• SDN Site Updates

    Hey everyone! The site will be down for approximately 2 hours on Thursday, August 5th for site updates.

  • How To ACE Your Medical School Interview

    In this webinar hosted by SDN with experts from BeMo Academic Consulting, you will learn a simple five-step process to help you translate your interview invitation into an acceptance.

busupshot83

S.D.N. Vet
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Mar 23, 2003
2,247
3
37
Texas
Status (Visible)
Kaplan refers to one method for determining the nucleophilicity of a molecule, and Barron's Organic Review says another:

Kaplan
1) if attacking atom is the same, then nucleophilicity depends on basicity.
2) if attacking atom differs, and reaction occurs in protic solvent, then nucleophilicity depends on molecule size.
3) if attacking atom differs, and reaction occurs in aprotic solvent, then nucleophilicity depends on basicity.

Barron's Organic Chemistry Review Series
1) when molecules have the same central atom, a charge increases nucleophilicity.
2) larger molecules have greater nucleophilicity.
3) strong bases are more nucleophilic than weak bases.
4) steric effects decrease nucleophilicity.

I'm confused on what I should know for determining the nucleophilicity of a molecule. Is Kaplan or Barron's explanation better?
 

RING12

Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Aug 13, 2006
207
0
Status (Visible)
  1. Pre-Dental
Kaplan refers to one method for determining the nucleophilicity of a molecule, and Barron's says another:

Kaplan
1) if attacking atom is the same, then nucleophilicity depends on basicity.
2) if attacking atom differs, and reaction occurs in protic solvent, then nucleophilicity depends on molecule size.
3) if attacking atom differs, and reaction occurs in aprotic solvent, then nucleophilicity depends on basicity.

Barron's
1) when molecules have the same central atom, a charge increases nucleophilicity.
2) larger molecules have greater nucleophilicity.
3) strong bases are more nucleophilic than weak bases.

I'm confused on what I should know for determining the nucleophilicity of a molecule. Is Kaplan or Barron's explanation better?


do not study form barron's/ that book it;s just good for pat.for nuclophile you should look some thing like OH every thing that has negative charge is a nuclophile.

go to this page i think it would help you.

http://www.chem.ucalgary.ca/courses/351/Carey5th/Ch08/ch8-0.html
 

busupshot83

S.D.N. Vet
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Mar 23, 2003
2,247
3
37
Texas
Status (Visible)
do not study form barron's/ that book it;s just good for pat.for nuclophile you should look some thing like OH every thing that has negative charge is a nuclophile.

go to this page i think it would help you.

http://www.chem.ucalgary.ca/courses/351/Carey5th/Ch08/ch8-0.html

I don't know if this makes a difference, but it's not the Barron's DAT book... it is Barron's Organic Chemistry Review Series.

The site that you gave me is good.
 

busupshot83

S.D.N. Vet
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Mar 23, 2003
2,247
3
37
Texas
Status (Visible)
Ok, I've compiled what I learned based on Kaplan, Barron's Orgo, and that web site.

Nucleophilicity Rules:
1) when molecules have the same central atom, negative charges increase nucleophilicity:
CH3O- > CH3OH (C is central atom)
Me3P < Me2P- (P is central atom)

2) in atoms with the same attacking atom, nucleophilicity increases with basicity (basicity increases as you move to the left on the periodic table)

3) in atoms with different attacking atoms, and occurring in protic solvents, nucleophilicity increases with atomic size (size increases as you move to the left and bottom of the periodic table):
I- > Br- > Cl-

4) in atoms with different attacking atoms, and occurring in aprotic solvents, nucleophility increases with basicity (as in #2).

5) Nucleophilicity increases with less steric effects (steric effects decrease with more accessibility to the attacking atom)

Is this pretty accurate? Let me know.
 
About the Ads
B

BodybldgDoc

Ok, I've compiled what I learned based on Kaplan, Barron's Orgo, and that web site.

Nucleophilicity Rules:
1) when molecules have the same central atom, negative charges increase nucleophilicity:
CH3O- > CH3OH (C is central atom)
Me3P < Me2P- (P is central atom)

2) in atoms with the same attacking atom, nucleophilicity increases with basicity (basicity increases as you move to the left on the periodic table)

3) in atoms with different attacking atoms, and occurring in protic solvents, nucleophilicity increases with atomic size (size increases as you move to the left and bottom of the periodic table):
I- > Br- > Cl-

4) in atoms with different attacking atoms, and occurring in aprotic solvents, nucleophility increases with basicity (as in #2).

5) Nucleophilicity increases with less steric effects (steric effects decrease with more accessibility to the attacking atom)

Is this pretty accurate? Let me know.


#5 is not really a rule. Its just common sense that a nucleophile that can attack a molecule which is less sterically hindered will have greater nucleophilicity. The remaining 4 rules sound accurate. It would also be a good idea to understand why nucleophilic strength differs between protic and aprotic solvents, just to be able to make it easier to memorize the rules.
 

busupshot83

S.D.N. Vet
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Mar 23, 2003
2,247
3
37
Texas
Status (Visible)
#5 is not really a rule. Its just common sense that a nucleophile that can attack a molecule which is less sterically hindered will have greater nucleophilicity. The remaining 4 rules sound accurate. It would also be a good idea to understand why nucleophilic strength differs between protic and aprotic solvents, just to be able to make it easier to memorize the rules.

Thanks buddy, that sums that up.
 

CyborgNinjaX

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
Jun 15, 2006
150
0
Status (Visible)
  1. Pre-Dental
Crap man.... this stuff is hurting my head... is there any easy way around this? I hate the Alkane chapter for this reason alone... I think this is probably one of my more weaker points.
 

busupshot83

S.D.N. Vet
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Mar 23, 2003
2,247
3
37
Texas
Status (Visible)
Crap man.... this stuff is hurting my head... is there any easy way around this? I hate the Alkane chapter for this reason alone... I think this is probably one of my more weaker points.

I was looking at Organic Chemistry - Janice, Gorzynski, Smith, and here's another explanation:

when solvent is not given:
1) when molecules have the same central atom, negative charges increase
nucleophilicity:
2) nucleophilicity increases as you go left on the periodic table, or in other words, as basicity increases:
3) nucleophilicity increases as you go down on the periodic table, or in other words, as size increases:
4) Nucleophilicity increases with less steric effects, or in other words, with more accessibility to the nucleophiles or central atom. Look for the least-substituted nucleophile/central atom.

when solvent is given:
5) in protic solvents, larger atoms are better nucleophiles (see #2 above):
6) in aprotic solvents, more basic atoms are better nucleophiles (see #3 above):

---

Now test yourself and determine which molecule is more nucleophilic (highlight spaces below for the solution):
CH3O- vs. CH3OH
CH3O- > CH3OH (rule #1)

-OH vs. H2O
-OH > H2O (rule #1)

OH vs. F-
-OH > F- (rule #2)

I- vs. Br- vs. Cl- vs. F-
I- > Br- > Cl- > F- (rule #3)

in protic solvent: HSe- vs. HS- vs. HO-
HSe- > HS- > HO- (rule #5)

in aprotic solvent: I- vs. Br- vs. Cl- vs. F-
I- < Br- < Cl- < F- (rule #6)
 
This thread is more than 14 years old.

Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:

  1. Your new thread title is very short, and likely is unhelpful.
  2. Your reply is very short and likely does not add anything to the thread.
  3. Your reply is very long and likely does not add anything to the thread.
  4. It is very likely that it does not need any further discussion and thus bumping it serves no purpose.
  5. Your message is mostly quotes or spoilers.
  6. Your reply has occurred very quickly after a previous reply and likely does not add anything to the thread.
  7. This thread is locked.