yaah said:
Plus, one of their residents is really cute.
Hmm...yet you did not rank them. Hey you're interested in dermpath these days, right?
OK *serious hat back on*...my thoughts on Penn mirrors what Logos' has to say.
Penn's program is pretty big and last year's class was almost all MD/PhDs which they said was a total fluke. Each year though, they do attract an insane # of MD/PhD's though and they have a great track record for producing academic pathologists. Logos' mentioned the one year of research support. It seems that many programs will fully fund one year of research (whereas other programs will fund up to 3). During this one year at Penn, you will be expected to get preliminary data in the lab and apply for those KO8's. However, Penn has a very rich tradition of success in this aspect as virtually close to all their residents succeed in getting KO8's without any problems (1/3 of the score being quality of mentor; 1/3 score being your institution; leaving only the remaining 1/3 on how badass your proposal is). Anyways, their strong tradition of producing physician-scientists really impressed me; they're doing something right. This is one of the places where I would not feel as part of a minority or an exception to some rule...I don't wanna go to a place where I'm referred to as, "we got this one resident in our program but he's off in the lab now."
As for Philly, Philly isn't the prettiest place to live but Philly gets a bad rap just like Baltimore. There is perhaps some justification to this but I think too many people jump to write those two cities off as sh*tty places to live. As for Penn, their medical center is intermingled with the other Penn schools and the undergrad campus somewhat and their campus looks very nice. It seems that there are pockets of neighborhoods where the Penn residents live and I think they get free parking in a garage so you don't have to worry too much about getting your car broken into.
As for their applicants, I am well aware too that Penn is producing many pathology applicants this year. And I heard that 6 or 7 of their graduating MSTP class is going into path and almost all of them are really into neuropath (based on a conversation I had at Hopkins since apparently all those Penn folks interviewed at Hopkins). Neuropath at Penn is really really strong and I think a hefty number of them may want to stay at Penn for residency so competition is quite stiff. I would think that if they wanted to stay at Penn, they're pretty much a shoe-in which really leaves just a few spots for us outsiders
Furthermore, there is the AP and CP issue at Penn. When I interviewed there I got the distinct impression that CP as extremely strong there...probably one of the best CP training institutions in the country. But they recently lost Debra Leonard to Cornell and now lost Jay Hess to Michigan (Go Blue!). However, I don't think the impact will be too significant given that Penn is very CP-strong and will fill these holes pretty quickly. With all this CP talk, I can see how some may think that AP takes a back seat at Penn and may not be as strong as other AP heavy institutions. However, they do have good specimen variety and volume so when I look at Penn, I see a strong and balanced institution.
Finally, I can't say enough about the administration, the PD, and the department chair. Some of the coolest people I've met along the interview trail. Very pro-resident attitudes from the high-up's and Logos' testified to the evidence for that in his post. As for the surg path facilities, I was told that they were not too pretty and many people who interview there are far from impressed. However, they were upfront and honest which I respect a lot. They are trying to remedy the situation; however, due to space issues renovations/expansions of the surg path area will happen very incrementally and not as fast as the improvements being made to other path areas such as the residents room and all.
What I wanna know is: How can they afford to take all these interviewees out to dinner the night before? and then a nice lunch on interview day? where does this money come from?