pretty accurate assessments. you may not have a ton of responses because there aren't a ton of people that go through there-- and there are plenty of other craptastic bases to have the chance to go to. i was there from 2007 to 2011 on the primary care end, the end of which i was dept chief.
to me, the upside was cheap living, having a smaller atmosphere where people (for the most part, if you were nice to them) would help you, and having a small medical staff that also got along pretty well. the base also had a decent amount of stuff. with subspecialty care so far and such a long wait away, you can also do as much as you want in the subspecialty arena. the place survived from an inpatient workload basis on trainees, old farts, and the mother baby unit. their "ICU" was not really, so most sick people transferred out. though now they have some whacky "virtual ICU" thing that is a disaster waiting to happen (saw it on their Facebook page).
the downside was the remote location, all chain restaurants (the place just got a panera right before we left) and the tendency of the hospital commanders and DCCS types to change for the sake of changing when they arrive. it's a pitstop for most on the way to O-6 or trying to get a star, so all kinds of bat**** ideas and oddities will come down. the remoteness i think allows them to kind of do whatever they want. also, the union is strong and if you are in a position of leadership good f-ing luck getting anything accomplished. the "ER" was staffed by a bunch of castaways when i first arrived, but after my obligatory deployment it seemed they picked up a couple of real ones. the facilities are also old.
all in all, it was not *horrible*-- and clinically it was probably a good experience. but personally i'd never homestead or want to raise a family there. and i'm even from MO, lol.
put in your time, then leverage the **** outta the tour and get something nice next go round 🙂
good luck
your friendly neighborhood ex-lost in the woods caveman