The crux of the issue that I'm hung up on right now is that I usually feel like Vis has a tonal difference that I can pick up on when she's village vs wolf, and I'm not sure that I'm really getting that here one way or the other. I went back and looked at Choose Your Own II, which might be the last game I played with village!Vis, to see what kinds of things I'd said about her in the ISO I did there. The main thing that I kept coming back to, that ultimately pushed her villagey for me, was that I felt like she was making a fair amount of arguments that were stretchy, and they were on points that were weak enough that I couldn't see a wolf choosing to do that - it felt more like a villager going after something.
In Casino, which is the most recent wolf game I played with her, there was somewhat of a tonal difference that I'm not sure how to articulate, and her pushes were a little different. She's historically been less stretchy as a wolf, and that's where I'm getting a little hung up trying to decide how I feel about her in this game - because I have felt like some of her posts have been stretchy (particularly some of her ones about Cray), but it's not as in-your-face as village!Vis was in CYO II. But I'm wavering on whether I feel like there's enough to push me to voting her.