Pediatric surgeon dies trying to save two kids from Lake Michigan

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Wow. That is really moving. I just hope many of us would be willing to do the same.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
That's incredible. That's an even more reason as to why I want to be a pediatrician. I hope that we can all follow his footsteps, hopefully not to the point of losing your life, but still. God bless the man. He truly left this world as a real hero.
 
That is so sad. The comments are filled full of his patients, each expressing their condolences.
 
So sad. What a remarkable man...

Dr. Donald Liu died as he lived, saving children.

The pediatric surgeon was with his wife for a weekend getaway when he spotted two children struggling in Lake Michigan off a small beach in Berrien County Michigan Sunday morning. Liu was able to help the children but was pulled under the water and drowned, according to authorities and his friends.

"Dr. Liu drowned while successfully saving two children who got caught in heavy surf in Lake Michigan," said his friend and colleague, Dr. Jeffrey Matthews, chairman of surgery at the University of Chicago Hospitals, where Liu practiced.

"He managed to help them but he got pulled down by the undertow himself," Matthews said. "He really died a hero."

Liu had recently celebrated his 50th birthday and was spending the weekend with his wife and three small children in Chikaming Township, about 90 miles from Chicago. Around 9:40 a.m., he saw the children in trouble off Cherry Beach, police said.

Liu went out to help and went under the water before rescue crews arrived, according to Jeff Thornton, a dispatch supervisor for Berrien County Public Safety. "He was a responder who went out to help," Thornton said, but he had no details.

Thornton said Liu's death was one of two apparent drownings in the county Sunday. A 41-year-old man from west suburban Montgomery drowned a few hours later in the lake.

The unidentified victim from Montgomery was located in 12 feet of water in a rip current 350 yards off Tiscornia Beach in St. Joseph, according to a statement released by St. Joseph City Public Safety. He was pulled from the waters byU.S. Coast Guardworkers and taken to Lakeland Hospital, where he was pronounced dead, the statement said.

He was last seen in waves that were 6-8 feet high.

"It looks like he got caught in the rip,'' said Thornton of the Montgomery man. "The rip current is just a huge undertow caused by large waves that causes suction,'" Thorton said.

The rip current could also have played a role in the doctor's death, said Thornton.

"It could very well have resulted in the same thing,'' Thornton said.

Liu lived in Hyde Park and had worked at the hospital for about 10 years. He had recently been awarded a "distinguished clinician" award at the hospital.

"It's incredibly sad," said Matthews. "We are so absolutely heartbroken by the loss of our friend and colleague. Ironically, he died saving children which is what he does every day.

"He was a brilliant, caring, compassionate surgeon and one of the most wonderful people you would ever meet," Matthews said. "He was beloved in the Hyde Park community and he's just a prince of a man.

"He was a remarkable human being. We are all shocked," Matthews continued. "He was very passionate about his work. What the children needed was what always what he talked about. He was a world-class pediatric surgeon who made innovations and advancements in minimally invasive surgery for children and cared for trauma victims."

Another friend, Dr. John Cunningham, a pediatric oncologist at the University of Chicago Hospitals, said he knew Liu for six years and regarded him as "a brilliant surgeon."

"It wasn't just his clinical skills, but his people skills were just magnificent,'' Cunningham said. "He was a stellar communicator to families and children when they were facing very, very difficult challenges.''

He was also known for his teaching, training the "next generation of Chinese surgeons, because of his heritage'' said Cunningham.

"He lit up the room. He was a gregarious person who, when he spoke about a topic, you really felt that something good would happen,'' Cunningham said. "I spoke with him on Tuesday and he was his usual happy and wonderful self.''

Liu joined the University of Chicago Hospitals as a pediatric surgeon in 2001, and was named section chief of pediatric surgery and surgeon-in-chief at Comer Children's Hospital in 2007. He is survived by his wife, Dr. Dana Suskind, and three children: Genevieve, 13, Asher, 10, and Amalie, 7.


Source:http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/...ing-in-lake-michigan-20120805,0,7520105.story
 
Heroic. I guess we lose sight of the boundaries between heroism and expectation. Whereas he undoubtedly saved many children's lives through his practice, it's in a setting where it's expected and so doesn't receive the attention. Really this should cast a light on all physicians and what they do day in and day out in saving people's lives. He never lost sight of it and rose to the call of duty even outside his clinic. Heroic in every sense of the word.
 
First of all, RIP. I hope his family is OK.

I know this is going to sound weird, but I have to say it is a great way to die.

Yes, the timing is unfortunate, but if we could choose our own deaths, wouldnt you prefer to go out trying to help others rather than die from cancer on a ventilator when you are 90 years old?

Sadly, most of us will have "bad" deaths -- spending the last few weeks/months slowly deteriorating.

We've all got to die some day. Give me Dr Liu's death any day of the week over dying from cancer, or heart disease. or Alzheimer's, or even generic "natural causes."
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Absolutely tragic, but he undoubtedly died a hero. RIP Dr. Liu
 
Loved it!

Perhaps a weird way to phrase it, but I understand what you mean.

Very sad indeed, but what an incredible display of compassion for others. Who knows what kind of ripple effects this will produce.

What's sad is that they'll never talk about this guy on the news with anywhere close to the same extent of coverage for someone that killed two kids. These are stories that deserve to be told as well.
 
Thanks for the share indeed.

A doctor and a hero!
 
Wow that is really amazing. Just goes to show you this man truly did care for other people. I really hope for the best for his family.
 
First of all, RIP. I hope his family is OK.

I know this is going to sound weird, but I have to say it is a great way to die.

Yes, the timing is unfortunate, but if we could choose our own deaths, wouldnt you prefer to go out trying to help others rather than die from cancer on a ventilator when you are 90 years old?

Sadly, most of us will have "bad" deaths -- spending the last few weeks/months slowly deteriorating.

We've all got to die some day. Give me Dr Liu's death any day of the week over dying from cancer, or heart disease. or Alzheimer's, or even generic "natural causes."

Though he may have died in a "good" way, it came far too soon. Ideally he would have operated for another decade or so, and in doing so saved/improved thousands of lives. He then would have enjoyed a long, restful retirement, using his time to connect with his family, travel, and perhaps do some volunteer work. THEN he could have gone out in a blaze of glory.
 
Awesome guy, we need more people like this in the world.
 
Just saw this on the local news. They said his children and wife were all begging him not to go into the water, and then his wife tried to use CPR to save him but it was too late. 🙁 Rip Currents have been out of control in Lake Michigan this year. He was definitely an inspiring and strong guy.
 
I don't know how I feel about this. I greatly admired his heroic act but at the same time can't help but feeling he could have done more good being alive.

What do you guys think going through his head at the moment? Did he see the possibility of him dying for the two kids and made that choice or he really thought he could get away with it?
 
This is so sad. He definitely died a hero. Thoughts are with his wife and his family
 
I don't know how I feel about this. I greatly admired his heroic act but at the same time can't help but feeling he could have done more good being alive.

What do you guys think going through his head at the moment? Did he see the possibility of him dying for the two kids and made that choice or he really thought he could get away with it?

The smart thing to do is to ALWAYS find a rope or pole for the drowner, and to NOT swim out to them.

I think naturally as a pediatrician, he just wanted to save the kids lives though, and maybe he misjudged the weight of the kids he was trying to help. It would be hard for me to just stand there and watch two kids drowning in the lake.
 
I don't know how I feel about this. I greatly admired his heroic act but at the same time can't help but feeling he could have done more good being alive.

What do you guys think going through his head at the moment? Did he see the possibility of him dying for the two kids and made that choice or he really thought he could get away with it?

I don't think he even had much time to think. As a pediatrician, I truly believe it was in his heart to save those kids no matter the consequences.
 
Very sad, very heroic...not sure if I would do the same thing (not a strong swimmer, and seems he wasn't either - just making it more courageous).
 
The word hero is used quite loosely in this country. However, in this case it fits. I'm sure his family and friends are proud to know him. RIP
 
Sad story, but this sort of story reminds me that there's still a lot of good left on this planet. Thanks a lot for sharing, I doubt I would have come across this otherwise.

Condolences to his family.
 
This is too weird... I live in St. Joe but this is the first time I've heard about this incident. My heart goes out to his family. He seems to have been an amazing man.

This isn't even the first drowning this year. It's always the tourists and out-of-towners who drown in these incidents.
 
First of all, RIP. I hope his family is OK.

I know this is going to sound weird, but I have to say it is a great way to die.

Yes, the timing is unfortunate, but if we could choose our own deaths, wouldnt you prefer to go out trying to help others rather than die from cancer on a ventilator when you are 90 years old?

Sadly, most of us will have "bad" deaths -- spending the last few weeks/months slowly deteriorating.

We've all got to die some day. Give me Dr Liu's death any day of the week over dying from cancer, or heart disease. or Alzheimer's, or even generic "natural causes."

I agree he died heroically, but I would never want to die the way he did. Drowning absolutely terrifies me.
 
The smart thing to do is to ALWAYS find a rope or pole for the drowner, and to NOT swim out to them.

True, but in these situations I think there's a different response from the "brain" vs the "heart"

While the cerebral cortex part of my brain is telling me not to jump in after them, the limbic and pre-frontal cortex part of my brain is hoping I wont listen.

It would be hard for me to just stand there and watch two kids drowning in the lake.

Damn straight. Kids are worth dying for, no questions asked. I dont know how I'd react in that situation, but I'd like to think I'd go after them, even at the risk of certain death. I can accept death. I cant accept just standing there and watching 2 children die right in front of me.

There's a scene from I, Robot that this story reminded me of:

Calvin: "What happened to you?"

Spooner: "Headed back to the station...normal day, normal life...
Driver of a semi fell asleep at the wheel.
Average guy...wife and kids... you know, working a double...not the devil...
The car he hit, the driver's name was Harold Lloyd. He was killed instantly.
But his 12 year old was in the passenger seat.
Never really met her...can't forget her face though. Sarah.
She wanted to be a dentist. The hell kind of a 12 year old wants to be a dentist?
Ya, um, the truck smashed our cars together and pushed us into the river.
I mean, metal gets pretty pliable at those speeds.
She's pinned, I'm pinned, the water's coming in.
I'm a cop so...I already know everybody's dead.
Just a few more minutes before we figure it out.


NS4 was passing by, saw the accident and jumped in water.


NS4: "You are in danger!"


Spooner: "Save her, save the girl! Save her!
But I, um... it didn't. Saved me.

Calvin: "The robot's brain is a difference engine. It's reading vital signs that must have calculated that..."

Spooner: "It did...I was the logical choice."
Calculated that I had 45% chance of survival.
Sarah had only an 11% chance. But Sarah was somebody's baby.
11% is more than enough. Any parent woulda known that."


I'd like to think I'd jump in, because I have a 7 year old son, and if my son was in that water I hope that somebody would go after him.
 
Last edited:
I'd like to think I'd jump in, because I have a 7 year old son, and if my son was in that water I hope that somebody would go after him.
I would go after your kid. I would like to think you would go after mine too.....
Emedpa
PA, former paramedic, and believe it or not, former lifeguard and lifeguard instructor

I guess we can agree that kids supersede our petty arguments here on sdn.
 
The sincere messages posted by those he affected are truly heartwarming & heartbreaking at the same time. Absolutely brilliant doctor who has changed countless lives and will be missed by all.

Altruism at its finest.
 
Absolutely amazing!

Thanks for the share.

May he rest in piece.
 
So many conflicted feelings on this. Obviously, this man defines altruism. His actions were heroic; he deserves praise in every way. But I feel so terribly for his family. They watched him die. And I feel for all the patients he won't be able to help now. He is a hero, but I don't know if, in his shoes, I would want to do what he did.
 
this brought tears to my eyes. a tremendous sacrifice. not to belittle the story in any way, but its a great reminder to me that there are bigger tragedies than my mcat score. (currently in the month-long wait; its all that occupies my thoughts)
 
http://www.heraldpalladium.com/news...cle_8ac94808-6b80-5c88-830c-6001a774871e.html

Story from the local paper:

"Liu, a pediatric surgeon at University of Chicago Comer Children's Hospital, drowned Sunday while saving two children who had been kayaking in a choppy Lake Michigan when their kayak turned over. The children got back to shore safely and left while Liu drowned, police said."

I can't believe the kids just left while the man who saved them was drowning...
 
How come the kids are not being BLASTED and LAMBASTED for NOT HELPING Dr. Liu?
The were fine being saved but they left while Dr. Liu drowned, why not call for help?
 
How come the kids are not being BLASTED and LAMBASTED for NOT HELPING Dr. Liu?
The were fine being saved but they left while Dr. Liu drowned, why not call for help?

I mean, they're kids and we don't know the full story...but that seems pretty f'ed up. What a horrible way to show some respect for a man who saved them. I hope it's not as bad as it seems.
 
I mean, they're kids and we don't know the full story...but that seems pretty f'ed up. What a horrible way to show some respect for a man who saved them. I hope it's not as bad as it seems.

They're "KIDS"? Since when do kids go kayaking alone?
If they were kids, where were the parents?

It seems they were not kids but two scum-of-the-earth teenagers.
If they were indeed children, the parents of the children should be brought to court by Dr. Liu's family.
 
I feel terrible for his family, three young kids. I hope they're provided for...

And that does seem awfully shady that the kids he rescued just left!
 
Top