the official COMAT shelf thread

Behind the Knife - Dominate Surgery Course
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
DrStephenStrange said:
I now have 2 scheduled already as of last week.


Easy, some programs don't participate in VSAS, and you can just email their PC and you can get them scheduled that way.
Click to expand...
Yeah some like this ^ are easier. people going through only vsas arent really gonna have anything set up yet bc most places dont accept app submissions til 4/15 lol
 
I have 2 scheduled. The message from our school has been highly variable but most say to proceed scheduling as many as possible. My plan is to do 5 but I'm a little worried because one of my top programs might hold it against an applicant that does more than one away
 
DrStephenStrange said:
I didn't apply to places around me. I applied to one place in PA and one in IL, and both of them offer housing to students, so I will still save a little bit.
Click to expand...
Ahhh I see. I’m waiting till April first too schedule some anything away from my “home base”
 
Started my peds elective today. Feels go to be back but wow do you forget a lot of things after 7 months lol.

Also bittersweet because this was the comat I felt best about but was my worst score overall
 
Yo, I can’t remember who all is interested in DR/IR, but if you are, I made a thread over in the radiology forum for Co 22.

forums.studentdoctor.net

Co 22’ application season thread

Making this for all my radiology app peeps. @Ho0v-man, @Neopolymath and @NecrotizingFasciitis would love to have some advice/info from you all. @calivianya you were the only one on the thread for Co 22 that said you were interested in radiology, but if there is anyone else you know of, tag em.
forums.studentdoctor.net forums.studentdoctor.net
 
106 on OBGYN Comat. two points worse than predicted (would love to do better than predicted for once lol)

So comes the end of an era. a 107 Comat average. not bad for someone who was in the bottom 20% of their preclinical class with a 2.5 GPA lol.

I've said it before, but it is wild how much arbitrary measurements can wreck your sense of accomplishment. I went from bottom 20% in preclinicals to the top 25 percent of students (based on comat average) and I am so damn proud of that. Truly a comeback story. However, It still feels like a failure because I did not honor a single rotation due to my schools very high standards. Would not sting as bad if I didn't have students from other schools at my site who honored all rotations with sub 100 comat scores. I feel cheated sometimes.

Hopefully I tear it up for Step 2. Super proud of everyone in this thread, you have all been inspiration to work my hardest and try to accomplish bigger and better things.
 
Last edited:
ohmanwaddup said:
106 on OBGYN Comat. two points worse than predicted (would love to do better than predicted for once lol)

So comes the end of an era. a 107 Comat average. not bad for someone who was in the bottom 20% of their preclinical class with a 2.5 treats! lol.

I've said it before, but it is wild how much arbitrary measurements can wreck your sense of accomplishment. I went from bottom 20% to the top 25 percent of students (based on comat average) and I am so damn proud of that. Truly a comeback story. However, It still feels like a failure because I did not honor a single rotation due to my schools very high standards. Would not sting as bad if I didn't have students from other schools at my site who honored all rotations with sub 100 comat scores. I feel cheated sometimes.

Hopefully I tear it up for Step 2. Super proud of everyone in this thread, you have all been inspiration to work my hardest and try to accomplish bigger and better things.
Click to expand...
You killed it. Definitely something to be very proud of.
 
fldoctorgirl said:
Yes.
Click to expand...
Such BS. Idk if you saw the email though, but they aren't giving a transcript F anymore. They are allowing everyone a second remediation and if they pass they get a straight pass.

they also said there was a major B line issue and they had to reaudit everything because B line was not recording grades correctly, so you may have actually passed!
 
Hippocrates II said:
We had to do some telemedicine visit SP encounters as a prep for the now non-existent PE. Totally new to us, lots of new grading criteria that to either got all or no credit for doing. A sizeable portion of our class failed it as a result.
Click to expand...
Oh, same **** at my school. Did mine two months ago and still haven’t gotten my scores. I’ve heard it’s because so many failed that they’re now trying to change grading.
 
So I'm kinda doing garbage on Comquest OMM questions. Did not realize how much I struggle with rib and sacrum questions
 
ohmanwaddup said:
So I'm kinda doing garbage on Comquest OMM questions. Did not realize how much I struggle with rib and sacrum questions
Click to expand...
This crap is rough. I’m trying to get through the turn up 2 OMT deck *quickly* while I’m doing u world and other things so it’ll be knee jerk later and I won’t have to seriously study it between step and comlex. It’s got a lot of good rib and sacrum cards so far. I‘ve seen about 3/4 of the deck now.

Besides, the anatomic stuff in the deck and how to treat injuries, other than using OMT, is actually still helpful for step 2 even though I don’t want to admit that.
 
calivianya said:
This crap is rough. I’m trying to get through the turn up 2 OMT deck *quickly* while I’m doing u world and other things so it’ll be knee jerk later and I won’t have to seriously study it between step and comlex. It’s got a lot of good rib and sacrum cards so far. I‘ve seen about 3/4 of the deck now.

Besides, the anatomic stuff in the deck and how to treat injuries, other than using OMT, is actually still helpful for step 2 even though I don’t want to admit that.
Click to expand...
yeah After seeing a few questions Its already obvious how good the deck is. I take the exam next friday. Ill just keep powering through and hope for a pass. maybe itll be like OB where I start out getting wrecked but it gets better
 
Steve_Zissou said:
Yo, did UWorld for peds really **** anyone else up? Lots of "40% correct" questions that are super ****ing vague.
Click to expand...
dude I want to do peds and I get wrecked by peds questions. IDK what the hell happened, my first 100 I had like a 70% average, now I'm in the 50s
 
Update: holy sh** I'm so bored on GI. We legit just scope allllll day while an NP runs around seeing most of the patients on the floor. Shoot me.

And with that, I've definitely realized that the procedure lifestyle is not for me. I mean, I'm sure it's mildly more interesting when you're the one doing it vs. watching, but.....the same thing, non-stop, for hours every day? Noooooope.

Also, closer and closer to solidifying that hospitalist or PCP is the life for me. Like, 99.9% sure.


Unrelated, but also super conflicted about setting up rotations for fourth year. I'm trying to do things inpatient/with residency programs, but a bunch offered are with programs I actually want to go to and I don't want to shoot myself in the foot since aways aren't really recommended for IM. But I also have imposter syndrome that I'm not going to know how to function as an intern after DO style M3.
 
How about them savage beyotch programs that put their electives up on VSAS at midnight EST? I was like O.O when I heard that email ding. Really? I was winding down. Now I’m wound back up. 🤣
 
calivianya said:
How about them savage beyotch programs that put their electives up on VSAS at midnight EST? I was like O.O when I heard that email ding. Really? I was winding down. Now I’m wound back up. 🤣
Click to expand...
lol I had one open up at a day early at 11am. I didn't notice until 4PM.
 
fldoctorgirl said:
Update: holy sh** I'm so bored on GI. We legit just scope allllll day while an NP runs around seeing most of the patients on the floor. Shoot me.

And with that, I've definitely realized that the procedure lifestyle is not for me. I mean, I'm sure it's mildly more interesting when you're the one doing it vs. watching, but.....the same thing, non-stop, for hours every day? Noooooope.

Also, closer and closer to solidifying that hospitalist or PCP is the life for me. Like, 99.9% sure.


Unrelated, but also super conflicted about setting up rotations for fourth year. I'm trying to do things inpatient/with residency programs, but a bunch offered are with programs I actually want to go to and I don't want to shoot myself in the foot since aways aren't really recommended for IM. But I also have imposter syndrome that I'm not going to know how to function as an intern after DO style M3.
Click to expand...
Yeah no shot Im gonna feel ready for a SubI with only 5-6 weeks of inpatient IM. DO style rotations are rough and 1000% have imposter syndrome. I can barely present or workup copd exacerbation and im boutta be an MS4
 
Comquest OB questions are absolute trash. Bull**** questions on low yield garbage. Uworld was soooo much better omg. After having done the UW questions and then going to comquest its night and day. How predictive was people who did comquest for their actual OB comat
 
Deecee2DO said:
Comquest OB questions are absolute trash. Bull**** questions on low yield garbage. Uworld was soooo much better omg. After having done the UW questions and then going to comquest its night and day. How predictive was people who did comquest for their actual OB comat
Click to expand...
within 1-2 points per usual with comquest, but I did zero uworld


I actually liked the comquest ones a lot, but they were really hard for the first 50 or so
 
Deecee2DO said:
Yeah like the comquest questions they are asking are so dumb-so low yield its mad annoying
Click to expand...
I will say I personally felt that OBGYN comquest was the most representative of the COMAT compared to other subjects
 
Steve_Zissou said:
Any of you guys using Divine intervention?
Click to expand...
Legit love him. Its all I watch. I listen to him and do UW and i feel like he gets me so many questions on the shelves. Hes the Step 2 version of goljan. Highly recommend him over OME. OME actually sucks imo i never retain any of his lectures its basically him regurgitating algorithms completely useless to me
 
Deecee2DO said:
Legit love him. Its all I watch. I listen to him and do UW and i feel like he gets me so many questions on the shelves. Hes the Step 2 version of goljan. Highly recommend him over OME. OME actually sucks imo i never retain any of his lectures its basically him regurgitating algorithms completely useless to me
Click to expand...
Same. Divine was the GOAT during 3rd year.
 
whelp I finished the COMQUEST questions for the omm comat I take Friday. predicted at 99 which is my lowest ever. Im a little nervous about passing. Most of my mistakes were pelvic counterstrain though, so hopefully I can pound that and be ok.

I've heard awful rumors that one form of the exam has a ton of cranial on it.
 
ohmanwaddup said:
whelp I finished the COMQUEST questions for the omm comat I take Friday. predicted at 99 which is my lowest ever. Im a little nervous about passing. Most of my mistakes were pelvic counterstrain though, so hopefully I can pound that and be ok.

I've heard awful rumors that one form of the exam has a ton of cranial on it.
Click to expand...
COMQUEST OMM is so much easier than the actual COMAT LOL. It was the worst COMAT I have taken so far.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

K
Best books for Psychiatry Shelf Exam in 2024
Replies
2
Views
2K
L8rg8r
L
spes93
  • Question Question
Comparing NBME shelf performance to COMAT, and how to improve?
Replies
7
Views
6K
JimBone905
J
G
May have failed internal medicine shelf...again
Replies
3
Views
6K
PikminOC
PikminOC
T
Surgery shelf : Anki to retain Divergillio?
Replies
0
Views
5K
taeyeonlover
T
Fay1129
Step 2 and Shelf exam notes
Replies
3
Views
7K
pbsdrinkingwhale
pbsdrinkingwhale
Top