Just had this discussion yesterday with one of my partners. We had a possible bronchospasm vs laryngospasm in a 2yo at the end of a case. It was the real deal with unreadable sats and HR in the 50’s for a minute. Resolved by reintubating and recruiting alveoli. The kid did fine and was d/c’d home. We have a wild fire raging in town and everyone is feeling the effects, wheezing etc. I have put a hold on doing elective kids with reactive airway disease that are under 3yo (arbitrary number I admit) until the smoke clears.
But the vast majority of my group extubates their pedi pts awake. I usually extubate deep, especially the kids with reactive airways and living with smokers. Reasons in my head are that I don’t want them to potentially cough or buck on a Tube, stirring up a reaction. Plus on a busy dental or ENT day it is much faster. And it is safe when done properly and when your staff understands what the plan is.
My process is this, I spray the trachea with an LTA of 4% lido then come out and bag for a little bit. Maybe 5 breaths. Then I pass the tube and I make sure the kid is deep when I do all of this. Maintenance is irrelevant other than I do give narcs to an appropriate RR for age. When the case is finished I give 2-4 cc propofol depending on weight and age and turn off the gas. Suction well to assure myself that there is no bleeding or secretions to induce laryngospasm and then pull the tube with a small amount of positive pressure. Place the mask and apply PP again to assure patent airway. Roll the kid on its right side with a face mask applied and reassure that I see fogging ( too high of fresh gas flow can make this hard to see) of the mask with consecutive breaths and no need for assistance (jaw lift). Roll out to PACU were my staff knows not to disturb the kid until they see purposeful movements which take around 5minutes. No BP, just a pulse ox. I go to see my next pt and then return to be sure the kid is coming around and doing well. I don’t like to go back to the OR with the next case until the kid is moving purposefully and out of the woods. This is where I think the OP’s comment of pulling it at 2-3MAC would burn me. I’d be waiting fo that kid arouse for way too long.
If during induction, I found the mask ventilation to be suspect at all then I extubation that kid awake.