Request advice about switching malpractice coverage

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

MedicalCorpse

MilMed: It's Dead, Jim
15+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
679
Reaction score
88
Since leaving the military in 2005, I have been continuously covered by The Doctors Company (TDC) for malpractice insurance coverage. My experience with them has been excellent.

Since starting solo locum tenens work, I have had to pay for coverage by myself. Let's say that they charge me $X/year.

Last night I got a call from the insurance broker who has worked with me and my prior group for twenty years. He is suggesting that I change to MagMutual, which he estimates will charge me 0.7 $X for full time work. If I work part time (less than 20 hours per week on average [actual patient contact hours]), he quoted me 0.4 $X with a free tail after one year of continuous coverage.

No one I've talked to has heard of this corporation. I tried to do some internet research on the company and physicians' reviews of working with them (including searching SDN), but couldn't find much.

Note that I will lose a large chunk of change as "Tribute" from TDC, which they pay out if you die, retire, or become disabled, if I voluntarily leave them. There's no way to get the money back if I am unhappy with MagMutual and try to return after more than 12 months. It's just gone. My broker points out that I would save that much money in the first three years of coverage at a lower price point. However, knowing myself, I doubt I would put the excess in a separate bank account to pass on to my children if I die suddenly vs. using it to pay expenses.

Sadly, unless I immediately get hit with a malpractice suit within a few days of switching to MagMutual, and the legal process finishes within less than a year, whether by settlement, adjudication, or trial, there is really no way for me to know whether I made the right decision until it's too late to save my Tribute plan funds.

Any advice?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Bigger issue is whether the new company is reliable with a good track record or not
 
I was with Mag Mutual and have my retirement tail for free through them. The company is physician owned and solid. One of the keys to choosing a company is the number of states they operate in and whether you ever plan to move out of their coverage area.
 
Since leaving the military in 2005, I have been continuously covered by The Doctors Company (TDC) for malpractice insurance coverage. My experience with them has been excellent.

Since starting solo locum tenens work, I have had to pay for coverage by myself. Let's say that they charge me $X/year.

Last night I got a call from the insurance broker who has worked with me and my prior group for twenty years. He is suggesting that I change to MagMutual, which he estimates will charge me 0.7 $X for full time work. If I work part time (less than 20 hours per week on average [actual patient contact hours]), he quoted me 0.4 $X with a free tail after one year of continuous coverage.

No one I've talked to has heard of this corporation. I tried to do some internet research on the company and physicians' reviews of working with them (including searching SDN), but couldn't find much.

Note that I will lose a large chunk of change as "Tribute" from TDC, which they pay out if you die, retire, or become disabled, if I voluntarily leave them. There's no way to get the money back if I am unhappy with MagMutual and try to return after more than 12 months. It's just gone. My broker points out that I would save that much money in the first three years of coverage at a lower price point. However, knowing myself, I doubt I would put the excess in a separate bank account to pass on to my children if I die suddenly vs. using it to pay expenses.

Sadly, unless I immediately get hit with a malpractice suit within a few days of switching to MagMutual, and the legal process finishes within less than a year, whether by settlement, adjudication, or trial, there is really no way for me to know whether I made the right decision until it's too late to save my Tribute plan funds.

Any advice?
Mag Mutual is solid.
 
Since leaving the military in 2005, I have been continuously covered by The Doctors Company (TDC) for malpractice insurance coverage. My experience with them has been excellent.

Since starting solo locum tenens work, I have had to pay for coverage by myself. Let's say that they charge me $X/year.

Last night I got a call from the insurance broker who has worked with me and my prior group for twenty years. He is suggesting that I change to MagMutual, which he estimates will charge me 0.7 $X for full time work. If I work part time (less than 20 hours per week on average [actual patient contact hours]), he quoted me 0.4 $X with a free tail after one year of continuous coverage.

No one I've talked to has heard of this corporation. I tried to do some internet research on the company and physicians' reviews of working with them (including searching SDN), but couldn't find much.

Note that I will lose a large chunk of change as "Tribute" from TDC, which they pay out if you die, retire, or become disabled, if I voluntarily leave them. There's no way to get the money back if I am unhappy with MagMutual and try to return after more than 12 months. It's just gone. My broker points out that I would save that much money in the first three years of coverage at a lower price point. However, knowing myself, I doubt I would put the excess in a separate bank account to pass on to my children if I die suddenly vs. using it to pay expenses.

Sadly, unless I immediately get hit with a malpractice suit within a few days of switching to MagMutual, and the legal process finishes within less than a year, whether by settlement, adjudication, or trial, there is really no way for me to know whether I made the right decision until it's too late to save my Tribute plan funds.

Any advice?
Why can’t your current company offer you a competitive rate to compete with Mag Mutual? Is your current company not taking into account the amount of time you have worked? Or is it because you have been with them so long your premiums have increased?
 
Why can’t your current company offer you a competitive rate to compete with Mag Mutual? Is your current company not taking into account the amount of time you have worked? Or is it because you have been with them so long your premiums have increased?

Interestingly, my insurance broker tried. Their best offer was to re-issue my contract for 30% less, which means I only owe a small amount for the rest of the year. If I switched to MagMutual, I'd be on the hook for two quarterly payments, which I could theoretically fund with the money I get refunded from Doctors Company.

So far, I've decided to stay with the excellent company I know (which operates in all 50 states), rather than lose the Tribute Plan money for good. Thanks to everyone who answered my post.
 
Last edited:
Top