NYC Surgery Residencies

Started by Future Surgeon
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
F

Future Surgeon

Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member

I will be applying for surgery programs in the NYC area ... any advice/information on the relative strengths and weaknesses of Cornell New York Hospital, Columbia Pres, NYU Bellevue, Mt Sinai, St Lukes Roosevelt?

Especially helpful would be info on lifestyle, reputations, etc.
 
My God! I hope you got the grades, buddy.
 
CPMC and cornell (partic sloan kettering) are amazing schools for surgery (I'm greatly biased towards CPMC) however both places are tough to get into which i assume you know

location wise....CPMC is in washington heights which though was once known as the coke capital of the east coast...is significantly better and is especially safe around the medical center.....cornell is further downtown in a nicer neighborhood...however it will cost you most of your pittance they call intern salary to live in downtown manhattan...and to be honest you really wont leave the hospital enough to see manhattan


plus I hope you have some awesome recs and board scores
 
"I'm greatly biased towards CPMC..."

Any particular reason for this? Just curious.

Thanks for the input.

 
3 reasons for this bias
1) world class facilities and faculty esp in neuro
2) most of the faculty are very eager to teach
3) I am writing this post from the computer lab at the milstein hospital building of CPMC
 
Future Surgeon: You were smart to question the reasoning of the previous poster; he's an MSI. I would encourage you to speak with someone with a little more information and perspective.

Good luck.
 
1918

3 points of discussion regarding your comment

1) you really need to get out more its really a horrible shame that you have so much time on your hands (as well as some general bitterness)
2) I fail to see how being an MS 1 hinders my ability to parrot information and opinions that is repeatedly given to me by older MS's and residents, as well as common observations known to anyone who had ever lived on the upper east side (cornell) or washington heights (CPMC)
3) I also am amazed that cornell didnt rush to get you off the wait list.....I mean its every medical schools dream to have someone who fervently believes that they are omniscient and willing to pointlessly throw in their 2 cents at every occasion......in fact in my cornell interview I was asked to trash talk a cloth dummy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.