I have a similar question as BeancheBlanco.
I received generally good feedback about my PS last cycle. The one negative comment I received was that I needed to be more clear about my motivation(s) to pursue medicine and how my life narrative ties in with my future goals.
I am considering completely overhauling the PS and tackling it from a different angle. However, I am concerned that it might come across as disingenuous if it was compared to my previous PS.
In other words, my first PS cited experiences "A," "B," and "C" as my reasons for wanting to become a physician. If I instead talked about experiences "X," "Y," and "Z," which were entirely different but equally meaningful, would it be a problem?
Thanks!