OK -- opposite situation: I agreed to precept an NP student this summer. Slightly annoyed because she uses my first name in all her emails to me.
Tighten that *** up. Dress her down full metal jacket style.
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
OK -- opposite situation: I agreed to precept an NP student this summer. Slightly annoyed because she uses my first name in all her emails to me.
OK -- opposite situation: I agreed to precept an NP student this summer. Slightly annoyed because she uses my first name in all her emails to me.
on several accounts there.OK -- opposite situation: I agreed to precept an NP student this summer. Slightly annoyed because she uses my first name in all her emails to me.
OK -- opposite situation: I agreed to precept an NP student this summer. Slightly annoyed because she uses my first name in all her emails to me.
Just tell her that's not appropriate. Otherwise she's going to show up and call you "Kim" in front of your patients.
EDIT - On a related note, why exactly does an NP need to be precepted by a subspecialty surgeon?
Tighten that *** up. Dress her down full metal jacket style.
on several accounts there.
Slightly annoyed? At the beginning of the year I could barely call the peds residents by their first name even after they told me multiple times not to. I would never call an attending by their first name, can't even do last name only without the title like many of the residents do.
Thought nps were trying to do primary care in rural areas, what would they be doing with a breast surgeon in an urban area
crush that, who the hell addresses a boss by their first name unless they are told to do so?
I think it's a nursing culture thing, to call everyone by their first name, despite the culture of abuse. Which is why heirarchies are so foreign and think they don't apply to them.
But isn't it your job as a traveler in a foreign land to learn the culture?I think it's a nursing culture thing, to call everyone by their first name, despite the culture of abuse. Which is why heirarchies are so foreign and think they don't apply to them.
But isn't it your job as a traveler in a foreign land to learn the culture?
That being said, I'll bet she calls her physician employer by his first name.
Apparently so did your MD preceptor. If he wasn't there, why did he put you with the NP, especially knowing that she wasn't up to even NP standard? Why weren't you just given those days off? If there hadn't been an NP, would they have put you with the CNA and had then teach you pathophysiology?
The problem here is not the NP. It is the MD.
I don't think it's a business decision when this person is treating patients on her own while the physician is away without consultation, especially while the physician knows how incompetent she is. That's an issue of public safety, isn't it?In my mind, whether or not the NP is employed there is immaterial. That's a business decision, and there are a lot of factors that affect it. Even a "not very good" employee can fill a need.
But placing a student under the care of said NP is entirely inappropriate.
I mean, if you don't need to have a decent understanding of basic science to practice safely, why do we spend so much time learning it and getting tested on it? She didn't understand very fundamental things - I'd say that was a red flag and I wouldn't be too confident in her ability to properly diagnose and treat people.But it's not your business right? We have no idea whether this NP is good or bad at their job. We have no idea if they are capable of practicing safely. Any comments on that are simply supposition. But the poor teaching and poor understanding of basic science are very well described, and the MD was wrong for leaving this person to teach for them.
I agree. If the school can't find enough MDs to teach students, they shouldn't be taking on that many students. It doesn't matter how much you can learn from everyone else.You can learn a lot from the CT tech or the EKG tech or the dialysis nurse or the dietician. That doesn't mean they should be your supervisors in medical school.
Any medical school which makes you shadow NPs is doing you a disservice.
This how we blur the lines between nurses and doctors (by calling them providers)
Funnily, these lines are very real in court and malpractice litigation...where the MD has vicarious liability
But here in my state, they practice independently and see patients and diagnose/treat them. So how is that different from what an MD does? How is it that one needs to know basic science well and the other doesn't - to do essentially the same job safely? It sounds like that's what you're saying.Because NPs are not MDs, which was kind of my point in this thread from the outset.
Apparently some never read about Blalock and Vivien Theodore Thomas, a black surgical research tech pioneer who basically showed Blalock and Taussig how to get it down.
Thomas was given the job of first creating a cyanotic condition in a dog, and then correcting the condition by means of the pulmonary-to-subclavian anastomosis. He did much work on perfecting this, and he even was needed to assist, b/c Blalock didn't have the same level of skill on this as what Thomas had developed over time. Soon the Blalock–Taussig shunt came to be, but of course Vivien Thomas received no real credit for it.
During an atrial septectomy, the procedure was said to have been executed so flawlessly by Thomas that Blalock, upon examining the nearly undetectable suture line, was prompted to remark, "Vivien, this looks like something the Lord made."
Point is, sure, the evals should come from the right people; but forget it if you can't learn from someone else b/c of station. That's way sad. Mimelim is right on point. Holy cow.
Who said anything about not learning from other people. How about patients. Many of mine are homeless and smell funny. I still learn from them. So what. We're talking about training. These are different types of learning.
I know it rubs your Nightengale training the wrong way to not be thought of as playing a role in shaping the minds of the residents who rotate through but that's just what's up. You show them how to do aspects of the job but you don't refine their clinical skills in the way that an attending will model for them. Sorry. There is actually a chain of transmission.
As for your snarky example, that surgical tech should've and perhaps would've been a surgeon himself if Jim Crow wasn't as powerful as he was during that time. This does not mean we should be trained by nurses. After all, by their own confusing dogma, the don't practice medicine they practice advanced nursing, whatever that is.
A. Snarky is your spin. Never had that in mind. Honestly I am totally beginning to think you project a lot when it comes to me and how YOU THINK I THINK. 🙂
B. Semantics: learning versus training.
C. I really don't care so much about such ego-based crap; b/c in truth and sincerity, I am there for the patients and families, first. I couldn't care less who choses to listen or learn from me one way or another, so long as the patient does well, and we get him, her, them what they need. The ego-crap is something with which your really young, NY, chippy RNs had an issue. Where I have worked, it's about the patient. So who cares whose idea you make it sound like or who gets the credit? Our satisfaction is in knowing the patient is stable and is getting what he or she needs and can move forward.
D. I can only imagine what terrible situations and nurses with which you had to work in NY. I am very sorry it left such a negative taste in your mouth and some kind of long-lasting ecchymosis. But your mass hatred is based on a generalization.
Vivien didn't get ahead and get to go to medical school not just b/c of Jim Crow; but b/c of the push to keep him in the research, b/c Blalock KNEW he needed him. It was as much about self-interest as anything, and Vivien had already committed so much to the work.
Your sad interpretation of snarky example is quite unfortunate--but seriously, you injected that on to the example.
I call total projection on you, especially with the use of the word snarky. That is so completely your deal. And You really aren't all that old but you seem like a crotchety old man already. Wow and sad.
Learning and training--semantics. I already stated that formal evals should come from the most appropriate people. That has nothing to do with being open and able to learn from everyone--and yes--including your patients and families.
I wish you would stop this negative reading into stuff with me. It's starting to become a bit annoying, and in fact it has always been unnecessary. Get over it already. Your issue. Your problem.
Well. I have no idea what you're talking about but I think it's pretty obvious that they're are different types of learning. I speak from experience that one on one with attendings has been the most enriching clinical experience I've had. It happens with more frequency now that I'm a resident and many of our teams are 1 attending 1 resident outfits but I still think it's important for medical students to have physician lead teams as the source of training.
I still learn when my attending isn't around. And the sources are as wide as the scope of my perception. But what makes up the attending/resident relationship is the real heart and blood of physician training. And that's anything but just semantic differences from picking up things from other sources.
I project my thoughts onto you. Hoping that you'll get it someday.
"As you know, projection is a defense mechanism that involves taking our own unacceptable qualities or feelings and ascribing them to other people." (Snarky--You-->on to me) "For example, if you have a strong dislike for someone, you might instead believe that he or she does not like you. Projection works by allowing the expression of the desire or impulse, but in a way that the ego cannot recognize, therefore reducing anxiety."--Kendra Cherry
You label my comment snarky, and that is your very MO.
Hmmm, how do you know that indeed you don't have a thing or two to "get?" As I am sure it is true for me, I think it also continues with you.
"...one on one with attendings has been the most enriching clinical experience I've had."
Well, provided the person is effective in this role, I have no doubt it is true. By all means; it should be the mainstay of a MS/resident's clinical education. Never said otherwise.
That's far different from getting a freaky attitude how learning from a PA, NP, Nurse, RRT, whomever. There is this sick kind of pride that wells up in some folks in healthcare. It's like this entitlement perk or something. In reality it has nothing to do with the job or learning or helping, period.
But, as you like it. I respect @mimelim's perspectives here. Every time I read his perspectives, I find they are quite logical and on target.
So can we just skip the extra school and do it their way? It would save us a lot of time and money.
I mean, if you don't need to have a decent understanding of basic science to practice safely, why do we spend so much time learning it and getting tested on it? She didn't understand very fundamental things - I'd say that was a red flag and I wouldn't be too confident in her ability to properly diagnose and treat people.
Apparently some never read about Blalock and Vivien Theodore Thomas, a black surgical research tech pioneer who basically showed Blalock and Taussig how to get it down.
Thomas was given the job of first creating a cyanotic condition in a dog, and then correcting the condition by means of the pulmonary-to-subclavian anastomosis. He did much work on perfecting this, and he even was needed to assist, b/c Blalock didn't have the same level of skill on this as what Thomas had developed over time. Soon the Blalock–Taussig shunt came to be, but of course Vivien Thomas received no real credit for it.
During an atrial septectomy, the procedure was said to have been executed so flawlessly by Thomas that Blalock, upon examining the nearly undetectable suture line, was prompted to remark, "Vivien, this looks like something the Lord made."
Point is, sure, the evals should come from the right people; but forget it if you can't learn from someone else b/c of station. That's way sad. Mimelim is right on point. Holy cow.
I'm glad you have an sdn'er to love. Admit it though, this could be about the proper way to season mashed potatoes and you and I would be like Coyote and Roadrunner still.
Let's leave these people to their thread topic. I concede to an arrogant, self-involved, entitled, prideful, egomaniacal defeat.
If experience is all it takes and practicing MDs forget their basic science knowledge anyway, I would really love to skip med school (at least the first two years) and just get to work. I feel robbed.We get it, you don't know anything about NPs and hate them. You can learn a lot from people that have a tremendous amount of experience but lack 'basic science background' that the vast majority of practicing MDs have long forgotten. If you can't understand that concept, you are in for a rude awakening in the real world where experience counts for a lot at all levels. This seems to be your fundamental problem, other than the blind, "NPs are bad!" you don't understand that just because they aren't doing exactly what you will be doing in the future, doesn't mean that they don't have something to offer.
The only person making sweeping generalizations here is you. Nobody is arguing that NPs should be in full charge of a medical student's education. Nobody is arguing that NPs should step outside of the scope of their education or experience. Yes, any practitioner working outside of their area and hurting patients should be stopped. But, the number of MD violations of this is just as bad as any mid-level profession. It is a systemic problem.
I was responding to someone else, not you.Then go do that. But for the love of God, stop posting the same thing over and over again.
This is about the 87 millionth time you've gotten stuck on this comparison between MD and NP education.
We have a different training pathway.
Whether or not state laws allow NPs to practice independently says nothing about the capacity of an MD graduate to do the same.
We know. I'm not even really sure why someone who has said they hate every step along the path and wishes they'd quit, and didn't even apply for residency (or was that just false bluster?), feels so strongly on this issue.
I agree with you. People were up in arms in SDN when Missouri passed the law that will give MD graduates a license to become PCP with the title "assistant physician' after 1-year of 'clinical preceptorship' . They said that will 'degrade' the MD title. Guess what! This title is just a title now. People with a lot less education are practicing medicine...I was responding to someone else, not you.
Also, I would love to do that but the laws don't allow it. Hopefully they'll change because our licensing laws are kind of a joke right now. They're going in the direction of letting just about anyone practice medicine, but still maintaining a high standard for MDs, which makes no sense.
I don't want to get into this argument with you again, but I think you're dead wrong. It doesn't matter what your training pathway is, you need to have a certain amount of knowledge/experience to safely practice medicine independently, and you can't discriminate between training pathways. Doesn't make sense to have two different standards of safety. That's like saying one group of pilots who trained in System A only require 1000 hours of flight experience to safely fly on their own, whereas another group of pilots who trained in system B can't fly until they have 10000, although they're flying the same exact plane. Doesn't make a lot of sense, does it?
Anyway that's all I have to say on that. It's been beaten to death.
Even an NP who is capable of teaching their limited area of expertise is not qualified to assess a student's professional growth and progression. I have learned much from mid-levels, but they should never serve as a primary preceptor judging your overall performance.
Using the excuse that "other options were poor" is unacceptable. If the options are that poor, the rotation should not exist.
NP might be right when they say physicians are overeducated.😛
My cousin who is an internist told me he will never hire a midlevel even if mid levels would have increased his salary to at least 100k/year... He 'precepted' NPs when he was a hospitalist and he said it was scary.Propaganda if there ever was.
How did we ever get to a place in this country when the discussion is about how "over educated" physicians are for "simple" things like primary care.
Primary care is so vast, so complicated, so layered, that the fact that a common rhetoric these days involves us having too much training is just plain ridiculous.
My cousin who is an internist told me he will never hire a midlevel even if mid levels would have increased his salary to at least 100k/year... He 'precepted' NPs when he was a hospitalist and he said it was scary.
I happen to think PA is legit and NP is a joke...
My cousin who is an internist told me he will never hire a midlevel even if mid levels would have increased his salary to at least 100k/year... He 'precepted' NPs when he was a hospitalist and he said it was scary.
I happen to think PA is legit and NP is a joke...
But isn't it your job as a traveler in a foreign land to learn the culture?
That being said, I'll bet she calls her physician employer by his first name.
Yup had an RN as a preceptor on surgery. Im sure the thread has gone down in SDN history. Ahh well, ended up fine.
Doctors should be trained by doctors. It's really that simple.
I would not use the word 'competent' for most NP. They probably learn to follow algorithm. PA is legit though!
Our mission is to provide students with free, unbiased information, resources, and advising for careers in the health professions. We believe every student deserves access to trustworthy guidance, regardless of background or ability to pay.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.