i'm currently a second year at nymc... whether you'll like the school or not is really a matter of personal taste. but the pros and cons, in my opinion:
cons:
the campus is in the middle of nowhere, and you basically need a car to get around and go grocery shopping, go out to eat, etc (unless you want to depend on a fellow student).
it isn't very diverse ethnically.
they work you EXTREMELY hard at this school. i've heard several people from other new york med schools say that nymc has the reputation for being the most competitive med school in new york. i think the reason for this is that since the school doesn't have a great name (like an ivy), they work us hard so we do really well on the boards and can get the residency we want. so this could be a pro or a con, depending on how you look at it. i've heard of students at other schools actually having lives and not being so stressed, like we are here. but you do learn a lot.
pros:
you're only about a 20-30 minute drive away from manhattan, which is really nice.
there aren't any distractions, because you're NOT in the city.
you have a close-knit class, because the environment is so isolated.
you can do your rotations (3rd and 4th years) in manhattan. i think this is the biggest pro... nymc has a lot of affiliated hospitals in the city.
i think that's about it. feel free to email me if you have any other questions.
amy