- Joined
- Aug 12, 2007
- Messages
- 736
- Reaction score
- 3
In all honesty applying to very few places during the main match was probably what sealed your fate. Apply to as many programs and go on as many interviews as you can afford next year.
i disagree, i think most of the people here on this thread are AMGs that are truly surprised that they did not match...because even only a few years ago, it was unthinkable that a US grad would not match.
it seems that a fair amount of people in this thread are IMG's, likely american or canadian born students who want to return to the US for residency. there's nothing wrong with that. what i think is wrong is the culture and mentality that somehow you not securing a spot via SOAP/match is unfair because you made the decision to attend a non-US school for medicine.
you made the educated decision to attend a foreign medical school, likely because you couldn't make it in a US school. you should've known going in how much harder it was going to be to get into residency, something that im pretty sure all premed counselors tell their students when the topic of foreign schools get raised.
with the upcoming merger of the AOA and ACGME matches in 2015, its going to be even tougher for IMG's to match. all those currently open DO spots are going to fair game for unmatched students and there's no way a PD is going to give an IMG a spot over a US MD student.
tl;dr if you didn't get into a US school, don't go in expecting a US residency spot like its some sort of deserved handout
it seems that a fair amount of people in this thread are IMG's, likely american or canadian born students who want to return to the US for residency. there's nothing wrong with that. what i think is wrong is the culture and mentality that somehow you not securing a spot via SOAP/match is unfair because you made the decision to attend a non-US school for medicine.
you made the educated decision to attend a foreign medical school, likely because you couldn't make it in a US allopathic school. you should've known going in how much harder it was going to be to get into residency, something that im pretty sure all premed counselors tell their students when the topic of foreign schools get raised.
with the upcoming merger of the AOA and ACGME matches in 2015, its going to be even tougher for IMG's to match. all those currently open DO spots are going to fair game for unmatched students and there's no way a PD is going to give an IMG a spot over a US MD student.
tl;dr if you didn't get into a US school, don't go in expecting a US residency spot like its some sort of deserved handout
fixed.
Not sure what you're getting at but honestly if anyone went the offshore route instead of going to a DO school when that was a legitimate option, it was a huge mistake.
Only the lower tier schools. SGU, Ross, and AUC are businesses that need to weed people out to maintain high step one pass rates plus they don't have enough clinical rotation spots to accommodate all the people they accept in the first place. I heard US schools provide remediation tests though.
In all honesty applying to very few places during the main match was probably what sealed your fate. Apply to as many programs and go on as many interviews as you can afford next year.
Question: i tried to apply to this yrs match with an incomplete application (step 2ck and CS scores didnt come out until december, >24x on both) and am a non-us IMG, expected to graduate in may. It was not the smartest decision and now im hitting myself because even if i now re-apply this year with a 'complete' app and possible a step 3 I am afraid I won't get interviews from places I applied because its my second time around. Thoughts?
Joesephine, you didn't stand a chance this year but you have pretty nice chances for the next.
1. Many programs filter and do not invite IMGs without ECFMG certificate as they are concerned one would not be ECFMG certified by July 1.
2. Some programs would invite but not rank not yet certified for the same reason.
3. As you are graduating in May, they knee you are likely to be not certfied by July as the process is rather time consuming.
4. You were not ECFMG "verified" by December. Most programs would not touch an applicant not eligible for the match.
5. Next year the programs would not care (or even know) whether or not you participated in this match. I think you should not worry about it.
Good luck.
I forgot to release the CK and CS scores for SOAP. would that hurt me?
I had two interviews (I applied very selectively and to few places) during the main match. I have received no offers during SOAP. despite applying to surg prelim and IM prelim (50 places)
I have decent stats AMG/220/203/CS passed all 1x. BUT i failed 3 classes in first year and repeated the year with those classes only. I've done well on my clerkships and excellent on a surgery sub-i and received excellent letters from a well known Dept Chair in Surgery, SurgOnc Chief, and Gen Surg/Trauma Chief from a solid university program.
I don't know what to do... What if there are no more unfilled spots come monday. My hands were tied because I could not initiate contact. At this point I will take anything....
If not releasing CK and CS hurt me.........
did any of your advisors tell you your downward trend from step 1 to step 2 is a huge red flag?
if not, they did an incredible disservice to you.
when applying to such few places and with such few interviews, did anyone tell you to have a serious backup plan if you don't match?
All the programs only saw my Step I score.
Going back, my advisor told me to apply broad, consider another specialty or a prelim position in surgery at my home institution if geography was a factor. My choices were influenced by geography (I wanted to stay in my home state and had a few other states as back up). He referred me to the assistant PD where I was told that I was a "very strong candidate" for their prelim position and that I should give them a "very strong consideration". So I considered it a safety net and found out that they did not rank me high enough to match.
I should have applied broad from the beginning...
I matched!!!!!
I am a US-IMG who went to AUA.
I applied to a 120 programs, got only 3 interviews but still matched!!!. i am so happy!!!!.
( i realize that this might be the wrong thread to post this in but i couldn't find the right one)
i wish everybody the best in the soap process!!
DONT ever give up!!!!!
This thread is starting to get mean with the rising tensions. This is a horrible process for all involved. I am an AMG who didn't match twice but am now a categorical surg resident. Most of you are are good students and doctors who will be be great residents and attendings. The more you talk to residents and attendings, the more you will see how often they take a circuitous route. Whatever caused your current predicament, here is my advice with a grain of salt:
1) Focus- if your dream is to bean ENT or a family doc, decide what you want and narrow your efforts to that goal for the next round. Just like you did in med school, do what you have to do.
2) Get a job: with all of our debts and need to do things like eat, this next year, you probably need a job
- don't give up on residency jobs- there are websites for most specialties (apds.org for surgery, eg) and more general sites like residentmatch that can help you out. Moreover, and not to be underestimated is "pounding the pavement." There are many spots that aren't advertised such as new programs or extra spots at established programs that get ACGME approval for expansion. Something slightly less than the shotgun approach is appropriate here. Focus on programs you know, have interviewed at, have friends and classmates at and email and call judiciously. There will be some spots that open up when a IMGs papers don't come through, people drop out for personal reasons, especially in June.
- foreign residency jobs- look at UK requirements, your home country or where you speak the language- Canada, Australia, NZ, Caribbean, etc
- get a non-residency job: obviously less desirable but you need to eat and progress in your career. Research is a great option. It may be poo pooed by some but I know tons of residents, especially FMGs that did a year or two or 3 of research and matched well. Health care related research work is also good and pays ok.
- medical/non-research jobs: consultancies, insurance, public health, non-lab research, docs assistant/first assist type jobs, Kaplan or similar teacher
- other jobs you are probably qualified for and will pay more than McDs: private (school or home tutor)- doesn't require a certificate, volunteer- peace corps, americorps, etc, business jobs as previously mentioned on this forum
3) options that may help your future application:
- grad school: yes, more school but many phd positions pay, mph can be useful but now we are looking at next year or January to start as most apps are due in the fall and offer in the spring like undergrad
4) other:
- rely on undergrad major
- job to pay the bills, have time for step 3, next round of apps
For your next attempt: what factors can you modify?
- apply early, submit the day of opening
- start now trying to line up letter writers
- strategize: apply to more, broader, different specialties, different regions
- step 3 +\-: some states require internship prior to taking
- additional qualifications: papers published, posters, current projects, other qualifications- CITI certified for research, new degree or diploma, current on EHR (Epic, etc)
- contact programs/interviewers and ask what you did wrong, can do better, etc. what do you have to loose now?
Be prepared for spur of the moment residency openings:
- keep all your ERAS stuff (print out, keep up to date CV)
- ask your home program to keep your letters of rec on file or you keep them so you can send the minute you see an opening
- troll the web or openings, keep in contact with friends/residents for openings, contact PDs
Not matching is a horrible place to be, especially today. I empathize and there are more and more attendings that didn't get where there in the traditional route. This is not a reflection of your intelligence or you as a person.it is a career setback or stall. Do what you need to do for you, your family and for what you ultimately want.
Best of luck.
PM with questions
i didn't criticize them at all
i just said amg's should have priority regardless of merit and fully acknowledged how hard IMGs worked
i absolutely know that a ton of IMGs are US students who couldn't get into a med school in the states. however, the value of being in the states should be upheld by holding priority for people from the US and who are actively studying in the US, period.
This thread is starting to get mean with the rising tensions. This is a horrible process for all involved. I am an AMG who didn't match twice but am now a categorical surg resident. Most of you are are good students and doctors who will be be great residents and attendings. The more you talk to residents and attendings, the more you will see how often they take a circuitous route. Whatever caused your current predicament, here is my advice with a grain of salt:
1) Focus- if your dream is to bean ENT or a family doc, decide what you want and narrow your efforts to that goal for the next round. Just like you did in med school, do what you have to do.
2) Get a job: with all of our debts and need to do things like eat, this next year, you probably need a job
- don't give up on residency jobs- there are websites for most specialties (apds.org for surgery, eg) and more general sites like residentmatch that can help you out. Moreover, and not to be underestimated is "pounding the pavement." There are many spots that aren't advertised such as new programs or extra spots at established programs that get ACGME approval for expansion. Something slightly less than the shotgun approach is appropriate here. Focus on programs you know, have interviewed at, have friends and classmates at and email and call judiciously. There will be some spots that open up when a IMGs papers don't come through, people drop out for personal reasons, especially in June.
- foreign residency jobs- look at UK requirements, your home country or where you speak the language- Canada, Australia, NZ, Caribbean, etc
- get a non-residency job: obviously less desirable but you need to eat and progress in your career. Research is a great option. It may be poo pooed by some but I know tons of residents, especially FMGs that did a year or two or 3 of research and matched well. Health care related research work is also good and pays ok.
- medical/non-research jobs: consultancies, insurance, public health, non-lab research, docs assistant/first assist type jobs, Kaplan or similar teacher
- other jobs you are probably qualified for and will pay more than McDs: private (school or home tutor)- doesn't require a certificate, volunteer- peace corps, americorps, etc, business jobs as previously mentioned on this forum
3) options that may help your future application:
- grad school: yes, more school but many phd positions pay, mph can be useful but now we are looking at next year or January to start as most apps are due in the fall and offer in the spring like undergrad
4) other:
- rely on undergrad major
- job to pay the bills, have time for step 3, next round of apps
For your next attempt: what factors can you modify?
- apply early, submit the day of opening
- start now trying to line up letter writers
- strategize: apply to more, broader, different specialties, different regions
- step 3 +\-: some states require internship prior to taking
- additional qualifications: papers published, posters, current projects, other qualifications- CITI certified for research, new degree or diploma, current on EHR (Epic, etc)
- contact programs/interviewers and ask what you did wrong, can do better, etc. what do you have to loose now?
Be prepared for spur of the moment residency openings:
- keep all your ERAS stuff (print out, keep up to date CV)
- ask your home program to keep your letters of rec on file or you keep them so you can send the minute you see an opening
- troll the web or openings, keep in contact with friends/residents for openings, contact PDs
Not matching is a horrible place to be, especially today. I empathize and there are more and more attendings that didn't get where there in the traditional route. This is not a reflection of your intelligence or you as a person.it is a career setback or stall. Do what you need to do for you, your family and for what you ultimately want.
Best of luck.
PM with questions
With all of the world class faculty, remediation, and amazing resources provided to AMGs, they should not be in this predicament. There are IMGs who go to school in trailers and can put together stronger applications. No AMG should score under a 230 on any step (personal situation and catastrophe notwithstanding). We're all US citizens after the same goal so don't put IMGs down.
Forgive me, what does SOAP stand for?
With all of the world class faculty, remediation, and amazing resources provided to AMGs, they should not be in this predicament. There are IMGs who go to school in trailers and can put together stronger applications. No AMG should score under a 230 on any step (personal situation and catastrophe notwithstanding). We're all US citizens after the same goal so don't put IMGs down.
Forgive me, what does SOAP stand for?
Hmm...anyone want to be creative?
With all of the world class faculty, remediation, and amazing resources provided to AMGs, they should not be in this predicament. There are IMGs who go to school in trailers and can put together stronger applications. No AMG should score under a 230 on any step (personal situation and catastrophe notwithstanding). We're all US citizens after the same goal so don't put IMGs down.
This is utter bull****. Most US grads have about four to six weeks to study for Step 1 and two weeks to study for Step 2, a far cry from the six month to year long study regimens that many IMGs do. Your only existence as an IMG is to study for the damn test, while the rest of us went to a real school and learned things like coming up with a proper differential.
At my US school, we were still seeing patients during the day up to three weeks before Step 1.
This is utter bull****. Most US grads have about four to six weeks to study for Step 1 and two weeks to study for Step 2, a far cry from the six month to year long study regimens that many IMGs do. Your only existence as an IMG is to study for the damn test, while the rest of us went to a real school and learned things like coming up with a proper differential.
At my US school, we were still seeing patients during the day up to three weeks before Step 1.
Sh*tting On Awesome People
Not sure what you're getting at but honestly if anyone went the offshore route instead of going to a DO school when that was a legitimate option, it was a huge mistake.
Apparently, it seems many a good people got **** on this week.
I sincerely feel for you guys, AMG/IMG alike, irrespective of your backgrounds. You all I am sure have endured individual, relatively unique struggles, and I wish you all successful futures in which you can utilize the amazing, privileged knowledge you have accumulated over the past several years.
Keep your heads up
Thank you all in advance for any advice that may come my way. The thread has been up and down with getting down right nasty in some cases and though tensions run high and anger, sadness and being bitter is ok for the time being, please try to not get jaded. So here's my story;
Non traditional US senior in public state medical school; long story short, had to work EMS through medical school for financial reasons. Bad at managing both and ended up repeating 2nd year for a single course failure in which remediation was not an option. Tough coming back from it but I will finish my coursework with no other failures on my record. Passed all Steps first time with below average scores(1-221 2-208 CS - P). I was always passionate about EM, Honored all my EM aways, clerkships and continued to participate in research projects that will be submitted for publication this month and next. I applied early and widely on the eastern seaboard, knowing that EM is getting more and more competitive. My application was held up until late October for one letter of rec from an away program. I received 6 interviews, which I thought had gone well, and was counseled to apply to IM/prelim as a back-up. Only received one interview at my home institution and was told by the PD that my application was so EM heavy that it was no surprise that I did not receive more IV invites in my back ups.
NOW: No match, No SOAP and about 500k in debt and not sure about my future.
Plan: Try to scramble on Monday, keeping an eye out for any openings that might occur while in the meantime returning to work to live and try to participate in anypublishable research that might bolster my re application next cycle where I will try for EM even more widely and more IM programs as many as I can afford to apply to.
Any advice out there of anything more that I should do? Constructive comments would be greatly appreciated. Best of luck to all of you....
Keeping calm and carrying on...
Thank you all in advance for any advice that may come my way. The thread has been up and down with getting down right nasty in some cases and though tensions run high and anger, sadness and being bitter is ok for the time being, please try to not get jaded. So here's my story;
Non traditional US senior in public state medical school; long story short, had to work EMS through medical school for financial reasons. Bad at managing both and ended up repeating 2nd year for a single course failure in which remediation was not an option. Tough coming back from it but I will finish my coursework with no other failures on my record. Passed all Steps first time with below average scores(1-221 2-208 CS - P). I was always passionate about EM, Honored all my EM aways, clerkships and continued to participate in research projects that will be submitted for publication this month and next. I applied early and widely on the eastern seaboard, knowing that EM is getting more and more competitive. My application was held up until late October for one letter of rec from an away program. I received 6 interviews, which I thought had gone well, and was counseled to apply to IM/prelim as a back-up. Only received one interview at my home institution and was told by the PD that my application was so EM heavy that it was no surprise that I did not receive more IV invites in my back ups.
NOW: No match, No SOAP and about 500k in debt and not sure about my future.
Plan: Try to scramble on Monday, keeping an eye out for any openings that might occur while in the meantime returning to work to live and try to participate in anypublishable research that might bolster my re application next cycle where I will try for EM even more widely and more IM programs as many as I can afford to apply to.
Any advice out there of anything more that I should do? Constructive comments would be greatly appreciated. Best of luck to all of you....
Keeping calm and carrying on...
Any advice on how and where to find off-cycle openings?
Any advice on how and where to find off-cycle openings?
Thanks. How to know which programs do this?Go to one of the multiple sites that have postings - whether it is the individual specialty pages (listed yesterday), residentswap, the free database for findaresident, listings here, calling programs which not uncommonly have openings that are never advertised.
Any advice on how and where to find off-cycle openings?
This is utter bull****. Most US grads have about four to six weeks to study for Step 1 and two weeks to study for Step 2, a far cry from the six month to year long study regimens that many IMGs do. Your only existence as an IMG is to study for the damn test, while the rest of us went to a real school and learned things like coming up with a proper differential.
At my US school, we were still seeing patients during the day up to three weeks before Step 1.
Re: your debt, you will likely never pay it off and you'll have to go on the income based repayment plan, which is forgiven after like 10 years now I think if you've made monthly payments until then.
Thanks for the reply. Any thoughts on if it would be ok to reach out to the PDs where I interviewed and ask for feedback on how to improve for next cycle? I guess after Monday. . .that's pretty harsh that you'd have to repeat a whole year for only one course, no? I would suggest to apply to IM and possibly transfer later on. There are still some positions open and I'm pretty sure will be positions open after today and that pop up. Needless to say being an AMG gives you an advantage. Also while you have repeated a year, I find it surprising that you did not match. I've had colleagues with lower scores than you who did match. I myself only went to a handful of interviews that I can count on my hand and matched in my specialty so maybe get some feedback if possible about what might have gone wrong. Lastly, any way that you can talk ot your school and ask if they could give you a prelim spot? Most EM programs require internship anways so that might help. Also ask your EM PD for help, if they like you, you are far more likely to get in next year. Re: your debt, you will likely never pay it off and you'll have to go on the income based repayment plan, which is forgiven after like 10 years now I think if you've made monthly payments until then.