So the best poker players are simply just lucky?
Well, at its most basic, it's still what cards are dealt. No one is getting rich just folding his hole cards time and again. Just like poker, a lot of it is being in the right place, at the right time, which means that, the better one can recognize those right times, the better one does. However, the randomness is in there. To go back to poker, "you don't play the cards, you play the man", but, when the cards get flipped, if you are mismatched off suit, there's nothing, and, if you went to the end, it's what hand you have.
The point is, Phil Hellmuth and Daniel Negreaneau could math out what their hole cards could do much, much better then the average Joe, but, it's still random from that deal, and, evaluating those cards is like evaluating those stocks and funds. You gotta be in the right place at the right time. Who is it, the pain doc here on SDN, with the tag line, "All in at the wrong time"? That's where you don't want to be. I don't doubt that there were such massive gains (congrats!), but, the question is, is it replicable? Some people just **** on other people that post that they made a killing day trading, but, the question, again, is, is it replicable? If someone can do that, hell, throw the medicine RIGHT in the bin, and get rich, and, get out!!
("Bin" is British for "garbage can")
(I'm not British)