- Joined
- May 7, 2014
- Messages
- 1,780
- Reaction score
- 3,834
- Points
- 5,966
- Attending Physician
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I have been following with great interest the debate on whether the ASTRO PAC should not give campaign contributions to candidates who challenged President Biden's election. While withholding money would certainly put ASTRO on record against questioning the reality-based community, there is so much more that ASTRO could do to draw a clear line in the sand.
To start with, ASTRO could bar Trump supporters from leadership roles in the organization, and from giving invited talks and chairing scientific sessions at ASTRO-sponsored meetings. The next step would be to reduce the value of a Trump supporter's vote in ASTRO elections, or even to deny Trump supporters the right to vote in ASTRO elections altogether. A further step would be to simply deny Trump supporters membership in ASTRO. In parallel with this, ASTRO could push to have Trump supporters barred from holding academic faculty positions, and could even propose that Trump supporters' ABR board certifications, and even their medical school diplomas be revoked.
In order to identify Trump supporters, the ASTRO membership application/renewal form could add the question: "Have you ever donated money to the Trump campaign or any other organization affiliated with Donald Trump, have you ever worked on a Trump political campaign, have you ever spoken or written towards his behalf, or in any way, are you now, or have you ever been a Trump supporter?" Of course, not all Trump supporters will answer this question truthfully, so to identify the Trump supporters hiding in the attic, so to speak, social media could be reviewed and co-workers, neighbors, and even family could be queried, an approach which has seen some success in the past in other situations.
While I am sure there will be some debate over these measures, it is important that ASTRO be seen as a leader in going along with the spirit of the times.
------------------------------
David Shimm MD
President
Beckley Oncology Associates
Beckley, WV 25801
304-253-6060 x232
To start with, ASTRO could bar Trump supporters from leadership roles in the organization, and from giving invited talks and chairing scientific sessions at ASTRO-sponsored meetings. The next step would be to reduce the value of a Trump supporter's vote in ASTRO elections, or even to deny Trump supporters the right to vote in ASTRO elections altogether. A further step would be to simply deny Trump supporters membership in ASTRO. In parallel with this, ASTRO could push to have Trump supporters barred from holding academic faculty positions, and could even propose that Trump supporters' ABR board certifications, and even their medical school diplomas be revoked.
In order to identify Trump supporters, the ASTRO membership application/renewal form could add the question: "Have you ever donated money to the Trump campaign or any other organization affiliated with Donald Trump, have you ever worked on a Trump political campaign, have you ever spoken or written towards his behalf, or in any way, are you now, or have you ever been a Trump supporter?" Of course, not all Trump supporters will answer this question truthfully, so to identify the Trump supporters hiding in the attic, so to speak, social media could be reviewed and co-workers, neighbors, and even family could be queried, an approach which has seen some success in the past in other situations.
While I am sure there will be some debate over these measures, it is important that ASTRO be seen as a leader in going along with the spirit of the times.
------------------------------
David Shimm MD
President
Beckley Oncology Associates
Beckley, WV 25801
304-253-6060 x232
