Hi, this might be too early - I'm a C/O 2025 hopeful - but being a non-trad I'm trying to plan ahead of time. I'm also most interested in IM vs. ECC. One thing I never really figure out is, if I decide not to be a criticalist, do I benefit doing a rotating internship before working in ER? I know some ER doctors get the job fresh out of school, without a horrible internship year.
Another question is, if I want to leave my options open regarding specializing, is research experience in vet school helpful? Or shall I devote more time and energy shadowing in the teaching hospital?
I believe that if you want to do ER that doing a internship is beneficial. There may be a few new grads that can jump into ER off the bat but I think not that many places are setup to take new grads on ER and train them vs just throwing a warm body into the mix and hoping for the best. Do they exist— yes are there many—no.
I think that the internship year doesn’t have to be a horrible year and indeed a good internship shouldn’t be a horrible year. Will you work longer hours and get paid less than an associate—yes. I was picky in my job hunt and that has paid off. Some things to think about in evaluating a internship or job offer:
What is the schedule like? 6 days?5days/week? 4days/week? Work 6 days and required rounds/journal club is day seven? On call—for surgeries?scope? Backup on the floor? Are those days clumped or spread out? Which do you like—working a stretch and then a clump off or never having a “long” week? Are you on a internal medicine rotation but still work Saturday overnight ER—-ie mixing specialist and ER coverage? In my opinion you should still have at least one day off and out of the hospital a week if this is a associate position more. Ie not needing to come in for rounds,not on call, not working that night. Ask how much time on primary receiving you have vs time shadowing specialists. How much of the year is overnights vs day vs swing? How much elective time is there? Do they have a specialist in your chosen area of interest or if not is there elective time you can use for that? How much overlap of doctors is there—multiple doctors on at a time helps spread the load, you will likely be on alone at night—-but is that all the time? After 6 or 9 or after midnight? Do you have someone you can call with questions on cases or are you left without support until morning?
Depending on your goals “good” answers to those questions may vary. Ie if you want to do ER a good chunk of time in ER vs with specialist is good. If you really have your heart set on a dermatology residency maybe more time with specialists/more elective time is helpful. If you want a residency often a true rotating internship is what they are looking for if looking at ER could do either rotating or ECC internship just look to see if they accept new grads.
See the VIRMP website if you have no idea what I am talking about.
I personally think a mix of time with other doctorand time alone is helpful to make you trust yourself. But having phone back up is great. I still occasionally call my criticalists on cases that are crumping to see if they have any pearls of advice— although it is sometimes disheartening to hear keep doing what your doing when what your doing is not making any headway! We also have two locations so can phone a friend if it’s something I don’t want to wake a criticalist for but want someone’s thoughts. Often just talking through the case can be helpful.
I highly recommend getting contact info for current/prior interns and would also consider getting associate info and emailing them. Ideally you would do a externship during fourth year at places you think you like— you may find you love it or it may be different than you expect. Covid has made that a lot harder but hopefully will be better soon.
Hope that helps! Happy to talk specifics about the practice I work for if you message me.
as far as research I think most residencies require a publication not sure if that can be from prior to the residency or not! Research time doesn’t hurt—especially if you found something more clinical in a area of interest.