I never said anything about probation. The eye rolling that went along with CMS goes way back (20 years or more) and has more to do with low admission standards and a reputation of being very low in the academic pecking order. (Taking a facutly job was not seen in the same light as going to UChicago.)
Sorry I should have rephrased that to say that it is a combo of what you said and the fact that it was on probation.
My bad!!
But I know for a fact as far back as only 2-3 years ago it was on probation for some reasons. That probationary status could also have contributed to the problems.