Reverse WW - Game Thread

Started by Animal Midwife
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
genny said:
If that's true, wouldn't it be to the wolves' advantage to kill him tonight rather than going for a villager, and thus be dangerous to reveal? (Assuming his goal is to live longer since he initially claimed wolf.)
Click to expand...
Chaos' role is usually to live long enough to fulfill a requirement. So now it might be to die before a particular event or something. In regular WW the goal for everyone is to live so I'm assuming everyones goal now is to die. Ouch, my head.
 
Official "My, How the Tables Have Turned" D1 Lynch Tally

Barks (2) - Coop, Cubs
Pips () -
Cubs () -
MPM (1) - Miz
Miz (1) - Grebes
Allieh (1) - Pips
Sporty (3) - Frosty, genny, allie
MJ (1) - Sporty
Nav (1) - FTF
Coop (3) - mpm, dolphin, SAR
MsP (1) - Barks

Voting: 14/19
@SportPonies and @Coopah you are in the lead

Missing: @acanthuroidei @WildZoo @Navilly @Mad Jack @Ms Procrastinator

Lynch Deadline: 10 PM Eastern (~2 hrs)

1561139571238-png.268561
 
Ms Procrastinator said:
Chaos' role is usually to live long enough to fulfill a requirement. So now it might be to die before a particular event or something. In regular WW the goal for everyone is to live so I'm assuming everyones goal now is to die. Ouch, my head.
Click to expand...
I get what you're trying to say here, but there's information in the opening post about the village win condition and the wolf win condition. There's nothing about 3rd parties and how that might play into parity.

Barkley13 said:
I don’t even want to think about third parties because I’m barely starting to understand the game. Plus there’s no reason to actually think there’s any rn
Click to expand...
And there is actually reason to think there aren't any
 
Animal Midwife said:
Official "My, How the Tables Have Turned" D1 Lynch Tally

Barks (2) - Coop, Cubs
Pips () -
Cubs () -
MPM (1) - Miz
Miz (1) - Grebes
Allieh (1) - Pips
Sporty (3) - Frosty, genny, allie
MJ (1) - Sporty
Nav (1) - FTF
Coop (3) - mpm, dolphin, SAR
MsP (1) - Barks

Voting: 14/19
@SportPonies and @Coopah you are in the lead

Missing: @acanthuroidei @WildZoo @Navilly @Mad Jack @Ms Procrastinator

Lynch Deadline: 10 PM Eastern (~2 hrs)

1561139571238-png.268561
Click to expand...
Feels weird that my three people I feel like are talking too much and are giving me feelings have all not voted... 😱
 
grebes4lyfe said:
I’ve never seen Ms P so chatty and idk if I’m reading it village or not. In a normal game I’d read her village but it’s hard to tell since a wolf *would* be trying to draw attention to themselves.
I think I’m leaning village but not sure enough to change my vote there.

Cubs and navs quick role reveals were a little skeevy to me (as others have said)

Idk wtf to make of MJ.

Not feeling great about FTF but also never played w them. Can’t put my finger on why I find him sketch, but I do.

I guess everyone else is reading neutral to village.
Click to expand...
And that to me is wolfy lol if Ms P is a wolf then I feel like you are too
 
Ok so for the people who are reading Sporty as village, what about this exchange makes you feel good about her?
SportPonies said:
I don’t think I even understand what affiliation I am, so everything is fine.

Everything.

Is.

Fine.
Click to expand...
SportPonies said:
Since you put nav on ignore and he mentioned it, I’m checking: you know that the game is backwards and you want to lynch village, right?
Click to expand...
Mad Jack said:
Oh wait, am I supposed to want to die then? I literally can't tell. Kill me I guess? This is too complicated for me, and I don't have time to read the reverse WW thread to understand. All I know is that I'm a wolf and I don't know what the hell to do with that information
Click to expand...

When I read that, it feels like Sporty was geared up to vote for MJ before he even really opened his mouth, and then he is basically echoing her and she's feeding him an out. I'm not really getting where people are reading that as village.

FrostySparrow said:
Sorry for that! I’ll be more careful of that from now on.
Going to avoid MJ for now, I don’t like what’s going on there and the thought of worrying about another party with a potential different win condition is something I don’t want to worry about right now, unless an experienced player can share why we would want to worry about that Rn.
Click to expand...
I don't think we do have to worry about it.

But you are voting for someone who is supporting that line of thinking, which doesn't make a ton of sense to me
 
Official "My, How the Tables Have Turned" D1 Lynch Tally

Barks (2) - Coop, Cubs
Pips (1) - MsP
Cubs () -
MPM (1) - Miz
Miz (1) - Grebes
Allieh (1) - Pips
Sporty (3) - Frosty, genny, allie
MJ (1) - Sporty
Nav (1) - FTF
Coop (3) - mpm, dolphin, SAR
MsP (1) - Barks
genny (1) - dubz

Voting: 16/19
Sporty and Coop you are in the lead

Missing: acan, Nav, MJ

Lynch Deadline: 10 PM Eastern (~1 hr)

1561139571238-png.268561
 
genny said:
I don't see that as w/w exchange. MJ would get screamed at in PM not to let out that he's wolfy.
Click to expand...
So you think he just decided to say he was wolfy for the shiggles?

There would be no point in faking something like that if village, because all it has done is move him out of the lynch options for a bunch of people. That's counter to the win condition of both affiliations.
 
PippyPony said:
Cuts deep

But also I'm interested in your choice here. Can you elaborate?
Click to expand...
tbh I trust genny and I was trying to pick between either sporty or coop and after seeing genny's vote I decided to go there too. I didn't read the convo between her and MJ the same way you did
 
PippyPony said:
Ok so for the people who are reading Sporty as village, what about this exchange makes you feel good about her?




When I read that, it feels like Sporty was geared up to vote for MJ before he even really opened his mouth, and then he is basically echoing her and she's feeding him an out. I'm not really getting where people are reading that as village.


I don't think we do have to worry about it.

But you are voting for someone who is supporting that line of thinking, which doesn't make a ton of sense to me
Click to expand...
Your *logic* can suck my balls, Pip
 
FrostySparrow said:
I would like to avoid a 1:1 scenario if it can be help though. That thought makes me super nervous and anxious about “what ifs” for that scenario.... more “what ifs” than ww normally does.
Especially since we don’t know how many wws there are. I’m thinking this is a safe place to lynch.

Lynch sporty
Click to expand...
although...I remember now when I saw this post I thought it was sketch. Feels kind of like manufactured concern over a situation that I feel is pretty unlikely to happen. So not sure what to make of Frosty voting for Sporty.

Also yes I'm going to continue to point out people I think are wolfy and those that have said "why bother" get sketch points in my mind too
 
PippyPony said:
So you think he just decided to say he was wolfy for the shiggles?

There would be no point in faking something like that if village, because all it has done is move him out of the lynch options for a bunch of people. That's counter to the win condition of both affiliations.
Click to expand...
So your thinking is Sporty's wolfy, gives wolfy MJ an out for possibly saying some sketch stuff, and he follows that up with admitting he's a wolf. I just don't see that happening.
 
Official "My, How the Tables Have Turned" D1 Lynch Tally

Barks (2) - Coop, Cubs
Pips (1) - MsP
Cubs () -
MPM (1) - Miz
Miz (1) - Grebes
Allieh (2) - Pips, acan
Sporty (3) - Frosty, genny, allie
MJ (1) - Sporty
Nav (1) - FTF
Coop (3) - mpm, dolphin, SAR
MsP (1) - Barks
genny (1) - dubz

Voting: 17/19
Sporty and Coop you are in the lead

Missing: Nav, MJ

Lynch Deadline: 10 PM Eastern (~30 min)

1561139571238-png.268561
 
Navilly said:
I would be mad too if I didn’t understand the game and made a major flubber early on
Click to expand...
Harebrained theory I have makes this post seem wolfy to me. Based on my role PM and theories about MJ’s posts, Nav just seems... not village here. Trying to figure out how to explain it in English and not gibberish.

Alternate tinfoily tinfoil and they’re both wolf lol I hate this game.
 
Official "My, How the Tables Have Turned" D1 Lynch Tally

Barks (3) - Coop, Cubs, Pippy
Pips (1) - MsP
Cubs () -
MPM (1) - Miz
Miz (1) - Grebes
Allieh (1) - acan
Sporty (3) - Frosty, genny, allie
MJ (1) - Sporty
Nav (1) - FTF
Coop (3) - mpm, dolphin, SAR
MsP (1) - Barks
genny (1) - dubz

Voting: 17/19
Sporty, Coop, and @Barkley13 you are in the lead

Missing: Nav, MJ

Lynch Deadline: 10 PM Eastern (~15 min)

1561139571238-png.268561
 
You must log in or register to reply here.