Thought the format was unnecessary and a little annoying. I didn't think I would mesh well with the PD if I were a resident there, which ultimately limits how high I'm willing to rank it. The residents there seemed pretty cool though and the location and housing is terrific.
I'm thinking of ranking GWU over BI mostly because its a university program versus a university affiliate, not necessary the strength of the program. I could live in either city and both are in great parts of town. I could understand someone ranking BI higher if they wanted to be in NYC >DC.
I didn't interview at winthrop or mount auburn so I can't comment on those.