- Joined
- Aug 30, 2007
- Messages
- 190
- Reaction score
- 0
Will be posting up my formal review of NSUCOM within the next couple of weeks. After finally matching...
congratulations on matching and can't wait for the review
Will be posting up my formal review of NSUCOM within the next couple of weeks. After finally matching...
+1 for MSUCOM update, would like to hear some more input with respect to quality of clinical rotations and preparation for boards
Is it possible to do all your rotations at VCOM/PCOM/Erie/UMDNJ at one rotation site? Or is it required that you travel around?
+2 still no update on MSUCOM?🙁
They went back to full dissection this year for my class. We still have practicals and still have Conover!@mosspoh: Is it true NSU doesnt have dissection lab/cadavers anymore? I recently found this out, and i was shocked! No more practicals?
Is it possible to do all your rotations at VCOM/PCOM/Erie/UMDNJ at one rotation site? Or is it required that you travel around?
+3 for MSUCOM. Particularly about the base hospitals, even if hearsay.
At LECOM-E you pick either a rotation schedule as your top pick (i.e. IM first, surg in the middle, Vacation at christmas, etc) or you pick an area/city you want to rotate in. I know Pittsburgh and Cleveland have plenty of rotations/hospitals to choose from. You can also do some of them in Erie. I haven't decided if I want a certain city or rotation schedule. I'll probably go with rotation schedule because since I am HPSP, the military match is in December so I need to make sure I have fourth year rotations early on that I can use for AI or aways.
Hey all,
I'd love if anyone can give more/updated reviews for Touro-NV and ATSU SOMA. I found out today that I am now accepted at both places, and I'm hard-pressed to choose, although I do have a little bit of time to decide.
If anyone of you know any strong reasons for one school or the other, I'd love to hear them; I'm also seeing how to get contacts for 3rd/4th years at these schools if I can.
So you either pick your location or your schedule? If you pick location, do you still get to pick your electives/selectives?
Thanks!
@mosspoh: Is it true NSU doesnt have dissection lab/cadavers anymore? I recently found this out, and i was shocked! No more practicals?
CURRICULUM: Overall, they have done a great job. It is systems-based and exams are about every 3 weeks or so. They have tweaked things a bit since the first class rolled thru based on feedback from the students, so it is always improving. Pharm is a weak teaching area, but improved with Dr. Babos, and will improve next year after more hires. Student feedback is extremely important to the school, so it is gathered constantly. Attendance used to be required, but that is no longer the case. We are surrounded by technology .actually, we may be the most technologically advanced DO school in the country, and probably more than most MD schools. Everything is done on computers (except exams), we utilize simulators, in fact, we have a wing dedicated to simulations. All of our lectures are video recorded (video shows the lecturer and powerpoint, so when he/she writes something on a slide, it shows up on the video). We are involved in clinical training from the start we see our first standardized patient within a month of starting school. It is a very rigorous program clinically, so we are very prepared for rotations. I would put us up against anyone. We have 10 clinical exam rooms where our OSCEs take place. These are setup just like a doctors office .in fact, this area of the school was used for the university clinic for the first 2 years. The clinic has now moved to a separate building and includes digital x-ray, labs and a number of examination rooms. Our OMM chair is amazing and makes the class/lab a lot of fun. You learn a lot and are VERY well prepped for OMM board questions. Anatomy utilizes prosection .students are the prosectors, so if you want to dissect, signup for that. Overall, I would call the curriculum evolving and adaptive to the student, but very demanding and challenging.
TESTING: We have block exams, so expect an exam every 3 weeks or so, depending on the system. OMM and EPC (clinical training class) are tested separately, about every 6 weeks or so. Exams are scheduled for the morning, usually starting between 8-9:00am. After lunch, you come back and take the same exam again, but this time with a group of 10-12 students. This team exam is used to assess validity of questions .so if a group feels a question was unfair, tested material outside the scope of the system, etc., the group writes up the question. The write-up is then assessed by the testing center thru stats, number of other groups complaining about the same question, and then a decision is made. The question will either count as is, be tossed out completely, or kept as a bonus question. The team exam is mandatory and you get a 2% bonus to your test by going. If you skip it, you lose 5%, so the extra hour or so is very much worth your time.
LOCATION: Its Harrogate, TN. We have 4 stop lights, one of which was put up for the school, so there isnt much traffic. There isnt a ton around, but with school and studying, you dont have much time to enjoy all that anyway. Knoxville is an hour away, so when those moments arise, you can go there and have a nice dinner, etc. Middlesboro, KY is the next town north of Harrogate, and its fairly large for the area. There are a lot of fast-food joints, a cheap movie theater ($3) with the newest movies, a Kroger, Walmart, Big Lots, a small mall and other various stores. Anything you need for daily living is within 10 minutes of school. In terms of activities around campus, anything you can imagine doing outdoors, you can do here. We are minutes from a state park with miles of trails, canoeing, hiking, etc. The scenery is beautiful, especially during the fall. We have mountains surrounding us and when the trees change colors, its an amazing sight. Of course, they schedule the white coat ceremony during fall, so families will be able to take in the beauty as well. The university is in the process of building a small golf course too.
COST: Tuition = $33,000, so right in line with every other DO school. We do have the most awesome financial aid advisor a gem of a lady. We are part of a university, Lincoln Memorial University, so we have all loan options available.
FACULTY: In terms of professors, I think we have some of the best in the country. We may be a new school, but we have recruited the best people to run the program. Those we have found who have never taught before have been absolutely amazing as well. I cant imagine a better faculty, both on a professional level and a personal level. There is an open-door policy at LMU-DCOM with faculty. As long as the profs/docs are in their office and not in a meeting, they are there to answer any questions, or even just chat about life for awhile. The camaraderie among the faculty is unlike anything Ive ever seen. In fact, the school got an accommodation from COCA during its last sight visit because of the faculty and the teamwork between them. Just a couple notable names .Dr. Leo, Dr. Cross, Dr. Wieting. As for our dean, Dr. Stowers, you couldnt ask for a better person. He is the reason, along with the rest of the faculty, that we have such a family-like atmosphere. We have deans hour meetings periodically throughout each semester, so he is in constant contact with each class. We have 2 profs who are professional BBQ judges and competitors, so they cook for us a lot when we have class get-togethers. Lets just say their food is AMAZING.
REPUTATION: We are a new school, so there isnt much of one yet. I honestly believe this is going to be one of the best programs in the country in the coming years (and its not just school-pride rah rah stuff either). There are a lot of passionate, hard-working people who are going to make this just an unbelievable education and experience. So far, the feedback from doctors about our 3rd year students (inaugural class) is very positive since we are very prepared for rotations. This feedback is both from local docs to attendings at residency programs around the country. The university, LMU, is in the process of building a brand-new science and research center as well. This building is planned to be as big or bigger than the medical school (which is 105,000 sq ft) and will be equipped with new labs and such, so research opportunities for both faculty and students will be increasing once that is done.
TECHNOLOGY: One of the most technologically advanced schools in the country, easily. Everything is done on the school supplied laptop (Lenovo tablets) except exams. All lectures are video recorded and put onto a server that is accessible from home so you can watch lectures as many times as you want, and at different speeds (up to 2x faster). The school also utilizes long-distance learning, so you can have a lecturer give a lecture from home, another office, etc. and it is displayed in the lecture hall. We are also in the process of implementing podcasting of lectures as well. We have a full simulation suite on the 3rd floor of the building. We have a total of about 7 suites, including 2 ER rooms, 1 OR, 1 OB/Gyn, 1 optho and 2 miscellaneous, where multiple things can be done. These rooms are equipped with cameras, so your scenario is taped and rewatched, with feedback, during analysis. We also have 15 study rooms on the 1st floor and about another 15 on the 4th floor that are equipped with 42 LCD flat-screen TVs. You can hook your laptop up directly to the TV and watch lectures. It is great for group study and they are also utilized for group projects and other types of lectures. The anatomy lab is equipped with 9 flat-screens, light boxes and mobile dissection videocamera. The camera can be displayed on all of the TVs making demonstrations to the entire class very easy. The OPP lab is equipped with around 9 flat-screen TVs and has a nice stage area. There are 3 cameras surrounding the stage, so any angle can be shown. There is even a camera under the OPP table. The section of padding can be removed from the table revealing a clear plexi-glass top that the camera looks thru .so you can now see the patients back or neck or sacrum, plus of the hands of the examiner. This makes seeing hand-position when learning supine techniques incredibly easy to see. All of the tables are motorized for adjusting height. The clinical rooms, used for OSCEs are equipped with cameras, so can watch your exam and get feedback (of course the cameras are not on while real patients are in the room).
CLINICAL ROTATIONS: My class is the first to hit the rotations trail, and so far most of us are very happy. We utilize community hospitals for the bulk of our training, so most of the hospitals are under 300 beds. There are not any residencies setup at these sites, YET, so it is just you and the attending. The thing that is nice about having community hospitals is we have a ton of hands-on experience. We are first-assist on all surgeries, close up surgeries, delivering babies and do all kinds of procedures. It is an awesome experience. In addition, we have a TON of elective rotations. You get 4 during 3rd year (2 electives, 1 IM selective and 1 Surg selective) and 7 during 4th year (4 electives, 1 IM selective, 1 Surg selective and 1 Other selective). These can be done anywhere in the country, which is very nice. Our CORE electives are Peds, Psych, OB/Gyn, Surg, IM x2, EM (4th year), Rural Primary Care (4th year), and Community Health x 2 month (4th year basically a rotation at a smaller community hospital where you function like the house officer, doing everything from H&Ps to surgery to delivering a baby to the ER). You also get 1 month of vacation per year. We have around 13 CORE sites currently (with more in the works) and each takes anywhere from 8-24 students and the school sets up these rotations. Rotations are given out in a lottery system. You rank your top 50 sites and the computer gives you one of those. If I remember correctly, in the class below us, only 5 students got a rotation outside of their top 10 choices. One of the reasons for so many choices is because rotations are divided by cores .so you either have cores the first semester or second, and if you have them second, you get electives first semester. So lets say you really want to go to Rotation Site A and they take 24 students (12 per semester) .you will rank that rotation site 24 times (due to 24 different schedules), thus you have 24 of 50 spots ranked. If you really want cores first, then you rank all 50 spots as cores first, but you will end up ranking 4-5 different hospitals. So there are a lot of options available. You can look at my signature below and see what my schedule looks like this year. Most of the core sites will require moving from the LMU-DCOM campus area. Moving is not required for other core rotations because everything required by the school is within driving distance from your core site. LMU-DCOM does have preceptors signed-up to take students, in rotations ranging from family practice to trauma surgery. You can choose to do your electives/selectives with those docs, or you can do them with other docs around the country. If you choose to do rotations with docs on the list, then the school will set those up for you otherwise you setup your electives. Obviously, moving may be required for these rotations, but only for a month .but that is up to you depending on where you choose to do your electives. You can do all of your rotations without having to move fairly easily. In terms of residencies, the school is developing a couple right now .once they are finalized, I will post them on here.
HOUSING: Housing in the area is very cheap. You can find rental property ranging from $300-$1000 per month. Overall, finding a place isnt too hard, especially when one of the classes moves for rotations. The hardest thing people have in finding housing is a property that allows pets. There are new houses being built all over because of the medical students, so options are always increasing. The school also bought and renovated a hotel, which is now housing for only the medical and PA school. There are single units (the size of your average Holiday Inn room) and double units (size of 2 Holiday Inn rooms) and they are equipped with a small fridge/freezer, stove, microwave/convection oven, desk and queen size bed. Common washer/dryer on each floor too, along with more study rooms on the 4th floor, which are equipped with large tables and white boards. The rent for the student apartments isnt too bad (the exact amount is on the schools website).
STUDY AREAS/LIBRARY: As talked about above, we have about 30 study rooms within the building, and these rooms can seat up to 12 people. So there is plenty of room at the school to study. Each of the rooms have white boards covering 2 walls, which are super nice. There is additional study space in the library, but I didnt spend any time over there so I cant comment on how much room is over there. Our librarian is incredible. She is always finding stuff on the internet to help us study and learn, plus is always willing to answer questions regarding searching for articles, journals, etc. She is a very useful person to know, plus she is a pretty cool person too. Students can also study in the lecture rooms until 9:00pm each night.
BOARD PREP: The school provides a 10-day Kaplan review, which includes lectures, books and Kaplan Comlex qbank. The amount of free study time has increased since my class went thru board study (they dropped a 2-week system that was not needed), so you have about 5 weeks now. I dont know what the average comlex score was for my class, but the overall pass rate was around 92%. We also have some faculty members who teach for Kaplan, so they will give lectures covering topics the Kaplan review does not ..a very nice perk. Prep could have been better for our class, but looks like it has been fixed now.
ACCREDITATION: Until just prior to the first class graduating, the school will have provisional accreditation. Every year, COCA visits the school, assess the curriculum, clinical education, faculty, and talks to students and LMU-DCOM has always met and surpassed COCA standards. The last COCA visit was a week ago and the school passed with flying colors. There were no deficiencies noted, 3 accommodations (areas of excellence that go above and beyond COCA requirements) and 4 recommendations (areas that pass accreditation standards, but should be improved). The 4 recommendations were very minor and were in the process of being fixed prior to the COCA visit. I have absolutely no doubt that LMU-DCOM will become fully accredited in 2011, thus it is a non-issue in my mind.
SUMMARY: Overall, I have absolutely loved my time at LMU-DCOM. The school and faculty are amazing and there is such a great, family-like atmosphere here. The school is very receptive to student feedback, which is good for a new school. The technology is second-to-none and makes learning easier. The school is very progressive, adaptive and always striving to be better. Plus, there are projects in the works (that cant be stated on SDN) that will make the school one of the best osteopathic schools in the country. It is a very exciting school to be a part of and it is going to produce outstanding doctors. I am very proud to be in the inaugural class and look forward to seeing the school grow.
GRADES
Curriculum: A-
*Anatomy: A
*Basic Sciences: B+
*Micro: B-
*OPP/OMM: A
*Pharm: C- (would be lower if not for Dr. Babos .she is a life-saver)
*Clinical Training: A+
*Physio: A-
*Path: B (looking for a new path doc, hence the grade .the previous doc was awesome sad to see him go)
Location: B (great for studying and scenery, not for socializing or variety .need more restaurants locally)
Cost: B (on par with other schools .all DO schools need to decrease tuition)
Faculty: A
Reputation: B- (new school .but keep an eye out for us)
Technology: A+
Clinical Rotations: B+ (number of electives is awesome...core sites good but would like to see some bigger hospitals but still stay very hands-on like we have now .couple small kinks to work out since we are new)
Housing: B
Study Areas: A
OVERALL GRADE: A-
So, this thread has been around since i was in my M1 year, and at that time a lot of the beginning reviews were from M1 and M2's..which IMO doesnt mean squat. Only those that are at the end of their M4 or have already graduated are qualified to give proper reviews. So of course I have waited until I have matched to write this. Let me also say things have changed since my M1 year, so some of the M1/M2 info may not be accurate.
Curriculum: Mainly lecture based the first 2 years, with the first year consisting of basic sciences and the 2nd year broken down into systems (cardio, pulm, renal, etc). 2nd year incorporates PBL style learning thats held once every week or every other week to discuss a case with a preceptor. This mix in style of 90% lecture/10% PBL was a nice touch, better then the 100% lecture based for sure. Also in 1st year we have simulated patient exams already so by the time we take the COMLEX PE, its a breeze. Also during 1st year they start with patient contact from the beginning, shadowing docs once every other week on a friday, by 2nd year its one day a week, and of course by 3rd/4th year its everyday. Our school had a Harvey, so during 2nd year in the cardio section we would of course get to play with the simulator. It mimics tons of different heart sounds and breathing as well. I really wish i got to play with it more, o well. Everything else is pretty standard with anatomy labs and about 7 students per cadaver. The curriculum for M3/M4 years is setup so you have to do 3 months of IM, 2 months of Surg, FM, peds, 1 month of psych, obgyn,geriatrics during your 3rd year. There are different rotation sites for 3rd year which will be determined based on lottery. Most people get their first couple of choices. I got my 1st choice which was Mt. sinai. Other then Mt. sinai there is Broward general track, Florida hospital East in orlando, Suncoast hospital in tampa, Palmetto general hospital, VA/West palms/Columbia in west palm beach, and various others. Essentially 3rd year will be SET for you, so you dont have to worry about setting it up. I prefer it this way, a lot of stability. As 4th years you are required to do 1 ER month, 2 months rurals (suck), 1 month rural selective, and everything else you can select as electives but 2 months cant be the same thing. So if you are pursuing surgery then you cant have more then 2 months of general surgery rotations, but you can work around it and have an elective in laparoscopic surgery, colorectal, vascular, etc. Grading is numeric in M1/M2. And honors, pass, fail in M3/M4. The big negative in the curriculum is during 4th year. 3 months of rural? seriously? Sometimes the school schedules those rurals during audition months for residency which can be good or bad. Our year i believe was the last year they did NOT require students to have laptops. All the lectures are available online, which is why i dont really understand the attendance policy.
Location: No brainer, its South FL. The school itself is in Davie, which is about 15 min away from ft. lauderdale, 20 min away from ft. lauderdale beach/dania beach. About 45 min away from Miami/South beach all accessible by highway.
Cost: Tuition is increasing year by year. I started off at 32.5K for Out of State (cheaper for instate). This rate only lasted 2 years. By M3 i was paying over 35K, and M4 is where it reached 40K. Very classy NSU, hike up the tuition the years we dont ever use your facilities AND NSU is not known for paying hospitals to be affiliated with them SO who knows where the money is going, maybe towards a boat somewhere.
Faculty: Average i guess, Just like all schools some are good others arent. None were particularly malignant though.
Reputation: This isnt one of the oldest DO schools by any means. DMU, PCOM, CCOM, KCOM (and KCUMB i think) are the oldest ones. But i feel like our reputation is improving year by year. In terms of top tier DO schools i would put all the ones that get federal funding at the top with those previous mentioned. So schools like TCOM, OSU, UMDNJ. Then i would probably put NSU right under, if not right at that level.
Clinical rotations: The real strength i feel is in this category. Many tracks to choose from, each with its pros and cons. All are rather excellent. Most are big community hospitals with a wide variety of pathology. Speaking spanish will go a long way down here, but dont worry if you cant (i cant). Most attendings are pretty good, but i feel like you learn the most from the residents.
Housing: most students live near school in M1/M2, but in retrospect you can easily live in Las Olas (nice area near Ft. lauderdale downtown) in M1/M2 and it wont be a big deal. Cost of living is not bad at all if you have roommates. The most Ive paid for rent in the 4 years down here has not exceeded 600/month.
Study areas: The HPD (health professions dept) has its own library, which is of course shared by the DO, dentist, nurse anesthetist, PA, PT/OT, optometry, etc. NSU also has a ginormous library on its main campus not too far away (<5 min drive). Locally there are coffee houses, starbucks, barnes/nobles, etc. There are plenty of places to get your study on.
Social scene: Dont even need to comment on this. Miami + Ft. laudey FTW.
Preparation for boards: Like most other schools Kaplan is also offered. Other then that, not much. Not a big deal though, this is something you have to study on your own. They did however prepare us very well for the COMLEX PE.
Chances of specializing: In my class, So far (without the MD match because that hasnt happened yet), theres an ENT, Ophtho, 3 Ortho, Neurosurgery, Gen surg, many EM including myself, 3+ obgyn, Urology. So really its not bad.
Dress Code, Policies, Administration: Definately the weakest point of this school. There is a dress code, but i just wear scrub pants with a tshirt everyday. Attendance policy, many ways to work around this, use your imagination they take attendence based on swiping your id card. Its the popular thought that the school is trying to squeeze out as much money as they can from you. They also charge 220 for graduation! Thank god they didnt make us pay for cap/gown.
Report Card
Curriculum: B-
Location: A+
Cost: D
Faculty: B
Reputation: B+
Technology: A
Study Space/Library: B+
Library technology/Resources: B+
Rotations: A
Social: A+
Overall Grade: A-/B
I would come here again. Time passed by quick, made some friends for life. And matched into the specialty I wanted all along!👍
bump.
Any PCOM or UMDNJ-SOM students want to add a new review? 🙂
1st link in my sig
+4I am curious, too.
bump.
Any PCOM or UMDNJ-SOM students want to add a new review? 🙂
They give preference to those from or with ties to the NW. There are many attending there from states not in the NW, but not many.
They give preference to those from or with ties to the NW. There are some attending there from states not in the NW, but not many.
Western's new campus in Oregon will also be doing the same thing according to their website. I'm a big fan of what they are setting up for the new Western campus since I work at the main core hospital. I have not been nearly as impressed with PNWU, but they are so new that comparing them to Western is hardly fair.
Edit:
What I like about Western is that they have set up rotations and residency spots before opening up a whole new campus. I think it shows that they have a plan for their students and will make sure there is a spot for them to train in somthing they like when they finish. PNWU has not really released any information other than what cities will be used for rotations.
Hmm perhaps I'll do one tonight for PNWU. I can say right now, the cost is getting out of control. It keeps going up more than we are told it will go up.
Heck, UNECOM is more expensive than PNWU. UNECOM tuition last year was $43,120. Seeing as it goes up about 6% every year, it will be more expensive than PNWU this year (whose tuition is $44,650). No doubt.
UNECOM again proves why their students rank #1 in total student debt load. Way to go.
Heck, UNECOM is more expensive than PNWU. UNECOM tuition last year was $43,120. Seeing as it goes up about 6% every year, it will be more expensive than PNWU this year (whose tuition is $44,650). No doubt.
UNECOM again proves why their students rank #1 in total student debt load. Way to go.
NYCOM is up there, too, in the tuition department. $44,405 BEFORE all the additional fees (like health insurance).