Ortho Review of New Edition of McGlamry

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

mildoc2016

resident
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2006
Messages
114
Reaction score
3
"1 of 29 people found the following review helpful
Fraud -, March 18, 2013
By Ortho1This review is from: McGlamry's Comprehensive Textbook of Foot and Ankle Surgery, 2-Volume Set (Hardcover)
How can any Podiatrist write a book on Ankle surgery? It is like a blind person writing a book on art appreciation! How many Podiatrist do a Orthopedic residency, Foot and Ankle fellowship, take acute trauma on a daily basis at major University trauma centers? At best maybe 1% of the Podiatry profession has any ankle training and usually they are from the military. Podiatry training is very sketchy and they can't handle their own complications for any number of reasons including 50 different scopes of practice in 50 States. How can people who are limited by law in most States from even touching the ankle decide they will teach Ankle surgery? The Podiatry profession is good at billing and performing procedures they decide are legit without any literature on the subject except what they decide is valid.
Podiatry should stick with bilking the public with their "lazer" toenail procedures that are about 30% effective and cutting corns and calluses. If I had an ingrown toenail I would go to a Podiatrist but of course get a bill consistent with cardiac surgery. They are Allied Health Professionals who can't admit without a physician co admit and in most States and cant even perform a legit H/P. Unfortunately the public falls victim to their nonsense. Students who had 2.86 gpa in unknown undergraduate schools playing DR. and expecting parity. Sorry, ain't gonna happen. "


Please go to amazon and email amazon.com authorities this untrue rendition of our profession. Please dont let uneducated individuals defame our training.

http://www.amazon.com/review/R1YICR...D=Mx2HJR2UNM09I5K&store=books#Mx2HJR2UNM09I5K
 
Yeah I remember seeing that review too. I flagged it as inappropriate, but obviously it's still there. Sad to see discrimination 👎
 
This "Ortho" review has some suspiciously similar language to a few trolls that have posted on our forum...
 
I guarantee this review was written by a medical student and not a Dr.
 
I am not particularly fond of rotten reviews if they're written by people who may not have bothered to read a book. If you want to shut people who use a man's book to insult your field, buy this book at Amazon, and write a review. Readers give a greater weight to reviews written by people who've purchased the product. The author and editors labored extensively to put this project together, allowing a reviewer to impede sales is flat out dirty pool.
 
How many people outside of our profession consider buying that text? We already know better than to listen to what ortho1 is saying, so I think the damage will be minimal or nonexistent. It's just some douchebag out trolling.
 
How many people outside of our profession consider buying that text? We already know better than to listen to what ortho1 is saying, so I think the damage will be minimal or nonexistent. It's just some douchebag out trolling.

Agreed.

Sad when people feel the need that they need to go out of their way to "correct" the misinformed masses.
 
it gets even better.

he updated the review. I sure hope I can land a residency where I am done by 10 am.


Update - 5/25/13 I stand by this review 100%. We also have two young three year surgically trained Podiatrist's at our institution that are quite comfortable and competent performing Diabetic nail debridements and wound care duties in the clinic that agree with me and state all they really did in the Podiatric surgery programs was stand behind many people and watch? Many stated their day was over at 10:00am.
This is one of only many reasons I stand by my review of the book. Please, get over it. Everybody in your profession seems to idolize it!
 
He might be a troll from sdn and saw this post lol

Sent from my Nexus S using Tapatalk
 
I'm enjoying ortho1's highly advanced grammar, spelling, and professionalism. The more he or she comments the better it makes us all look.
 
i think that he is still butt-hurt that the uncensored podiatry forum got shut down.
 
Look at his review for sarrafian..... Somebody is way insecure
 
Top