools. I personally think this is a more broader issue with lack of male role models now, especially during youth.

Most boys don't see men in a role of power in school unless they hit university. I can count the number of male teachers I had growing up. Not to mention I think a bigger issue is how do we tackle this when it comes to black men.

AAMC even talked about this since it seems like black men are the only demographic cross-section that actually is decreasing in attendance into medical school

(Product Detail)
Men dominate power roles at most levels of society and even if one’s immediate environment growing up is not filled with men, abundant media certainly shows another story. And if these role models appear in uniervsity as you say, then aren’t all men medical school applicants sufficiently socialized since they all have to have attended university?
 
Men dominate power roles at most levels of society and even if one’s immediate environment growing up is not filled with men, abundant media certainly shows another story. And if these role models appear in uniervsity as you say, then aren’t all men medical school applicants sufficiently socialized since they all have to have attended university?
All I am saying is during schooling most of your superiors (teachers) are women in today's era. So some men without male role models at home don't have any exposure to dominate male roles models which is why most men probably do not enter college that much. The opportunity cost is way too high and it is not seen as "manly" anymore compared to a trade.
 
All I am saying is during schooling most of your superiors (teachers) are women in today's era. So some men without male role models at home don't have any exposure to dominate male roles models which is why most men probably do not enter college that much. The opportunity cost is way too high and it is not seen as "manly" anymore compared to a trade.

Is this a Jordan Peterson thing?
 
I have no issue with this unless affirmative action played a role.

Affirmative action needs to go and die in a fire.
Shhhh! SPF is that way ->; we don't want to venture there.

But I agree that an n=1 is no reason to start clutching pearls. I remember back in the mid 2000s that the trend at the time was more women getting accepted, which people predicted to a massively female clinician workforce by mid century.

That trend did NOT hold.
 
Women have been graduating high school, attending college, and graduating from college at higher rates then men.
It makes sense that they're starting to gain more representation in grad programs like med school.

Does this mean schools should start reaching out for male applicants, maybe start some STEM pipeline programs for male undergrads to strengthen their applications?
At a certain point, social engineering starts to break down and get silly.

On the GME level, I think we already have female predominance in fields like peds and obgyn, and I haven't heard anyone calling for gender parity.
On my rotations, as a guy I have definitely felt out of place on rotations where I was with only female residents, when the conversation shifts to gendered topics (I'm sure women may also feel uncomfortable with a bunch of male residents who talk about stereotypical guy stuff all the time). And when it comes to mentors, there's a big difference between talking to a male mentor vs a female one. Imagine if every field of medicine were like that. It'd be what women have experienced in med school and residency for the last 50 years. Does anyone want guys to experience the same thing?

As far as income goes, women do tend to make less than men, and it's not clear how much of that is due to a difference in hours worked (women tending to work fewer hours on average) or differences in income per hour (because of pay discrimination, or because women don't negotiate the same, or because their negotiations take a back seat to their partners', or because their RVUs are different, I don't know). So having more women in a field doesn't necessarily mean a male doctor's income will go down, unless it's a pure salary model maybe.
 
On the GME level, I think we already have female predominance in fields like peds and obgyn, and I haven't heard anyone calling for gender parity.
On my rotations, as a guy I have definitely felt out of place on rotations where I was with only female residents, when the conversation shifts to gendered topics (I'm sure women may also feel uncomfortable with a bunch of male residents who talk about stereotypical guy stuff all the time). And when it comes to mentors, there's a big difference between talking to a male mentor vs a female one. Imagine if every field of medicine were like that. It'd be what women have experienced in med school and residency for the last 50 years. Does anyone want guys to experience the same thing?

Male doctors are disappearing from gynecology. Not everybody is thrilled about it
 
Women do have equal pay. Wage discrimination is illegal in the US. The wage gap is a myth peddled by people with an agenda, and has been disproven by every serious economist who has ever examined it (look up the Forbes article detailing the work of Claudia Goldin, a Harvard economist). There is an “earnings” gap where a woman will earn less overall during her work lifetime than a man, but it doesn’t factor in hours worked, taking time off for family, etc. Once those things are factored in, the “gap” decreases to 1-3 cents to the dollar, rather than the much touted 15 cents.

As for respect in the workplace, there is no proof women get any less respect than men, provided they have the same skill set. A male obgyn is routinely, in fact, treated worse than a female, multiple articles about that, because patients can discriminate against male obgyns. The myriad programs geared toward women (pick any stem field for example) that actively exclude men indicate that we, as a society, have been actually using our resources for the direct benefit of women. If “putting your money where your mouth is” isn’t a sign of respect, then I don’t know what is.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
My wife and I both do outpatient PCP work (I'm FM, she's IM). Our salaries are literally identical - both guarantee and then how they calculate productivity.
 
Calm down, trigglypuffs.
All he’s saying is that he doesn’t want to be viewed as a weird anomaly. All people have a natural drive to “fit in” and he’s expressing it.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Funny, I thought he was saying that it would suck for his career to become considered a predominantly-female job, because then he'd be affected by our society's sexism and face some of the biases that women face in the workplace. Which, he's absolutely correct about. But please excuse me if my heart doesn't quite bleed for him and all other dudes who get sideswiped by the semi truck as it barrels down the road trying to T-bone us.
 
Funny, I thought he was saying that it would suck for his career to become considered a predominantly-female job, because then he'd be affected by our society's sexism and face some of the biases that women face in the workplace. Which, he's absolutely correct about. But please excuse me if my heart doesn't quite bleed for him and all other dudes who get sideswiped by the semi truck as it barrels down the road trying to T-bone us.
Or maybe he's worried about, as OrthoTrauma pointed out, the problems facing male OB/GYNs but expanding to other fields
 
Or maybe he's worried about, as OrthoTrauma pointed out, the problems facing male OB/GYNs but expanding to other fields
Yah you're right, let's twist what was said until it sounds better, and not take the poster at face value when they literally give examples of what they're concerned about (nurses, teachers, etc).

Look, as I said, I don't blame the dude. I wouldn't want to be discriminated against either, and I'll be sad if doctors as a whole start to make less money because sexism is a thing. Nothing they said makes them a bad person or anything even close to that. I just personally am not going to get super worked up about the collateral damage said sexism may cause rather than the actual sexism itself.

If your reaction to the statement "when more women enter a field, salaries and respect for the field go down" (which is a paraphrase of what the poster himself actually said) is "wow, I hope women stay away from my field" rather than "wow, how do we fix the problem where women's work is valued less by our society," I'm not that sympathetic to your plight because you're not acting very sympathetic to theirs.
 
The funny thing is most women will request a female gyn. Not only that but during rotations male medical students are usually sent away. Honestly, the way I see it, if that is what gyn wants, let them have it. If any issues arise let them find out if male diversity is needed, if the field is fine without a decent portion of men then let it be that way. It's all about making that patient population comfortable. Personally I would never want to be involved in a specialty that doesn't enthusiastically want me to practice in it.
 
Yah you're right, let's twist what was said until it sounds better, and not take the poster at face value when they literally give examples of what they're concerned about (nurses, teachers, etc).

Look, as I said, I don't blame the dude. I wouldn't want to be discriminated against either, and I'll be sad if doctors as a whole start to make less money because sexism is a thing. Nothing they said makes them a bad person or anything even close to that. I just personally am not going to get super worked up about the collateral damage said sexism may cause rather than the actual sexism itself.

If your reaction to the statement "when more women enter a field, salaries and respect for the field go down" (which is a paraphrase of what the poster himself actually said) is "wow, I hope women stay away from my field" rather than "wow, how do we fix the problem where women's work is valued less by our society," I'm not that sympathetic to your plight because you're not acting very sympathetic to theirs.
You mean like how he said that now a days if men go into teaching or nursing it's assumed there is something wrong with them?
 
You mean like how he said that now a days if men go into teaching or nursing it's assumed there is something wrong with them?
Yes, literally that. I am more annoyed that "women's work" is seen as lesser (but we are expected to stick to those roles) than I am that some guys who do "womens' work" are looked down upon for choosing such a 'lesser' field. I'm more annoyed that if I were to do such work, it would be seen as normal, but a guy is considered to be 'settling' for doing it. I'm glad we're on the same page now, because yes those are EXACTLY the examples I was thinking of from his post that support my point!
 
Yes, literally that. I am more annoyed that "women's work" is seen as lesser (but we are expected to stick to those roles) than I am that some guys who do "womens' work" are looked down upon for choosing such a 'lesser' field. I'm more annoyed that if I were to do such work, it would be seen as normal, but a guy is considered to be 'settling' for doing it. I'm glad we're on the same page now, because yes those are EXACTLY the examples I was thinking of from his post that support my point!
I don't think you quite get how men are viewed if they go into those fields.

Male teachers are often assumed to be pedophiles. They aren't judged for "settling" for a woman's job, they're judged for doing a job involving children.

Male nurses aren't judged for settling either. It's often assumed they're gay.
 
The funny thing is most women will request a female gyn. Not only that but during rotations male medical students are usually sent away. Honestly, the way I see it, if that is what gyn wants, let them have it. If any issues arise let them find out if male diversity is needed, if the field is fine without a decent portion of men then let it be that way. It's all about making that patient population comfortable. Personally I would never want to be involved in a specialty that doesn't enthusiastically want me to practice in it.

As a male OB/GYN resident, I have to disagree. What most patients want first and foremost is a competent Dr who they are comfortable with. And sometimes they associate the male gender with a level of uncomfortableness. It’s actually not very common that I am asked to leave a room due to my gender.

If you don’t want to be involved in the specialty that has preferences that’s also your preference. However the field is wide open to good doctors of both sexes who will have a full schedule of patients who want to see them.

And an additional point not related to the comment above, affirmative action is missed-named and a damage to the good that is attempting to do. When the intention of the initiative is to bring equality into the room, but by doing so gives people of lesser qualifications a distinct advantage, taking that from others who have stronger merits, we have done our society a disservice.

The SDN Lizzy M score will show you the average GPA and MCAT needed to get acceptance to certain tiers of medical school. Someone with any certain set of numbers would have a far higher chance of getting accepted into medical school if they were African-American vs being white, but would still better off with those numbers than a person of Asian descent. If you’re going to call it affirmative action, then race nor gender should not play a part in this role, but simply the best students who best fit the initiative of the school should be considered.
 
Last edited:
As a man OB/GYN resident, I have to disagree. What most patients wants first and foremost is a competent Dr who they are comfortable with. And sometimes they associate the male gender with a level of uncomfortableness. It’s actually not very common that I am asked to leave a room due to my gender.
That is not universal. When I was in residency, the OB group that we worked with hired a new male OB. This was actually the 5th job he'd applied to. The previous 4 all said they wanted a female physician.

The other group in town had 3 female and 3 male physicians. The male doctors could get new patients in within 2-3 days. The female doctors had new patient appointments scheduling out 6-8 weeks.

We had the same problem when my wife was pregnant (different city). The group closest to us had 2 male and 3 female OBs. New patient OB was 1 week with the men, 3-4 weeks with the women.
 
That is not universal. When I was in residency, the OB group that we worked with hired a new male OB. This was actually the 5th job he'd applied to. The previous 4 all said they wanted a female physician.

The other group in town had 3 female and 3 male physicians. The male doctors could get new patients in within 2-3 days. The female doctors had new patient appointments scheduling out 6-8 weeks.

We had the same problem when my wife was pregnant (different city). The group closest to us had 2 male and 3 female OBs. New patient OB was 1 week with the men, 3-4 weeks with the women.
And of the dozens of males that I’ve met and worked with in this field not one has expressed that issue to me, and I know several of them are very high in demand, even more so than the female counterparts. Geography and location can certainly play a role, and small sample sizes are not very helpful in creating the argument either way.

Even though 80% of current residents are female, roughly 70% of current attendings are male. I think evidence shows there’s excellent opportunity for a male to pursue OB/GYN as a career
 
Last edited:
And of the dozens of males that I’ve met and worked with in this field Not one has expressed that issue to me, and I know several of them are very high in demand, even more so than the female counterparts. Geography and location can certainly play a role, and small sample sizes are not very helpful in creating the argument either way.

Even though 80% of current residence or female, roughly 70% of current attending’s are male. I think evidence shows there’s Excellent opportunity for a male Topursue OB/GYN as a career
Gee, might the gender make up of attendings be representative of the gender make up of med school in the past?

And my argument was merely that your experience isn't universal, which it isn't.
 
Let's hope this imbalance doesn't worsen. Fields predominantly made up of women have traditionally enjoyed lower prestige in the eyes of the public. Teaching as an example used to be an almost exclusively male preserve and was very respected, now it's predominantly female and coincidentally or not, is seen as the refuge of people not good enough to hack it in the real world. Not saying it's right or wrong, it just is. Furthermore, men working in female dominated fields are usually looked at with raised eyebrows, consider male nurses or kindergarten teachers. I'd hate to end up as a "male doctor" 20 years from now if the gender ratio becomes too skewed.


This, exactly. Well said. There’s also an interesting trend of orthopedic surgery continuously receiving (somewhat) sufficient reimbursements and respect compared to other fields for their services
 
I don't think you quite get how men are viewed if they go into those fields.

Male teachers are often assumed to be pedophiles. They aren't judged for "settling" for a woman's job, they're judged for doing a job involving children.

Male nurses aren't judged for settling either. It's often assumed they're gay.
I do get it. But where does it come from? It ultimately stems from the idea that there is no reason a man would choose 'womens work' unless there were an underlying motive/flaw.
 
I do get it. But where does it come from? It ultimately stems from the idea that there is no reason a man would choose 'womens work' unless there were an underlying motive/flaw.
I think that sometimes that's true (nursing) and sometimes its not (teaching).
 
This, exactly. Well said. There’s also an interesting trend of orthopedic surgery continuously receiving (somewhat) sufficient reimbursements and respect compared to other fields for their services

That trend has nothing to do with gender. It is because we use more implants than any other field, plus a crapton of ancillary services like PT, and it makes a ton of money for the hospital. Thus, they can afford to pay us a lot.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
That trend has nothing to do with gender. It is because we use more implants than any other field, plus a crapton of ancillary services like PT, and it makes a ton of money for the hospital. Thus, they can afford to pay us a lot.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
I love that y'all only "somewhat" receive sufficient reimbursement apparently
 
Gee, might the gender make up of attendings be representative of the gender make up of med school in the past?

And my argument was merely that your experience isn't universal, which it isn't.
You might think, but dig up numbers on current attendings on for example surgeons, urologists, plastic surgeons - any surgical specialty for that matter, and you'll find the percentage of males outweighs females in those fields in larger proportions than the class ratios of Males/Females for those graduating classes, with the exception of OBGYN. Males even in those years had traditionally gone into OBGYN in less than average proportions than female counterparts graduating.

My experience might not be universal, but I am a resident in the field, have a large number of colleagues who are male as well and believe the data supports a open field for men to have excellent careers in OBGYN on average rivaling or surpassing those of female colleagues in the same field. Your argument from a wifes/friends/associates experience is not exactly a solid case study either, which is why I brought in good data.
 
That trend has nothing to do with gender. It is because we use more implants than any other field, plus a crapton of ancillary services like PT, and it makes a ton of money for the hospital. Thus, they can afford to pay us a lot.


That’s not the point of my post...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top