Quantcast

Rejecting students they know won't attend their school...

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

senzabee

Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
353
Reaction score
0

Members don't see this ad.
I was reading people's comments about what schools were easy to get into, and some where saying that although USN is "easy", some smart kids with degrees weren't granted an interview there (but got interviews elsewhere at better schools :eek: ).

Do you guys ever wonder if schools will reject you because they think you're too good of a candidate? Like, they know that you're applying to their program as a back up and that it would be a waste to admit you because you're just going to reject their offer anyways.
 

PharmacistApril

Pre-Pharmacy Student
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2006
Messages
62
Reaction score
0
senzabee said:
I was reading people's comments about what schools were easy to get into, and some where saying that although USN is "easy", some smart kids with degrees weren't granted an interview there (but got interviews elsewhere at better schools :eek: ).

Do you guys ever wonder if schools will reject you because they think you're too good of a candidate? Like, they know that you're applying to their program as a back up and that it would be a waste to admit you because you're just going to reject their offer anyways.

Yes and no I believe that can be true in a way ex. When I worked in Human Resources we rejected applicants because they were over qualified and they might become unhappy with the position down the line. Then again a candidate can have the best grades and they are not as "well rounded" as other applicants who have a lower gpa ex 3.5-.....
 

aboveliquidice

No sacrifice - No victory
Moderator Emeritus
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2006
Messages
2,812
Reaction score
26
Sadly I wont have to worry about that... :( I dont think you can be overqualified for Pharm School though. They truly do want the best of the best. If you dont attend a particular school - dont feel bad for them, they have somebody else with similar stats just waiting for a call on the waitlist.

Just my .02
 

Smilescali

Almost there...
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
May 21, 2004
Messages
623
Reaction score
6
senzabee said:
I was reading people's comments about what schools were easy to get into, and some where saying that although USN is "easy", some smart kids with degrees weren't granted an interview there (but got interviews elsewhere at better schools :eek: ).

Do you guys ever wonder if schools will reject you because they think you're too good of a candidate? Like, they know that you're applying to their program as a back up and that it would be a waste to admit you because you're just going to reject their offer anyways.
Not a chance. My point was (in the other thread) that USN is NOT an easy school to get into. They offer interviews based on points...the more points you have the more likely you are to get an interview, so the higher GPA you have, the higher number of points you will get...hence the more likely you will be granted an interview.

I have a 4.0 GPA, own my own business, do tons of charity work and USN didn't view me as over qualified. I interviewd early and was granted an early admission. My friends obviously didn't have enough points (based on their GPA's) to make USN's interview cut..., but yes they were granted interviews at so called "better" schools....USN looks mainly at your academic record and interview/communication skills. :)
 

Swanchick84

Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2005
Messages
246
Reaction score
0
senzabee said:
I was reading people's comments about what schools were easy to get into, and some where saying that although USN is "easy", some smart kids with degrees weren't granted an interview there (but got interviews elsewhere at better schools :eek: ).

Do you guys ever wonder if schools will reject you because they think you're too good of a candidate? Like, they know that you're applying to their program as a back up and that it would be a waste to admit you because you're just going to reject their offer anyways.


Regarding USN-
I'm from CA and my parents encouraged me to apply to USN b/c they have property next to the school. I went to Nevada with my parents and visited USN and got to talk to a pharmacy admissions counselor. We talked about the curriculum, school and such. She then asked me where I was taking my prerequsites. I told her at UCLA and that I would be getting my bachelor's. She then asked me my GPA, and knowing that the avg GPA for USN is ~3.7, I reluctantly said 3.2.

You know what the admissions lady said to me?

"Ohhh, you should take your courses at Petterson (referring to a community college)."

I'm not discrediting community colleges, b/c I'm going to one right now to retake a few pre-requsites. But come on! We all know that level of difficulty of courses is much tougher at 4-year universities.

Why does USN do this? It has to do with their grading system. They don't have grades. They only have P/NP. However, to pass, you have to get a 90% or above in all your courses. With this type of grading scale, the best way they can evaluate your success at USN is through GPA.

So folks...choose your schools wisely.
 

Seveneighty

ego sum venenum
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2005
Messages
180
Reaction score
0
Don't think this is the case, as it would be absolutely ridiculous.

"This guy/girl? Too qualified, they'll never go to our P.O.S. school. Knock this genius off the list and let's see if the next candidate is mediocre enough for us!"
 

senzabee

Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
353
Reaction score
0
Seveneighty said:
Don't think this is the case, as it would be absolutely ridiculous.

"This guy/girl? Too qualified, they'll never go to our P.O.S. school. Knock this genius off the list and let's see if the next candidate is mediocre enough for us!"

haha.

And I never did imply that I think USN is an easy school. I nearly used it as an example from the blog about easy schools and that other people mentioned it was easy, and I wondered if you would get rejected from "easy" schools in general for those reasons. Of course there are reasons other than grades that a 4.0 genius wouldn't get an interview offer and each school has different criteria or things they are looking for.
 
Top