Teladoc, k health .... telemedicine

  • Thread starter Thread starter deleted497653
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
D

deleted497653

anybody have experience with these companies or telemedicine for urgent care type consults overbthe phone or video. They pay 23/10 minute phone consult. Teladoc lets you work whenever you want and as little or as much as you like.


I saw online only a few reviews having to do with being called when you don’t want to be called.

I’m trying to decide if it’s a good side gig. Financially I can make more just doing one or two more shift.


Thanks in advance.

Members don't see this ad.
 
I must have missed that one. Thanks.

They seem to offer less money now...
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Telemedicine for undifferentiated patients in the wild is a great development for 1) telemedicine companies trying to profit and 2) insurance companies and group benefit plans trying to save money.

I know of 0 docs who feel like it's been fulfilling personally or financially. The pay is atrocious. The liability is unknown as there have yet to be any major suits, but they will eventually happen. Your ability to assess a patient is, at best, very limited.

Ask yourself whose interests these types of businesses really serve. One of these companies reached out to me about doing telehealth via text-message only communication with patients. There is no voice or video contact. Let that sink in for a second. The premise of this must sound great to the MBA marketing the service or the millennial patient who wants antibiotics because...Google. How does that sound to you?

If you find one of these companies that actually provides legitimate value to patients while allowing you to practice good medicine while being fairly compensated let me know. In the meantime, I'll be hanging out in the salt mines.
 
-S*** pay - $23 / ten minute consult? That's about 1/2 what I make in the ED. And you still have to deal with patients. And after you consider the fact that I'm seeing nowhere near 6 pph in the ED for my rate, this makes it even less palatable

-No vitals and limited assessment = high liability

-Probably a z-pack / steroid mill...don't wanna play? - ok you're fired.
 
Telemedicine for undifferentiated patients in the wild is a great development for 1) telemedicine companies trying to profit and 2) insurance companies and group benefit plans trying to save money.

I know of 0 docs who feel like it's been fulfilling personally or financially. The pay is atrocious. The liability is unknown as there have yet to be any major suits, but they will eventually happen. Your ability to assess a patient is, at best, very limited.

Ask yourself whose interests these types of businesses really serve. One of these companies reached out to me about doing telehealth via text-message only communication with patients. There is no voice or video contact. Let that sink in for a second. The premise of this must sound great to the MBA marketing the service or the millennial patient who wants antibiotics because...Google. How does that sound to you?

If you find one of these companies that actually provides legitimate value to patients while allowing you to practice good medicine while being fairly compensated let me know. In the meantime, I'll be hanging out in the salt mines.

I agree it's generally poor patient care, but the few docs I know who have done it made $200 plus an hour.
 
It doesn't work that way. It's not a flat rate. They would maximize bonuses, pick certain shifts etc. American Well and maybe MDLive. Both during cold and flu season.
 
anybody have experience with these companies or telemedicine for urgent care type consults overbthe phone or video. They pay 23/10 minute phone consult. Teladoc lets you work whenever you want and as little or as much as you like.


I saw online only a few reviews having to do with being called when you don’t want to be called.

I’m trying to decide if it’s a good side gig. Financially I can make more just doing one or two more shift.


Thanks in advance.


I recently started doing Teladoc to see what it was about. It does not seem "worth it" in the sense that you really have to grind to make any sort of real money. Outside of flu season the volume is not there unless you're using multiple telemedicine services with multiple state licenses and at that point you're really working for it.

I do it when I'm at home watching TV and bored. You can see the chief complaint and look at patient demographics prior to accepting any encounter. I tend to avoid elderly, pediatrics, abdominal pain, etc. As others have mentioned it is a little nerve racking to evaluate a patient with such limited information, but I think all parties acknowledge this limitation. It is significant to note that no major lawsuits have occurred despite this service being around for many years thus far. I always put in the discharge instructions to follow up in a reasonable time with PCP or ER if symptoms don't improve and also verbalize this over the phone.

I may quit doing it soon since it's not very satisfying nor lucrative, but I'd give it a try because you may like it. There's a couple people I know doing almost full time telemedicine (not Teladoc specifically) and seem happy. They were clearly burned out from regular EM, enjoying the stay at home environment and flexibility despite the significant drop in pay (and career satisfaction in my opinion).
 
anybody have experience with these companies or telemedicine for urgent care type consults overbthe phone or video. They pay 23/10 minute phone consult. Teladoc lets you work whenever you want and as little or as much as you like.


I saw online only a few reviews having to do with being called when you don’t want to be called.

I’m trying to decide if it’s a good side gig. Financially I can make more just doing one or two more shift.


Thanks in advance.

Not a frequent poster but I am writing here to not only answer your questions but also to spread awareness about what these telemedicine companies are about and the pitfalls of working under them.

I have worked with many: doctor on demand, Teladoc, Mdlive, k health, lemonaid, Amwell.

In order to give you a better overview of how these companies, I will break this down by how you will interact with a patient and how you will get paid.

1. Patient Interactions
usually most of these platforms are phone or video which is synchronous; you interact with the patient in real time. now, some companies are offering text/chat based interactions in real time. others do this ASYNCHRONOUS, where the patient leaves a message and you answer it when you get the message(usually with 24 hours of receipt)

doctor on demand,-video only ,synchronous
Teladoc, phone and video,synchronous
Mdlive,phone and video, synchronous
k health,text only ,sometimes asynchronous
lemonaid, text , sometimes phone ,sometimes asynchronous
Amwell.video only,synchronous

personally, the one i disliked the most is video. it ties me to the computer and I have to sitting there with white coat over my jammies and shorts to give the facade of being in the office. i also have to make sure i dont have anything in the background(no screaming kids, no barking dog or running around, no pot about to boil).

with all of the above there is risk to ones license with ALL of the above tech formats. much more so than a regular in person visit. all of the companies provide malpractice for you, however the litigious aspect of this telemedicine industry is unknown at present and with covid increasing the usage of it, it will only become more intense. patients are now relying on telemedicine for everything. i have had patients call when they clearly were septic or having chest pain. do i direct to the ER? Of course. are the patients about it? nope. does that affect patient satisfaction? yes. do the telemedicine companies care about patient satisfaction? yes.

however most patients call about the common cold and demand antibiotics. i had one patient demand antibiotics because he saw someone cough and he wanted augmenting 'just to head things off'.

so this pushes the doctor into a tough position ; scylla and charybdis are the companies' interests and the patient's interests. no body gives a hoot about you the physician.

2. how you get paid
this varies somewhat. usually it is anywhere from $9 to $23 per consult. if that seems paltry, it is. unfortunately, the only way to make this lucrative is get multiple state licenses(at least 6-10) AND make sure you keep your consults as short as possible. now there are two problems with the latter approach. one is the patients don't like to be rushed and with the pandemic, patients are treating telemedicine visits like primary care office visits. i had one guy call about his cold sore and it lasted for over 20 minutes. usually btw that is not even a 3 minute visit. then you have patients who chronic problems and want a 'second opinion' from you and they will talk forever. the other flip to the coin is again the telemedicine company itself. they also want you to see as many consults as you can, because the brings in more revenue for them, but they also want you to take more time with the patients, to improve patient satisfaction , and also to appease more insurance companies, who are now using telemed companies . again, as the doc, you are in the inferior position.

most will pay you on a 1099 as an independent contractor, k health only pays on a w2 as a salary which is 80K per year and you have give them scheduled 20 hours per week at least.


now that i have got that out of the way. the biggest danger with telemedicine is not the patient, at least not yet. the biggest one is the telemedicine company itself. the one i warn you to strongly stay away from is teladoc. this company is highly dysfunctional and unscrupulous. they have leadership which is also a revolving door and they have been reporting doctors to NPDB, the national practitioner data bank, of which I am now one. they are reporting anyone who is resigning from their company, under false pretenses. this company has singlehandedly managed to mess up my career. and btw, for those not familiar, the NPDB reports are permanent and are NEVER removed unless the reporting entity, chooses to do so, Teladoc in my case. another thing i disliked about Teladoc was they were also incredibly dishonest about the pay and reimbursement for licenses, where they promised to reimburse the cost of those but ending up backing out, leaving me with footing the bill, of over $5k. i have had to hire entire attorney and that has already cost me another $6k.

if you have further commments or questions, put them up here.

IF YOU ARE A RESIDENT/FELLOW/MEDICAL STUDENT, DON'T DO TELEMEDICINE. It will destroy your career. I am attending in a teaching institution and I don't want anyone to deal with these business who are out to screw doctors and doctors in training. i thought this would be a way to ease my student loan debt but it did the opposite and this is one career decision I will forever regret.
 
@molossus , thank you for that informative post. Looks like telemedicine is one of many avenues where doctors get lowballed and taken advantage of. I hope you sue teladoc to get your name removed from NPDB. That sounds like libel/defamation of character to me.
 
Not a frequent poster but I am writing here to not only answer your questions but also to spread awareness about what these telemedicine companies are about and the pitfalls of working under them.

I have worked with many: doctor on demand, Teladoc, Mdlive, k health, lemonaid, Amwell.

In order to give you a better overview of how these companies, I will break this down by how you will interact with a patient and how you will get paid.

1. Patient Interactions
usually most of these platforms are phone or video which is synchronous; you interact with the patient in real time. now, some companies are offering text/chat based interactions in real time. others do this ASYNCHRONOUS, where the patient leaves a message and you answer it when you get the message(usually with 24 hours of receipt)

doctor on demand,-video only ,synchronous
Teladoc, phone and video,synchronous
Mdlive,phone and video, synchronous
k health,text only ,sometimes asynchronous
lemonaid, text , sometimes phone ,sometimes asynchronous
Amwell.video only,synchronous

personally, the one i disliked the most is video. it ties me to the computer and I have to sitting there with white coat over my jammies and shorts to give the facade of being in the office. i also have to make sure i dont have anything in the background(no screaming kids, no barking dog or running around, no pot about to boil).

with all of the above there is risk to ones license with ALL of the above tech formats. much more so than a regular in person visit. all of the companies provide malpractice for you, however the litigious aspect of this telemedicine industry is unknown at present and with covid increasing the usage of it, it will only become more intense. patients are now relying on telemedicine for everything. i have had patients call when they clearly were septic or having chest pain. do i direct to the ER? Of course. are the patients about it? nope. does that affect patient satisfaction? yes. do the telemedicine companies care about patient satisfaction? yes.

however most patients call about the common cold and demand antibiotics. i had one patient demand antibiotics because he saw someone cough and he wanted augmenting 'just to head things off'.

so this pushes the doctor into a tough position ; scylla and charybdis are the companies' interests and the patient's interests. no body gives a hoot about you the physician.

2. how you get paid
this varies somewhat. usually it is anywhere from $9 to $23 per consult. if that seems paltry, it is. unfortunately, the only way to make this lucrative is get multiple state licenses(at least 6-10) AND make sure you keep your consults as short as possible. now there are two problems with the latter approach. one is the patients don't like to be rushed and with the pandemic, patients are treating telemedicine visits like primary care office visits. i had one guy call about his cold sore and it lasted for over 20 minutes. usually btw that is not even a 3 minute visit. then you have patients who chronic problems and want a 'second opinion' from you and they will talk forever. the other flip to the coin is again the telemedicine company itself. they also want you to see as many consults as you can, because the brings in more revenue for them, but they also want you to take more time with the patients, to improve patient satisfaction , and also to appease more insurance companies, who are now using telemed companies . again, as the doc, you are in the inferior position.

most will pay you on a 1099 as an independent contractor, k health only pays on a w2 as a salary which is 80K per year and you have give them scheduled 20 hours per week at least.


now that i have got that out of the way. the biggest danger with telemedicine is not the patient, at least not yet. the biggest one is the telemedicine company itself. the one i warn you to strongly stay away from is teladoc. this company is highly dysfunctional and unscrupulous. they have leadership which is also a revolving door and they have been reporting doctors to NPDB, the national practitioner data bank, of which I am now one. they are reporting anyone who is resigning from their company, under false pretenses. this company has singlehandedly managed to mess up my career. and btw, for those not familiar, the NPDB reports are permanent and are NEVER removed unless the reporting entity, chooses to do so, Teladoc in my case. another thing i disliked about Teladoc was they were also incredibly dishonest about the pay and reimbursement for licenses, where they promised to reimburse the cost of those but ending up backing out, leaving me with footing the bill, of over $5k. i have had to hire entire attorney and that has already cost me another $6k.

if you have further commments or questions, put them up here.

IF YOU ARE A RESIDENT/FELLOW/MEDICAL STUDENT, DON'T DO TELEMEDICINE. It will destroy your career. I am attending in a teaching institution and I don't want anyone to deal with these business who are out to screw doctors and doctors in training. i thought this would be a way to ease my student loan debt but it did the opposite and this is one career decision I will forever regret.

What did they report you to the NPDB for?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
@molossus detailed it in his/her post.
Where? It just says they are reporting people who resign. That's not a actual reportable reason. Maybe they edited their post and you saw something different?

@molossus I'm also curious what the exact circumstances of the reporting was, as I've also worked for teladoc in the past. If you're not comfortable responding here, feel free to pm me.
 
Where? It just says they are reporting people who resign. That's not a actual reportable reason. Maybe they edited their post and you saw something different?

@molossus I'm also curious what the exact circumstances of the reporting was, as I've also worked for teladoc in the past. If you're not comfortable responding here, feel free to pm me.

Ya, I also signed up for Teladoc when COVID started; haven’t been using it as it’s not really worth my time. I’d like to know more about the reasoning behind reporting you, so that I might be able to avoid that issue. Feel free to pm me as well.
 
Ya, I also signed up for Teladoc when COVID started; haven’t been using it as it’s not really worth my time. I’d like to know more about the reasoning behind reporting you, so that I might be able to avoid that issue. Feel free to pm me as well.

the official reason is because ' i resigned during an investigation'
 
Where? It just says they are reporting people who resign. That's not a actual reportable reason. Maybe they edited their post and you saw something different?

@molossus I'm also curious what the exact circumstances of the reporting was, as I've also worked for teladoc in the past. If you're not comfortable responding here, feel free to pm me.


sorry for the delay, ive been busy with the hospital work, they reported bc i 'resigned during an investigation'
 
Agree completely with what has been said. Only do Telemedicine under two scenarios:

1. You can be your own boss
2. The scope is very limited to a specific goal or problem.


i think it is very risky even if you have your own company, the liability is high for the one issuing treatment, what if that sinus HA is a tumor?
 
This solidifies my lack of desire to pursue telemedicine for peanuts. I think EPs are poorly qualified for telemedicine in comparison to office based specialties. We rely on vitals, sick appearing, multitasking, labs, imaging and procedures. The environment of the ED doesn’t translate well to a virtual format. It also insulates us well from future automatization or replacement. I work enough at work, and will leave it at that instead of adding on ‘tele-work’ with risks that don’t seem worth the benefits.


the issue is these companies are all for profit and they want the doctor to be the fall guy and if you dont play along they will get you, that is my take away from doing this with teladoc
 
@molossus , thank you for that informative post. Looks like telemedicine is one of many avenues where doctors get lowballed and taken advantage of. I hope you sue teladoc to get your name removed from NPDB. That sounds like libel/defamation of character to me.

there is no legal basis to sue, unfortunately the law is NOT on the side of the physician. shocked? me either , if i sue, i will lose lots of money and time and i still wont get my name out of the NPDB
 
23 dollars per patient? And people are actually considering this? Wow..
 
i was trying to post my whole experience as a separate thread but apparently i cant do that in the attending areas 🙁
If you're talking about the Practicing Physicians forum, you need to be approved for access.

You can do that by following the directions here.
 
Would definitely love to hear more about this - I'd been considering Teladoc / K health as well but would be great to get some context and hear about someone else's experience before jumping in.
 
23 dollars per patient? And people are actually considering this? Wow..

I did this last year when I had the whole day off or did it at work. They gave bonuses b/c it was busy so ended up being 35-40/pt. I was able to see/chart 7 pts/hr so not bad making 225+/hr handing out zpaks all day.

But it seems to have slowed down and I am not not doing it for 23/pt and sitting to snipe the next patient.
 
If you're talking about the Practicing Physicians forum, you need to be approved for access.

You can do that by following the directions here.

well i have not visited these forums in ages and things have changed! there used to be a general forum but that has vanished, im just trying to figure out the best place to thread this
 
Would definitely love to hear more about this - I'd been considering Teladoc / K health as well but would be great to get some context and hear about someone else's experience before jumping in.
well if you can direct me where to post this, i will, i am trying to reach as many people here as a i can

k health is stupid. they will pay on a w2 and demand a schedule from you but wont give you any benefits, any doc who signs up for that is a damn fool
i have lots to say on teladoc bc they are dangerous
 
How is (what K Health is doing) legal?


all of the telemed companies are capitalizing on the pandemic confusion, i think with more time, there will be even more regulation. btw khealth isnt alone, 98point6 and lemonaid as well as nurx are all doing the same or similar
 
all of the telemed companies are capitalizing on the pandemic confusion, i think with more time, there will be even more regulation. btw khealth isnt alone, 98point6 and lemonaid as well as nurx are all doing the same or similar

Nurx was around long before the pandemic. What is it that they’re doing that could be potentially legal.

I work for a telemedicine company (a specific thing we deal with and I’m not EM) and I’ve been generally happy with how we’re treated and the pay, so I’m wondering if I’m missing something shady going on.
 
well i have not visited these forums in ages and things have changed! there used to be a general forum but that has vanished, im just trying to figure out the best place to thread this
And I pointed you to it and how to get access to it. Follow the instructions and all will be good.
 
Nurx was around long before the pandemic. What is it that they’re doing that could be potentially legal.

I work for a telemedicine company (a specific thing we deal with and I’m not EM) and I’ve been generally happy with how we’re treated and the pay, so I’m wondering if I’m missing something shady going on.

i think the issue is that many states dont like the idea of doctors not actually 'seeing' their patients, whether it be f2f or on video
 
And I pointed you to it and how to get access to it. Follow the instructions and all will be good.


well i sent a message and did not hear back, i did post my story hear. hopefully, other doctors will be able to learn from my experience with Teladoc

 
well i sent a message and did not hear back, i did post my story hear. hopefully, other doctors will be able to learn from my experience with Teladoc

No, you just posted in that forum, which is not what I told you to do. Follow the directions, get approved for the Practicing Physicians forum and then we can move the conversation there.
 
No, you just posted in that forum, which is not what I told you to do. Follow the directions, get approved for the Practicing Physicians forum and then we can move the conversation there.
i DID follow the instructions, anyways, i posted in the IM thread, hopefully that WILL reach other doctors, so they can be forewarned, if not, they will learn if/when they get reported to the NPDB
 
Anyone work for MTAG/MedCall Advisors? Would like to hear any words of wisdom from someone with experience with them
 
Bottom line is you can be reported for anything and it is up to the agency to accept it or not. Seems like the NPDB just attaches it to a docs file without doing much investigation.

I have had a few complaints to my state board from not giving druggies norco but I alteast got a formal notice to reply. After showing the pt's 50 scripts from 20 providers in the past year it falls off. Still a pain.

Also, why do these companies care if you sue them? The docs spend time and $$$ and unless there is a huge monetary sum at the end, no lawyer is going to take it up Pro bono. Until it can be done Pro Bono, no many docs are going to spend their resources to fight these complaints.

I also worked for Teledoc and thought it was OK. When I started 2 yrs ago during the flu winter, there were patients lined up to be seen. They gave bonuses too which made their rates about 38/pt and I was very selective on what patient I wanted to see so ended up seeing 7pph. Not bad at 250/hr.

Back in the day, they would just have queue where you can select certain pt and complaints. I stuck with UTI/URIs and young. Always Avoided video for a laundry of reasons. Never saw a complicated complaint. I mean anyone with CP or numbness could be so undifferentiated and I would have to spend 10+ min on them. Thing have changed. Last time I logged in, it was different and seems like you could not see the complaint. No way..... screw that. If I can't cherry pick, I am not doing it for 38/pt less 23/pt.

It is a beat down seeing 7pph and truly more work than even when I worked in the hospital seeing 3pph. Atleast in the hospital, I get to walk around and socialize/surf the net. But to be stuck in a room for 4 hrs constantly working looking at my screen was difficult.

Thank you @molossus for the insight. Another reason I will never do telemedicine again..... well maybe when they up the rate to 50/pt.....
 
Bottom line is you can be reported for anything and it is up to the agency to accept it or not. Seems like the NPDB just attaches it to a docs file without doing much investigation.

I have had a few complaints to my state board from not giving druggies norco but I alteast got a formal notice to reply. After showing the pt's 50 scripts from 20 providers in the past year it falls off. Still a pain.

Also, why do these companies care if you sue them? The docs spend time and $$$ and unless there is a huge monetary sum at the end, no lawyer is going to take it up Pro bono. Until it can be done Pro Bono, no many docs are going to spend their resources to fight these complaints.

I also worked for Teledoc and thought it was OK. When I started 2 yrs ago during the flu winter, there were patients lined up to be seen. They gave bonuses too which made their rates about 38/pt and I was very selective on what patient I wanted to see so ended up seeing 7pph. Not bad at 250/hr.

Back in the day, they would just have queue where you can select certain pt and complaints. I stuck with UTI/URIs and young. Always Avoided video for a laundry of reasons. Never saw a complicated complaint. I mean anyone with CP or numbness could be so undifferentiated and I would have to spend 10+ min on them. Thing have changed. Last time I logged in, it was different and seems like you could not see the complaint. No way..... screw that. If I can't cherry pick, I am not doing it for 38/pt less 23/pt.

It is a beat down seeing 7pph and truly more work than even when I worked in the hospital seeing 3pph. Atleast in the hospital, I get to walk around and socialize/surf the net. But to be stuck in a room for 4 hrs constantly working looking at my screen was difficult.

Thank you @molossus for the insight. Another reason I will never do telemedicine again..... well maybe when they up the rate to 50/pt.....
Did the same thing with teladoc. Got in when patient volume was insanely high and docs were few/far between. Saw patients when there were bonuses, didn't when there weren't. I joined after they stopped letting you screen by CC, and you just got the next pt in the queue. That said, it then showed you their CC, so if it turned out to be "anxiety" or "chest pain" or "abdominal pain," I just clicked the "patient didn't answer" button and got a new patient.

Now there's a crapton of docs doing it and the bonuses are gone. I told them to cancel my account months ago.
 
Did the same thing with teladoc. Got in when patient volume was insanely high and docs were few/far between. Saw patients when there were bonuses, didn't when there weren't. I joined after they stopped letting you screen by CC, and you just got the next pt in the queue. That said, it then showed you their CC, so if it turned out to be "anxiety" or "chest pain" or "abdominal pain," I just clicked the "patient didn't answer" button and got a new patient.

Now there's a crapton of docs doing it and the bonuses are gone. I told them to cancel my account months ago.
From the NPDB complaint, you better watch your back 🙂

I could see "pt abandonment and quality of care" attached to your file soon.

Another straw that broke the camel's back was when they started to send me regular pt metrics and Press Ganey type stuff. Just hospital crap that I was not taking when I never even saw the pt.
 
From the NPDB complaint, you better watch your back 🙂

I could see "pt abandonment and quality of care" attached to your file soon.

Another straw that broke the camel's back was when they started to send me regular pt metrics and Press Ganey type stuff. Just hospital crap that I was not taking when I never even saw the pt.
I know, I remember that thread. They sent me some sort of learning module that I had no intention of doing, so I simply let them know that I hadn't been active on the platform for months, that I likely wouldn't be doing the training module, and if they wanted to revoke my privileges as a result, that was fine with me. They sent me an email a couple of days later saying they received my request to be removed from the teladoc medical group and they did so. Not terribly worried.

I also started getting those patient satisfaction metrics and quickly realized I was done with the platform.
 
They really need to have a strict timer for these telemedicine visits. Make it 5 minutes, so that it abruptly cuts off if the patient is streaming too much verbal diarrhea. Have an option so that the doctor can extend the session if needed at their discretion.
 
Top