Moving this to the random thread since it's not really a rant anymore...
General question: what advice do folks give on this topic to people who are interested in adopting a younger dog?
I feel like I could comfortably say which breeds I would recommend for new dog owners based on their individual lifestyle choices and personalities, but I have wondered about this on the adoption front. Sometimes generalizations can be made based on probable breed combos, but that's not possible to do for many mutts because their parentage is hard to determine.
Obviously for adult shelter dogs, I would say to rely on the shelter/rescue org/foster to help find a good match... but with puppies or dogs <1-2yrs old, I find it hard to determine if they will be high energy or low energy adults, easy to train or more challenging to train...etc.
And I know some of this can be overcome with good training and socialization, but not all of it.
I've been wondering about this from the perspective of advising clients/friends, but also curious about it for myself -- eventually I would like to get a dog and would like to consider a rescue dog... but in some ways, working with a conscientious breeder seems easier. Of course, every dog is an individual, but there are some general inherited tendencies that are seen more frequently in breeds. And for example, I like the look of border collies, but I would probably be a terrible border collie mom, so I worry I might go for a border collie-ish pup in a shelter and then later on be like "what have I done" (but then I would love them too much so I'd have to get a farm and some sheep? idk)