COMLEX Official 2019 Comlex 1 Experiences and Scores Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

ASGD1983

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Messages
249
Reaction score
186
It's that time of the year. Anyone took new Comsae recently? Hopefully it's more predicitve than old ones that were all over the place - like +/- 100 points.
Also, interesting to hear if this years comlex is indeed changed? If anyone took it recently - please share your experience. Especially if you can compare it to previous year one.
 
Congrats on finishing! Hard in what sense..was it just a lot of low yield content? How did you feel about the real thing vs the comsae?

My general feeling about the comlex is that you are given less clinical background than say Uworld. Uworld i could think through the scenario with enough time. Here you need to move fast. This is just a general overview of the comlex. You're rushed for time always too.
 
For the record, i thought that yesteday comlex was hard. I scored a 473 today comsae 103 to just boost my confidence albeit my brain is fried...not sure how that will correlate anyone know how predictive 103 is?

Patient presents with bizarre compulsion to take practice tests after major examinations. Medical history is unremarkable. What is the axis of the strain pattern that will most likely be observed?
 
Patient presents with bizarre compulsion to take practice tests after major examinations. Medical history is unremarkable. What is the axis of the strain pattern that will most likely be observed?


HAHAHA! It wasn't that bad on the brain. Overall, the MCAT was a much more tiring exam.
 
Hey guys,

Been a real long time since I've been on this network, and thought I'd drop by this forum real quick to offer some encouragement and feedback that will hopefully help you guys out. It also gives me a nice break from my Step 2 studying (currently as a newly minted 4th year).
What you guys are going through is totally new this year, as it looks like they revamped the Comsae practice exams, and may have also changed the scoring scale accordingly. I think the reason for that is the NBOME had reset the scoring scale for my class, which I think dropped the national average compared to the previous cycle (from 550's back to 520's for us). As such, you guys may have heard, we (I'm not necessarily only referring to my school...but just students in my graduating class in general across all DO schools) had numerous instances where their real COMLEX Level 1 scores dropped significantly from the practice Comsae exams. I'm not saying that everyone had a score drop, but a significant number did.

Glancing at this forum, I understand that there appears to be a lot of nervousness going on, especially as you get closer to your real COMLEX exam and having seen the results of your practice test. I totally get that, as I was in your shoes roughly a year ago. The test is very confusing at times, poorly worded, and vague - and I've experienced the feeling where you feel as though you are running out of time on the real test. Sometimes, there will be easy buzzwords and questions that you will know easily. However, many times, you will only have enough time to skim through the question quickly and make a quick educated first guess before moving on. It's just the way the COMLEX is and always has been. There is no way to sugarcoat it - the COMLEX Level 1 is a mentally exhausting exam, not to mention expensive too.
But what I wanted to tell, and encourage, you guys is to not worry so much on what your practice test results say - the NBOME most likely has not perfected the scoring scale for your new practice exams, and it doesn't shock me that the scores are so much lower. Rather, I want to tell you guys to trust more the process of your studying. Trust the standardized process of UFAP (+ sketchy if you use it or whatever other videos/resources/question bank), as it has worked out well for the majority of medical students over many years. I also will tell you not to focus so much on your question bank percentages - it is much more important to focus on just learning all the concepts well and thoroughly. I didn't pay attention to my percentages that much, because I was actively learning. If you put in the hours and the work, and really spent the time to learn the material and solve questions, then trust that the work will pay off eventually when you take the test. Even if you have to take a quick educated first guess and you have no idea what the question is asking, trust your gut feeling - usually it will serve you well over the course of the exam. And I will tell you that regardless of your preparation, almost nobody walks out of the exam feeling like they nailed the COMLEX - rather, we all thought that we failed this exam miserably. And for the most part, we did relatively fine (even with the score drop in my class) and moved on to clinical years without a second thought.

Just wanted to encourage you guys as you hit the home stretch! You guys are almost there, and you will make it to your clinical years!
 
Just a random thought, I was doing UW and I often check back to FA for some details I don't remember that good and I noticed that it's often down to tiny winy details that might make it or break it the question for you. For example I got a question about myopathy and I missed it just because I couldn't remember specific antibody for it. So I looked it up in FA and it was mentioned only once - literally 3 words Anti-Jo antibodies - that were never mentioned again anywhere in FA. So reading FA it's so easy to miss small details. You think that you know it well enough, but then realize that there are so many details that you don't really remember cold and that's what usually gets me on questions.
Another thing I noticed is that they might ask you a question about well known fact or concept, but it will be worded in such a way that you are left scratching your head and losing time trying to reason through.
Which brings me to my biggest fear of not having enough time per question to really think it through and be able to read all details and labs. I really really hate that feeling when you have to fly through questions skipping lots of details just to make it in time. 🙁
Sorry for the rant. Hopefully we will all make it fam.
 
Just a random thought, I was doing UW and I often check back to FA for some details I don't remember that good and I noticed that it's often down to tiny winy details that might make it or break it the question for you. For example I got a question about myopathy and I missed it just because I couldn't remember specific antibody for it. So I looked it up in FA and it was mentioned only once - literally 3 words Anti-Jo antibodies - that were never mentioned again anywhere in FA. So reading FA it's so easy to miss small details. You think that you know it well enough, but then realize that there are so many details that you don't really remember cold and that's what usually gets me on questions.
Another thing I noticed is that they might ask you a question about well known fact or concept, but it will be worded in such a way that you are left scratching your head and losing time trying to reason through.
Which brings me to my biggest fear of not having enough time per question to really think it through and be able to read all details and labs. I really really hate that feeling when you have to fly through questions skipping lots of details just to make it in time. 🙁
Sorry for the rant. Hopefully we will all make it fam.

Just to stoke the general sense of despair:
We have 400 questions. 8 hours. 72 seconds per question. And yet we have videos that are 30-40 seconds in some of them. Who came up with that? :hungover:

On the other hand: We all gonna be fine.

To your case specifically: Pathoma does a great job pointing these little yet important details out. Check it out if you have the time!
 
Just wondering since I don't know about general consensus on this- I did UFAP+sketchy and took step earlier this week. I have COMLEX in 2 days and pretty much just read the green book in the meantime+ some Turnup2OMT. No COMBANK at all. Is this gonna be okay to get say an average score? I was predicted around a low 240 on step based on the reddit predictor so just wanna make sure I don't screw myself on comlex by not doing the comlex specific practice Q's
 
Heyyo friendos, I'm 10 days out from taking my comlex 1 and was wondering if my score predictor on comquest is accurate at all. I only just started doing questions around 10 days ago so my average has been pretty high so far I've done around 500 questions and I'm really happy with the score its given me. Recently I've been doing blocks of 50 and have also been happy with those scores.
Do y'all think this is an indicator that I'm ready and can expect a score in that range? Or do you think that comquest is giving me a false sense of security.
I'm thinking about doing another comsae to get a idea of what score I may get but because I won't be able to review the questions this feels like a waste of time that could be better spent reviewing more flashcards.
Any input would be megga helpful. Good luck to all y'all.
 
Just wondering since I don't know about general consensus on this- I did UFAP+sketchy and took step earlier this week. I have COMLEX in 2 days and pretty much just read the green book in the meantime+ some Turnup2OMT. No COMBANK at all. Is this gonna be okay to get say an average score? I was predicted around a low 240 on step based on the reddit predictor so just wanna make sure I don't screw myself on comlex by not doing the comlex specific practice Q's
All I did for the COMSAE (103) was cram some OMM questions on truelearn (school provided) and went through the green book a few times for a day and a half tops. I ended up with a 530 when my schools average was a 498. I'm third quartile and only projected to get a 230 ish from the predictor.

long story short you beat me in every category and I barely did a thing for COMSAE and scored above average when the averages were supposedly down. You'll be fine
 
Heyyo friendos, I'm 10 days out from taking my comlex 1 and was wondering if my score predictor on comquest is accurate at all. I only just started doing questions around 10 days ago so my average has been pretty high so far I've done around 500 questions and I'm really happy with the score its given me. Recently I've been doing blocks of 50 and have also been happy with those scores.
Do y'all think this is an indicator that I'm ready and can expect a score in that range? Or do you think that comquest is giving me a false sense of security.
I'm thinking about doing another comsae to get a idea of what score I may get but because I won't be able to review the questions this feels like a waste of time that could be better spent reviewing more flashcards.
Any input would be megga helpful. Good luck to all y'all.
It's hard to base predictions on Comquest alone. From previous years statistics to pass you need to be consistently hitting more than 60% on Comquest timed/random. Obviously for average score or above - you'll need more than that. Like triangulation technique they use in cell industry to pinpoint location using several cell towers, the more predictors you have the better. Comquest + Comsae will give better idea where you are. Even better if you add some NBME test to that. However, if you have consistent 85% or more in Comquest timed/random - we can at least say you should pass 🙂
 
It's hard to base predictions on Comquest alone. From previous years statistics to pass you need to be consistently hitting more than 60% on Comquest timed/random. Obviously for average score or above - you'll need more than that. Like triangulation technique they use in cell industry to pinpoint location using several cell towers, the more predictors you have the better. Comquest + Comsae will give better idea where you are. Even better if you add some NBME test to that. However, if you have consistent 85% or more in Comquest timed/random - we can at least say you should pass 🙂
I'd say COMSAE is a much better indication than Comquest. COMSAE and NBMEs >> Comquest.
 
So I just took my final comsae before comlex in 8 days. Everything was acceptable or good except for a poor in "Systems-Based Practice in Osteopathic Medicine". After looking up that category on the NBOME website, it seems like that category is all the health policy type things, and I swear there were only like 2 on the entire comsae. How do you even study for that kind of stuff? Anyone have any resources, since this is the category that USMLE type prep just plain doesn't cover...and I don't think we even covered in class to any meaningful degree.
 
I'd say COMSAE is a much better indication than Comquest. COMSAE and NBMEs >> Comquest.

Thanks for the input do you think that comquest would over or under predict a score or can you just not tell at all. I want to take another comsae but I just don't want to spend that time and then not be able to review the questions. Would the comquest full length assessment be worth doing or do you recommend something else.
 
So I just took my final comsae before comlex in 8 days. Everything was acceptable or good except for a poor in "Systems-Based Practice in Osteopathic Medicine". After looking up that category on the NBOME website, it seems like that category is all the health policy type things, and I swear there were only like 2 on the entire comsae. How do you even study for that kind of stuff? Anyone have any resources, since this is the category that USMLE type prep just plain doesn't cover.
I figured I’d just mail it in on those haha like there are hundreds of healthcare laws or things related to them there really isn’t a way to study them. As soon as they get the data back and realize that’s a dumb waste of time I bet those questions disappear
 
So I just took my final comsae before comlex in 8 days. Everything was acceptable or good except for a poor in "Systems-Based Practice in Osteopathic Medicine". After looking up that category on the NBOME website, it seems like that category is all the health policy type things, and I swear there were only like 2 on the entire comsae. How do you even study for that kind of stuff? Anyone have any resources, since this is the category that USMLE type prep just plain doesn't cover.
Everyone I know "bombed" this section on COMSAEs. Its 0-5% of your comlex. I wouldnt worry about it. Might not show up at all, if it does, we'll wing it and hope for a good curve.
 
So I just took my final comsae before comlex in 8 days. Everything was acceptable or good except for a poor in "Systems-Based Practice in Osteopathic Medicine". After looking up that category on the NBOME website, it seems like that category is all the health policy type things, and I swear there were only like 2 on the entire comsae. How do you even study for that kind of stuff? Anyone have any resources, since this is the category that USMLE type prep just plain doesn't cover...and I don't think we even covered in class to any meaningful degree.

I honestly think you just gotta hit the practice questions a bunch. Some of them are so stupid. I got a question wrong today because I didn't realize you have to give a pt 30 days notice via certified male. Thats just something you are never going to study outside a practice question.
 
Heyyo friendos, I'm 10 days out from taking my comlex 1 and was wondering if my score predictor on comquest is accurate at all. I only just started doing questions around 10 days ago so my average has been pretty high so far I've done around 500 questions and I'm really happy with the score its given me. Recently I've been doing blocks of 50 and have also been happy with those scores.
Do y'all think this is an indicator that I'm ready and can expect a score in that range? Or do you think that comquest is giving me a false sense of security.
I'm thinking about doing another comsae to get a idea of what score I may get but because I won't be able to review the questions this feels like a waste of time that could be better spent reviewing more flashcards.
Any input would be megga helpful. Good luck to all y'all.
do you think that comquest would over or under predict a score or can you just not tell at all.

I don't think you can get any reliable data from that. If so I'm about to get my score back and have it be a 950 lol.
I figured I’d just mail it in on those haha like there are hundreds of healthcare laws or things related to them there really isn’t a way to study them. As soon as they get the data back and realize that’s a dumb waste of time I bet those questions disappear

Yeah honestly I always just took the approach that no one else had studied that stuff either and took the L. I might have had 3 questions like that on my real thing.
 
For those that have taken step + comlex, is it even worth it to take a COMSAE? My last NBME 18 was 238 and UWSA 243.

Plan on just cramming OMM for 2 days
 
I don't think you can get any reliable data from that. If so I'm about to get my score back and have it be a 950 lol.


Yeah honestly I always just took the approach that no one else had studied that stuff either and took the L. I might have had 3 questions like that on my real thing.
Well ****. Ive only taken the two comsae my school has given me, which one do you recommend I take?
 
Still a bit more than 2 weeks until first batch of "new comlex" scores comes in. We'll hopefully be able to see what's the deal with new comsae score wise compared to comlex. Until then as AnatomyGrey12 said best approach is to keep studying as that's the only guaranteed and proven way to succeed 🙂
 
Thanks for the input do you think that comquest would over or under predict a score or can you just not tell at all. I want to take another comsae but I just don't want to spend that time and then not be able to review the questions. Would the comquest full length assessment be worth doing or do you recommend something else.
Can't say about the prediction... I know combank is good, never tried comquest, so can't say.
 
Does anyone know if I should take the Step to match Psych..? I am waiting for my COMLEX, hoping at least a 540-550... I didn't do very well on the NBMEs, but if I have a good chance of not matching Psych I'm really just going to try to take Step 1 again.
 
So I just took my final comsae before comlex in 8 days. Everything was acceptable or good except for a poor in "Systems-Based Practice in Osteopathic Medicine". After looking up that category on the NBOME website, it seems like that category is all the health policy type things, and I swear there were only like 2 on the entire comsae. How do you even study for that kind of stuff? Anyone have any resources, since this is the category that USMLE type prep just plain doesn't cover...and I don't think we even covered in class to any meaningful degree.

Do you have boards and beyond? This type of stuff is under “behavioral sciences” which is really more public health/policy/insurance/well visit/quality improvement/ethics. The entire section is 2 hours.
 
I'm so burnt out from step I need to get this comlex over with lmao. Is it still less of a "thinking" exam than step?
 
Did anyone take comsae form 104? I got a 477 on it with 1 week left to take comlex. Shooting for 450 on real thing. Possible or should i postpone?
 
Did anyone take comsae form 104? I got a 477 on it with 1 week left to take comlex. Shooting for 450 on real thing. Possible or should i postpone?
Nobody has real scores yet so nobody knows the value of the new COMSAEs. But you’re probably okay since you’re already above that
 
Did anyone take comsae form 104? I got a 477 on it with 1 week left to take comlex. Shooting for 450 on real thing. Possible or should i postpone?
General consensus is these COMSAEs are under-predicting, but nobody knows until the first scores from this new form are released in July.
 
I'm so burnt out from step I need to get this comlex over with lmao. Is it still less of a "thinking" exam than step?

It's definitely less of a thinking exam. Since there are 400 questions- there are plenty of first order "gimme" questions. The questions are written pretty terribly and you can tell at times they're trying to make Comlex harder than it is. They also test on pretty obscure stuff. It's sometimes a game trying to figure out what they're asking for. Just make sure to set a good pace, a lot of people seem to be crunched on time.

I took one school administered old COMSAE and did fine, but that's it. UFAP + sketchy should be enough to get you enough points to do well. If you do well on Step then Comlex shouldn't be so different.

I took Step and Comlex 3 days apart. All I did between were sympathetics, Chapman's points, and OMM questions. Would it have helped to do more Comlex style questions? Probably. Do I care enough about the Comlex? Nahh
 
Do you have boards and beyond? This type of stuff is under “behavioral sciences” which is really more public health/policy/insurance/well visit/quality improvement/ethics. The entire section is 2 hours.
I think DirtyUSMLE does a good job covering ethics as well. 30 cases, 53min. Just watch at 1.5-2x
 
People were saying greater than 50% in the past, but i'm not sure how it holds up now?

They didn't know it back then and now they don't know it either. NBOME doesn't give that data. Why shoot darts in the dark? It's not like you can benchmark that number against anything anyway. Give your best and you will be fine.
 
1 week until I take my test so i guess ill join in on this thread haha.

COMSAE Form D was 481. Approximately 3 months ago. I know this form is pretty inflated so i know i need to get an updated score.

Plan on taking a COMSAE on wednesday. After getting wrecked on USMLE my goal score is passing COMLEX tbh.
 
1 week until I take my test so i guess ill join in on this thread haha.

COMSAE Form D was 481. Approximately 3 months ago. I know this form is pretty inflated so i know i need to get an updated score.

Plan on taking a COMSAE on wednesday. After getting wrecked on USMLE my goal score is passing COMLEX tbh.

I read somewhere that form D underpredicted. Comlex is a different beast, good luck mate
 
1 week until I take my test so i guess ill join in on this thread haha.

COMSAE Form D was 481. Approximately 3 months ago. I know this form is pretty inflated so i know i need to get an updated score.

Plan on taking a COMSAE on wednesday. After getting wrecked on USMLE my goal score is passing COMLEX tbh.
Please let us know your new comsae score on Wednesday.
 
Top