Teach for America (Yes, I know about the search function)

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

loveoforganic

-Account Deactivated-
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2009
Messages
4,218
Reaction score
14
I went through about 150 posts of TFA threads and mostly found discussions that devolved into debates about the efficacy of the program. Not what I'm looking for.

Anyway. To those of you who have gone or are going through the program -


1) What grade/subject are you teaching? Rural/Inner city?

2) What has your general experience been like? i.e. positive/negative, motivating/demotivating, etc.

3) Has your school had adequate materials to teach in a manner you believe is effective? If not, are the resources you need coverable out of your own pocket?

4) Have you been able to find motivated teachers and students?

5) Do you feel your salary was enough to live on comfortably or does it cut it very close?

6) Do you feel you made a difference? Would you do it again?


Thanks for your time.
 
You might want to try contacting Teach for America, a representative or alumni, through their website. I have also considered joining Teach for America, and meeting with alumni, representatives, and friends I knew who did the program really shaped my understanding of it, pro's and con's alike.
 
I suppose that would be an option. Mostly concerned about getting skewed results from someone who would put themselves in that position for TFA.
 
Wow, that is a scary story, but surely that is a rarity. 😱

I wish it was a rarity, but I doubt it. I live in Baltimore city, and our public schools are notorious for this kind of behavior. I've been fortunate enough to enroll my kids in charter schools that have, so far, been able to separate the juvenile delinquent element from the regular kids, but most of my friends' kids (and kids' friends) go to schools that sound just like this one - stabbings, accusations against teachers, desperate overcrowding, very little actual education. It's no wonder the city has so much crime - these kids aren't being taught anything, just warehoused for a few years and then released into the wild with no skills, academic or social. There is precious little parental or community support and the teachers are criminally underpaid (it always makes me cringe a little to see the threads on here about how "Obamacare" might cut dr. salaries to a mere 5-10 times what a teacher makes). It's heartbreaking and frustrating.

/soapbox
 
Hey,I did Teach for America 2006-2008.

1) What grade/subject are you teaching? Rural/Inner city?

Atlanta (college park), 9th grade biology

2) What has your general experience been like? i.e. positive/negative, motivating/demotivating, etc.

It had very high highs and low lows, overall positive but incredibly stressful and difficult.

3) Has your school had adequate materials to teach in a manner you believe is effective? If not, are the resources you need coverable out of your own pocket?

No, not really. However, there is grant money and stuff out there to help. You learn to make do with a lot less in underfunded schools. I know a lot of TFA teachers who do have enough of a budget, that wasn't the case for me though.

4) Have you been able to find motivated teachers and students?

Yes. Some of my coworkers were some of the most amazing people ever, some sucked. Students, yes, same as the teachers. Some were awesome and inspiring, some I helped a lot and got to watch grow, and a lot I never got through to.

5) Do you feel your salary was enough to live on comfortably or does it cut it very close?

YES, but this depends on the area. Atlanta teachers make really good money, about 40K to start which is plenty in this city, especially for being right out of undergrad.

6) Do you feel you made a difference? Would you do it again?

Yes, yes.

PM me if you want more info.
 
Thanks a bunch for the reply, definitely will if I can think of anything else relevant 🙂
 
Did you try the search function?

shakefist.gif
 
1) What grade/subject are you teaching? Rural/Inner city? Inner-city.

2) What has your general experience been like? i.e. positive/negative, motivating/demotivating, etc. Extremely positive. Changed my life. Made me a better person and all that jazz.

3) Has your school had adequate materials to teach in a manner you believe is effective? If not, are the resources you need coverable out of your own pocket? Yes, school had good resources but I did spend a lot of my salary on my kids because I wanted to (ice cream parties, etc).

4) Have you been able to find motivated teachers and students? Yes to motivated teachers. If you can't find motivated students, it's your (teacher's) fault.

5) Do you feel your salary was enough to live on comfortably or does it cut it very close? Eh...I lived EXTREMELY comfortably...when I would go out, I would drop tons of money on drinks. However, I was 22 with no student debt or family to support at the time. It is beyond manageable if you're single or have a SO. With kids, it might be tough. Basically, you'll make 40k/yr+benefits. Believe it or not, I think teachers get paid ridic amounts. You gain a lot of money from doing after school activities which are basically babysitting gigs and you only work 9 months of the year. Add that to all the sick days, personal days, universal days, staff development days, etc and it's a pretty sweet deal.

I wrote about this stuff in my blog a whiles back if you're interested.

With respect to the article that was linked previously, keep in mind that in all things you're going to encounter a range of experiences. There are a lot of people that like what they do and a lot that don't (and this goes for everything, including med school). Those that extremely disliked their experience are naturally going to be quite vocal about it. It is what you make it. Teach For America will change your life and allow you to be a better person if you can be sold on its ideals.

6) Do you feel you made a difference? Would you do it again?
Hells yeah.
 
1) What grade/subject are you teaching? Rural/Inner city?

High school chemistry (grades 10-12), inner city.

2) What has your general experience been like? i.e. positive/negative, motivating/demotivating, etc.

Positive and motivating, but it depends on your school. I've had the experience of working for different schools my first and second year. My first year, I taught at a large school that had an inefficient administration. I had very little support from the administrators. There was low morale amongst the teachers, who felt that the admins were not doing a good job. Professional development consisted of b---- sessions. Classes were HUGE. Increases in class size make it exponentially harder to manage classes. Students do not learn well in classes that are not managed well. My largest class last year consisted of 47 students. In the end, students suffered.

I am currently teaching at a completely different school this year. It's been a completely different experience. People here care about the school. Administrators are very supportive and all teachers here try their best to do well. There are also a ton of resources here. Plus, second year is generally easier and I'm teaching an easier curriculum.

Unfortunately, most schools where TFAeres are found lack efficient administrators or sufficient supplies, or both. TFA does not place corps members in schools that are above a certain API (700 or so). Student test scores are usually too high for TFA to place in schools that have good admin AND money.

3) Has your school had adequate materials to teach in a manner you believe is effective? If not, are the resources you need coverable out of your own pocket? My first year, no. Second year, yes.

Your experience will depend on your school. There are always free resources and grants, especially if you plan on teaching science. You just have to look for them.

4) Have you been able to find motivated teachers and students?

Always! Sadly, there are also many demotivated teachers as well. Just don't hang out with them. They give bad advice. One of the veteran teachers at my old school told me to have my students trace science comics strips.

5) Do you feel your salary was enough to live on comfortably or does it cut it very close?

It's a good salary. I live in the city, pay 1k a month for rent, a few thousand for tuition, and I still have money leftover. For those of you going straight from college to TFA, where you're used to NOT spending, it'll be more than enough money.

6) Do you feel you made a difference? Would you do it again?

I think so. And yes, I would.

Just as a WARNING:

It's hard. All you do your first year is work work work work work, and when you're not working, you're thinking or dreaming about work. It's not an 8-5 job. You teaching from 8-3 or so, then go home and make phone calls, lesson plan, grade, etc. There's ALWAYS more you can do to make your classroom better.

Not all corps members make significant gains. It's easier to a make these gains when you're in elementary school, but it's more difficult at the upper grades. If you are a science major (likely), you'll be asked to teach secondary science (middle or high school science), one of the most difficult subjects to teach and coincidentally one of the most needed (we have to import science teachers from other countries to fill all the spots).

Don't do it to make your med school apps or your resume look better. If you do, you'll end up dreading school every day and wondering why you didn't do something easier. TFA is a good extracurricular but unlike what the website advertises, it won't make you a shoo in for med schools. I know many corps members that were fantastic teachers, yet did not get into an MD school. In the end, if that's all you're doing it for, all TFA is is a time-consuming extracurricular, a job.

PM me if you want to know more info.
 
This definitely wouldn't be for med school apps. Thanks a bunch for the info, both of you 🙂
 
Top