Dr. Will said:
If you're at a top 25 medical school, why do you care about CMS? No body in this world cares about where you went to medical school, they seem to care more about where you trained. The school is putting out quality docs going into strong programs and that's all that matters. And as I said, if these people are getting their top choices, what does it matter?!
Do you feel threatened by those of us that attend this school? If not, who cares. As far as this PD...that's one out of how many programs, in how many specialties that have something negative to say. This person probably doesn't have their facts straight anyways, just like most people who were so worried about the probabtion incident from the year prior (it was a bunch of BS due to an old administration from years ago). Point is, for every negative comment I've heard, I've heard even more positives.
I want to be a doctor, and I've worked hard enough that I will get a residency in what I choose. I don't need a "big name" to be happy. If the program suits my needs and wants, that's all that matters to me. Too many people put too much importance on name alone. Work hard, it pays off.
And your friend with a 22 MCAT...the only thing that matters is how she faired in the match. If she worked hard and made up for any undergrad deficiencies, good for her. Then the program worked and found someone deserving that may have had a bad day.