Toledo MSBS 2019-2020

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
somewhat random question... is it true that your white coats dont have your names on them lol

Members don't see this ad.
 
The M1s! At their white coat ceremony it didn’t look like their coats had names on them lol

(genuinely couldn’t matter less to me lmao I’m in no position to be applying to med school anytime soon either way this is purely out of curiosity, didn’t want to make it come off as being arrogant or anything )
 
Members don't see this ad :)
The M1s! At their white coat ceremony it didn’t look like their coats had names on them lol

(genuinely couldn’t matter less to me lmao I’m in no position to be applying to med school anytime soon either way this is purely out of curiosity, didn’t want to make it come off as being arrogant or anything )
Yeah, I have absolutely no idea, nor do I care. I interacted with med students all year long and can't remember at all if white coats were embroidered with names.... but I think they were??? Maybe it takes them awhile to get stuff embroidered after white coat ceremony (no sense in embroidering anything until you know who is going to matriculate and that everyone has the right size coat)., but again, things I couldn't care less about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
potentially stupid question, but the question about the M1's reminded me-- did you guys ever get the stats for your year's MSBS --> UTCOM matriculation in terms of how many of you ended up getting accepted/waitlisted/rejected? idek if you guys would have access to that info now that FERPA's a thing but just curious
 
potentially stupid question, but the question about the M1's reminded me-- did you guys ever get the stats for your year's MSBS --> UTCOM matriculation in terms of how many of you ended up getting accepted/waitlisted/rejected? idek if you guys would have access to that info now that FERPA's a thing but just curious
Still working on it.... well, im not... Im on a beach sipping a rum and coke... but we have a team on it. I apologize for not having the stats out earlier, but we decided to "expand" the project and give stats not only from our year, but for previous years as well. The whole furpa thing is making it difficult to obtain data, but we have our ways. Worse case senerio we will have it done in August (since some M1 is going to give a little presentation during orientation to you guys). I'm hoping to have things done and published in the next few weeks. I super promise I'll post some stats on here when they are done.
 
Hey no worries I appreciate it man enjoy that rum and coke and some well-deserved time off !!
 
this is a *really* stupid question and i dont even know how to properly ask it without sounding like a tool so im just gonna ask it-- a number of alumni in the program have stated (and i think Miracle_Max has too) stated that the year that they were in the program was one of, if not the hardest, year of their life. Could you clarify why? From what I can tell, you guys take one-two classes at a time (in comparison to other SMPs that take 4-5 classes/sem?) aside from research (which I admit would take up a lot of ur time, no denying that). But if most of you guys didnt restudy for the mcat, where else was ur time going? Or were the classes just that plain difficult?

I guess what Im asking is, what made this year harder than your junior or senior year of college, if you were a science major/pre-med who was doing research/volunteering/shadowing etc. on top of STEM coursework. Really hope i didn't come off as an dingus here lol, just was hoping to get a better idea.
 
this is a *really* stupid question and i dont even know how to properly ask it without sounding like a tool so im just gonna ask it-- a number of alumni in the program have stated (and i think Miracle_Max has too) stated that the year that they were in the program was one of, if not the hardest, year of their life. Could you clarify why?

No this is a legit question and one I had before the program started as well. There are a few factors that all combine into making MSBS a very hard year (for me it wasn't the hardest year of my life, but it was definitely in the top 5).

Looking at the class list before the program started I was thinking, "Wow Miracle Max, this looks chill af, I need to get a part time job. MAybe the king will take me back as a part time miracle man" But the classes are deceptive. With the exception of biostats and maybe Anatomy (which is its own beast), the classes pack a ton of various topics into them and really are just tons of different classes wrapped up into single classes: Pharmacology, diseases, genetics, biochem, cell bio, pathophisiology, histology, etc, etc. Basically, the classes are certainly rigorous, and the material you have to learn is pretty broad. Plus you are studying for these classes on top of doing ~10hrs of research a week (but for some students this was closer to 20+). On top of this, most students were involved in various extracurriculars: Volunteering, shadowing, etc etc. Quite a few of us did manage to pull in extra income through SUPER part time jobs. It all adds up to being busy. (Some of us even managed to keep our significant others, and one guy even has a wife and 2 kids). I exercised like once a month...

But the busyness is only part of what makes this a hard year. Many of us had to travel and interview at med schools, thus adding on more busyness. But probably most of us didn't have any outside interviews and basically ended up having all our eggs in the UTCOM basket. The stress of not knowing where you will be next year really builds. Even for those of us who were fortunate enough to have gotten into other schools early, the tress of not knowing where we will be still builds.

So yeah, classes are hard, but not really all that harder than doing a suicide class-load in undergrad (for me that was ochem+labs, microbio, calc, calc-based-physics, genetics, TA-ing, doing research, and volunteering at the hospital). It's really the stress and uncertainty on top of lots of busyness that really makes the MSBS year hard.

Hope that makes sense, but if it doesn't let me know. I'm busy day-drinking at the moment since I'm on vacation so I have no idea how coherent that was.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I had another question-- do you know off the top of your head how many people apply // how many people get offered a spot in MSBS? (trying to plan when to apply for the 20-21 year, but im prob not gonna get an mcat score back till feb '20 and not sure if that'll be uncompetitive :/
 
I had another question-- do you know off the top of your head how many people apply // how many people get offered a spot in MSBS? (trying to plan when to apply for the 20-21 year, but im prob not gonna get an mcat score back till feb '20 and not sure if that'll be uncompetitive :/
I actually know next to nothing about MSBS admissions. I probably know more about getting into UTCOM than MSBS. What I do know is that they send out WAY more acceptances than who actually shows up, so the odds are in your favor to get accepted. The can take up to 60 (my class had 31 to start), so my guess is they will send out at least 100 acceptances (but this is pure alcohol influenced guessing). I know many from my class applied in March/april when the realized they weren't going to get into med school. Definitely do what you can to focus on getting a good MCAT score. Who knows, score well enough maybe you can skip MSBS!

I remember I applied like in Sep-Oct after not getting any med school interviews right away and freaking out and applying to SMPs all over the country (ended up getting interviews later, but got stuck on wait lists). I maaaaay have sent anapplications to a few Caribbean med schools just to feel good about myself. I tend to waste money when im stressed out.
 
Also, kind of long term thinking, but as a current undergrad, I have little-no experience evaluating a match list lol (and I neither plan nor want to go to like a top 20 school or anything like that); i know Toledo regularly matches a lot of students in non-primary care fields () but I also saw that a lot of residents stay in the general OH area. I was wondering if you had any idea about a specialty you were leaning twds and also if you had plans to stay long term in OH.

Understandably, this isn’t something you have to consider for a solid 2-3 years but just wondering if you had any thoughts
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Also, kind of long term thinking, but as a current undergrad, I have little-no experience evaluating a match list lol (and I neither plan nor want to go to like a top 20 school or anything like that); i know Toledo regularly matches a lot of students in non-primary care fields () but I also saw that a lot of residents stay in the general OH area. I was wondering if you had any idea about a specialty you were leaning twds and also if you had plans to stay long term in OH.

Understandably, this isn’t something you have to consider for a solid 2-3 years but just wondering if you had any thoughts

I'm leaning towards specialty surgical, either Ortho, ENT, or Optho (recently ruled out Uro), but that will mostly depend on how my boards turn out. I plan on applying everywhere I can afford. With specialty surgical, that is where you start seeing students matching to anywhere under the sun, wheras FM, IM, ER, OBGYN, Gen Surg, (accounts for the majority of the class) do statistically match closer to where people did med school at. Personally I have no plans either way about where I will be after residency. By then the zombie apocalypse will most likely be upon us, but at least my student debt will be wiped out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Hey @Miracle_Max, long-time lurker here that’s been following this thread for a while; finally decided to make an account so I could ask some qs too-

I was just wondering what the selling points of this particular program were? I know you mentioned that you thought this program offered you the best chance of matriculating to the MD school (congrats btw!) but I was wondering if you thought there were any other strong points of this program? I imagine you’d have more insight on this having completed the program than other fellow students of mine who have just gotten accepted.

Hope you’re enjoying vacation!
 
Hey @Miracle_Max, long-time lurker here that’s been following this thread for a while; finally decided to make an account so I could ask some qs too-

I was just wondering what the selling points of this particular program were? I know you mentioned that you thought this program offered you the best chance of matriculating to the MD school (congrats btw!) but I was wondering if you thought there were any other strong points of this program? I imagine you’d have more insight on this having completed the program than other fellow students of mine who have just gotten accepted.

Hope you’re enjoying vacation!

Hi there!
So any time I talk to people about SMPs I always say that you need to pick the program that best fills your weaknesses and has good matriculation rates. So for me the major selling points of Toledo's SMP were:
  • It's only 1 year long (well, more like 10 months). I don't got time to do a 2 year program.
  • You get a degree. I ended up applying to teach (and got a job offer) at community colleges (in one of those freak out moments when I didn't know if I would get into med school) and a masters degree opens up more opportunities than does a non-degree post-bac.
  • It opened another state for me that had many schools I could get in-state tuition as a med student. Was also looking at SMPs in a few other states that did this, but Ohio is a good state to get that in-state tuition in.
  • It has a guaranteed med school interview. Many programs have this though.
  • It has a legacy of success. Very consistently 60%+ of MSBS students matriculate at UTCOM, and over 80% matriculate somewhere straight out of MSBS. Those are odds I can live with and this, possibly more than anything else was the clincher for me after evaluating all other factors. My class will keep the same rates (if not a bit better).
  • You are not competing against your classmates for a set number of spots in the medical school. They were very up front with us that they could take the entire MSBS class if they wanted to (and in the past have come really close to taking the entire class). They have the room (and to this day are still accepting people off waitlists).
  • They recruit a pretty diverse class. I'm quite possibly the most bland / non-diverse person in the class, but I do much better when I'm around people with completely different backgrounds than my own, and I felt that they did an overall good job putting together a pretty diverse class.
  • The classes were separate from med students. This was actually important to me. I don't thrive in competition. I just want to go in and do my best and not have to compare myself to others. There are other really great SMPs around that have you take classes side-by-side with med students, and you are compared to them. Wasn't for me, but is a big deal for others.
  • The same PhDs and MDs that lecture in the med school give the same lectures to the MSBS program, and overall the curriculum is super rigorous. By the end of MSBS, you will know if you gonna make it in Med School. I had a low cGPA from undergrad, so I needed pretty rigorous medical academics to convince AdComs that I don't suck.
  • Research is a large component of the program, and another area I was fairly weak in. This is where we start to see a lot of divergence from Toledo to other SMPs. Some SMPs will do MCAT prep (which I didn't want), some will even get you CPR and BLS certified (I figured whats the point since i'm hopefully going off to med school anyways), but Toledo gets you REAL research experience. Many of us got sent (all expenses paid) to various conferences around the country to present our research and network. And research experience, and pubs in particular, are freaking GOLD to AdComs. Every single medical school interview (except for Toledo) I went to asked me about my research. And if I want to do a competitive residency, I'm gonna need some research. I plan to continue on with my lab through med school and crank out them pubs.
  • Full cadaver dissection in anatomy. None of that sheep heart/brain BS. Many students also stayed on in the cadaver lab to help prepare professional quality plastination specimens. Another crazy cool opportunity.
  • Free coffee.
  • Really good volunteer opportunities in the teaching hospital right were we take classes and outpatient clinics. This was also a big deal for me as I got to know many physicians and various people on staff. This helped me line up shadowing opportunities.
  • Good cost-of-living. Comparing Toledo to Chicago, Philly, or even Cinci, it's significant.
  • Close enough to a few big cities that I can do anything, but far enough away to not get distracted.
There were plenty of cons that I think I discussed above elsewhere, but for me, the pros outweighed the cons, and I felt it gave me my best chance at going straight to med school compared to the other SMPs I got accepted at.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
That helps a lot thanks so much! I had one last question: you mentioned somewhere that most MSBSers apply during their MSBS year— if (one of the) point of the MSBS is to raise ur GPA, how are students even decently competitive for medical school at the time of entering MSBS? I might be missing something here but at least speaking from personal exp, if I entered MSBS this aug, id be entering with ~3.3 cGPA and a 512 mcat

In other words how are you guys applying to med schools during MSBS if the only grades/resume stuff you have are from pre-MSBS years?

Thanks again!
 
@Miracle_Max Since the program is now almost over how of your class got into Toledo and or other schools? Could you breakdown also how big your class size was? Will you be attending Toledo SOM

Would you still take this program over other "True SMPs" like Gtown or EVMS
 
Last edited:
That helps a lot thanks so much! I had one last question: you mentioned somewhere that most MSBSers apply during their MSBS year— if (one of the) point of the MSBS is to raise ur GPA, how are students even decently competitive for medical school at the time of entering MSBS? I might be missing something here but at least speaking from personal exp, if I entered MSBS this aug, id be entering with ~3.3 cGPA and a 512 mcat

In other words how are you guys applying to med schools during MSBS if the only grades/resume stuff you have are from pre-MSBS years?

Thanks again!

Good question: So, in my opinion, the purpose of any SMP is not necessarily to RAISE your GPA, but to ADDRESS undergrad GPA. If the SMP offers a legit masters degree, it will in no way raise your undergrad GPA, and will go into AMCAS as a separate graduate GPA. But, as you mentioned, you won't even have a transcript for the SMP available until late December once you finish your first semester/quarter, so too late to put into your primary AMCAS application until the following cycle anyways. Doing an SMP tells AdComs that "hey, look! I promise I actually don't suck as a student despite what my undergrad GPA says, and this program shows how serious I am".

So SMP's definitely make you competitive at the school where they are at, (otherwise no one would go to that SMP), but they do actually make you overall a little more competitive in the med school application cycle while you are enrolled in your SMP. Obvi they make you much more competitive in the subsequent cycle after SMP graduation, but if you can sneak in immediately right after you graduate from the SMP, might as well! So you have to apply while in the SMP (or more likely even before you start it).

So, if you mention (or list) the SMP program you are doing on your primary AMCAS application (which some people in my class did) or heavily mention it in secondaries (what I did), schools that don't have a hard numbers cutoff may see that, and want to interview you. I applied to 10 MD schools and 5 DO schools, and got 3 MD interview invites (including Toledo) and withdrew all my DO applications the second I got accepted to a DO school (which was really early on in the cycle, so technically only 1 DO interview). Every interview I went to asked me about the MSBS program (except for Toledo) and my research (part of the MSBS program). The schools I interviewed at ether did traditional interviews, or modified MMI's that can ask personalized questions at certain stations.

That said, probably no more than half the class had outside interviews. I got multiple MD acceptances, and the one DO acceptance this last cycle, where as for multiple cycles before, the best I ever did was slowly die on waitlists.

I had a 3.2 undergrad cGPA and a 508 mcat. The only thing different about my app this last cycle was I HEAVILY mentioned in my secondaries the MSBS program I was doing. Or maybe I just finally got lucky.

But yeah, other than that, you have to wait until the cycle after the SMP to reap the full benefits of adding your SMP transcripts into AMCAS.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
@Miracle_Max Since the program is now almost over how of your class got into Toledo and or other schools? Could you breakdown also how big your class size was?

Would you still take this program over other "True SMPs" like Gtown or EVMS

I will provide full stats once I get back from vacation and talk with the team that is crunching the numbers.

Off the top of my head though, I started with a class of 31, and 29 graduated (I think). only 28 interviewed at medical schools (including UTCOM). (1 guy wanted to use the MSBS program to get him into PhD school).

Last I heard (which is entirely out of date), 18 of the 28 that interviewed had been accepted at UTCOM, and at least 5 that were not accepted to UTCOM (probably more, but again I don't know the up to date stats) have outside acceptances. So, we are looking at a >60% acceptance rate at UTCOM (keeps within historical trends) and >80% of my class will be starting med school in a month (or have already started). Historically, within I think 2 years of graduating from the MSBS, Med school matriculation rates are in the high 90s %, but we won't know the overall rate of med school acceptance from my class for maybe another 2 cycles (I assume most people give up 2 failed cycles after MSBS, but what do I know).

You have to be careful when comparing SMPs to eachother, because the "success rate" they will give you will often be the overall acceptance rate of graduated students (could be years after completing the SMP), and not the immediate matriculation rate. For me, I was really only interested in the immediate matriculation rate of SMPs, which was sometimes really hard to get from some of the schools I looked into (and some schools straight up never gave me that info).

I don't really know what technically makes an SMP a "true SMP". I just assumed any masters program that is designed to funnel you into a med school was classified as an SMP, but I don't honestly know if there is a better definition.

I personally would choose just about anything over Gtown. I couldn't care less about the clout or "name brand" of a school (though im quite sure having Gtown on your transcript is a much bigger boost than having Toledo on there). Plus I would not do well living in DC and frankly can't afford it. But that's just me. I can certainly understand the appeal of going to a SMP at a big name school, it's just not for me. If you really want to go to med school at GTown, then doing well in their SMP would certainly give you a better chance compared to doing an SMP at Toledo or some other random place. Since I don't know anything about GTown's SMP, I can't really compared it to Toledo's. I also did not look into the SMP provided by EVMS, so again, I can't compare it to Toledo. I can say however that for many various reasons, I choose the Toledo MSBS program over the SMPs offered at Drexel, Duke, RosalindFranklin, Colorado State, Case Western, and Tulane (those are the ones I got accepted to besides Toledo) and I am happy with my decision.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I will provide full stats once I get back from vacation and talk with the team that is crunching the numbers.

Off the top of my head though, I started with a class of 31, and 29 graduated (I think). only 28 interviewed at medical schools (including UTCOM). (1 guy wanted to use the MSBS program to get him into PhD school).

Last I heard (which is entirely out of date), 18 of the 28 that interviewed had been accepted at UTCOM, and at least 5 that were not accepted to UTCOM (probably more, but again I don't know the up to date stats) have outside acceptances. So, we are looking at a >60% acceptance rate at UTCOM (keeps within historical trends) and >80% of my class will be starting med school in a month (or have already started). Historically, within I think 2 years of graduating from the MSBS, Med school matriculation rates are in the high 90 percent, but we won't know the overall rate of med school acceptance from my class for maybe another 2 cycles (I assume most people give up 2 failed cycles after MSBS, but what do I know). You have to be careful when comparing SMPs to eachother, because the "success rate" they will give you will often be the overall acceptance rate of graduated students (could be years after completing the SMP), and not the immediate matriculation rate. For me, I was really only interested in the immediate matriculation rate of SMPs, which was sometimes really hard to get from some of the schools I looked into (and some schools straight up never gave me that info).

I don't really know what technically makes an SMP a "true SMP". I just assumed any masters program that is designed to funnel you into a med school was classified as an SMP, but I don't honestly know if there is a better definition.

I would choose just about anything over Gtown. I couldn't care less about the clout or "name brand" of a school (though im quite sure having Gtown on your transcript is a much bigger boost than having Toledo on there). Plus I would not do well living in DC and frankly can't afford it. But that's just me. I can certainly understand the appeal of going to a SMP at a big name school, it's just not for me. If you really want to go to med school at GTown, then doing well in their SMP would certainly give you a better chance compared to doing an SMP at Toledo. But, since I don't know anything about GTown's SMP, I can't really compared it to Toledo's. I also did not look into the SMP provided by EVMS, so again, I can't compare it to Toledo. I can say however that for various reasons, I choose the Toledo MSBS program over the SMPs offered at Drexel, Duke, RosalindFranklin, Colorado State, Case Western, and Tulane (those are the ones I got accepted at besides Toledo) and I am happy with my decision.

Are you going to attend Toledo SOM?
 


^^ God among men right here

but real talk, thank you for your help, really appreciate it. Also, I think UTCOM's orientation is sometime in the next two weeks-- hope you have a great rest of your vacation and soak up as much sun before you hit the books!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
^^ God among men right here

but real talk, thank you for your help, really appreciate it. Also, I think UTCOM's orientation is sometime in the next two weeks-- hope you have a great rest of your vacation and soak up as much sun before you hit the books!

You're welcome! Feel free to reach out if you have any more questions and I'll do my best to help however I can
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Hi I realized I had a few more qs lol-

1) did most of you guys have to take out loans to pay for the program? I’m OOS and I genuinely don’t think I can work during the program after reading what u were saying about the workload...

2) do you know if UTCOM plays a role in admissions to the MSBS? Or is it just GV (and/or Anita/anyone else?)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
1) did most of you guys have to take out loans to pay for the program? I’m OOS and I genuinely don’t think I can work during the program after reading what u were saying about the workload...

Yes, and it absolutely sucked. However, keep in mind that even as an out of stater paying double the in-state rate in MSBS, if you matriculate into an Ohio state supported med school, you will be overall taking out less money in loans than if you were able to skip MSBS and matriculate into a private school. I broke it down earlier in this thread:
Tuition for MSBS.
$26,491.20 for in-state.
$53,136.40 for out-of-state.
MSBS-MS Medical Sciences: FAQs
Keep in mind that some private med schools can be 50-60k+ a year (some even more!). By going through MSBS for a year, you qualify for in-state Ohio tuition your MS1 year, which is between 30-35k at any of the Ohio State supported schools (OSU, Wright, Toledo, Cinci) . So, 53k + 35k +35k + 35k +35k = 193k for out of state MSBS + 4years of in-state med school tuition. Whereas a private med school is easily 200 -250k or higher. Case Western in Cleveland is 250k+ and most (not all) DO schools are similar in cost. So for out-of-staters, you have to decide if dropping 53k is worth opening up another potential state you can get in-state tuition for med-school in (plus you get a master's degree, make your app more competitive, and get a guaranteed interview at UTCOM... assuming you don't massive screw up).

2) do you know if UTCOM plays a role in admissions to the MSBS? Or is it just GV (and/or Anita/anyone else?)
I actually don't know how MSBS decisions are made. I am however quite confident that UTCOM plays no role in it. I suspect it's just Anita, GV, and a few select PhDs, but again this is speculation based on nothing but the fact that I ate a pancake this morning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Did all 30 (60?) of you end up taking all your classes together at the same time?

Happy orientation btw!
 
I’m hoping to apply to this program in February when my mcat comes in. Will that be too late?

I think the majority of applications come in during the Jan-March timeframe when it's becoming fairly obvious people won't be getting into Med school. My guess is that March is a good time to apply, but maybe email Ms. Anita Easterly (program coordinator) and just double check. [email protected]
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I think the majority of applications come in during the Jan-March timeframe when it's becoming fairly obvious people won't be getting into Med school. My guess is that March is a good time to apply, but maybe email Ms. Anita Easterly (program coordinator) and just double check. [email protected]
Thank you! I saw that you mentioned that the usual class size is 60 but you only had 30 in the class. Does that mean there wasn’t enough applicants for them to fill the class seats?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Thank you! I saw that you mentioned that the usual class size is 60 but you only had 30 in the class. Does that mean there wasn’t enough applicants for them to fill the class seats?

I must have mispoke. They will seat a class up-to 60. That's all they can handle (probably a limit set by UTCOM as being the max they would be willing to consider taking). Rarely has it ever historically been at 60; usually a little less. Again I don't know all that much about MSBS admissions, but my understanding is that what happens is they send out 100 acceptances (on a rolling basis I think) and historically this fills a class between 40-60. I don't think they send out any more acceptances than that. I don't know how many applications they get from year to year, but for whatever reason for my year out of the 100 acceptances they sent out, only 31 showed up and 29 graduated. From what I've seen of the incoming class, this next year's class will be larger and back into the 40-60 range.

Also as a side note, after 3 days of medical school, man am I glad I did MSBS. Biochem is a beast and I'm chillin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Also as a side note, after 3 days of medical school, man am I glad I did MSBS. Biochem is a beast and I'm chillin


this made me more than a little happy and slightly emotional lol; congrats on surviving your first half week!! Your internet stranger friends are so proud
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
So, unfortunately it looks like I won't be able to provide super in-depth stats breakdown for you guys like I wanted to for various reasons.

Here are a few basic stats from our class that may or may not be helpful. You can make your own conclusions about the numbers.
Average MSBS GPA of MSBS students that matriculated into UTCOM: ~3.8*.
Average undergrad GPA of MSBS students that matriculated into UTCOM: ~3.45*
Average MCAT of MSBS students that matriculated into UTCOM: ~507*
Number of MSBS students who started the program: 31
Number of MSBS students who graduated: 29
Number of MSBS students that interviewed at UTCOM: 28
Number of MSBS students that matriculated into UTCOM: 18
Number of MSBS students that matriculated at a medical school somewhere else: 6 (includes both MD and DO schools, with 2 of us at OSU)

*Self-reported numbers. No way to verify these.

So in general, after running the numbers a million different ways, we came to the conclusion that there were no guarantees with the MSBS program. People that 4.0d the program and had a killer MCAT were waitlisted, and people with low MCATs or low class GPA were admitted into UTCOM. We were unable to find any statistically significant predictor of success (matriculation at UTCOM) for the MSBS program. Though we are pretty confident that performance on the interview and an overall strong well-rounded application are incredibly important in addition to MSBS performance. Im pretty happy that so many of us are currently wearing white coats. There are a few people that I scratch my head about and really can't comprehend why they didn't get in somewhere, but I don't know their apps all that well.

So with that, I wish you all good luck in your future journeys to becoming physicians. I look forward to meeting you all at physician conferences in the distant future, and you can all buy me a beer. In the meanwhile, I am going to retire from SDN for a few years (until applying for residency) and focus on surviving med school. Hopefully the answers I have provided previously in this thread will help you all out if you have questions about the program.

Take care all and never give up!
MM
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Short answer: a person who has weaknesses not addressed by the Toledo program, or doesn't do well in Toledo's culture.
If you have a low MCAT, the Toledo MSBS won't help you (I suppose what you learn in the curriculum will help you crush biological sciences, but not much else). If you want to get into a prestigious or top 20 med school, the Toledo MSBS doesn't really have a track record of doing that. If you just want class with no research component, then Toledo is Really not for you. If you thrive in competition (especially taking classes along side med students and doing better than them and flexing on them) and get lazy when not competing, Toledo is not a good fit (you don't get compared to the med students or other MSBS students). If you want to gain clinical skills in an SMP, Toledo is not for you (yeah some do that). If you have good grades, good research experience, good medical exposure, and really just need volunteer experience then really no SMP should be on your radar. If you have a great app, but are kind of a jerk and/or interview poorly then SMPs in general are probably not going to be all that helpful.

To SMPs? Yeah, I had a 35 MCAT from the old school format, and a 508 from new school. 3.2 cGPA, 3.9 sGPA. 2 years of no-one-cares research with drosophila (NO ONE at any medical school I interviewed at cared. "Do rodents or you are wasting everyone's time." I was told at one point.). A stupid ton of medical exposure. OK amount of volunteering. 4 years of striking out on wait-lists at medical schools. But I am an N of 1. What is more important is the MSBS class ranges and averages. Our average MCAT was like a 505 I think with a range of 500-512ish? I don't remember. Undergrad cGPA of like 3.4-3.5 with a range of like 2.8-3.9? I should have stats of successful MSBS students over the past 2 years in a few weeks.

Yeah, I think everyone in my class did. Since you get a guaranteed interview during your MSBS year, you might as well. Why put it off and chance it after MSBS? Probably 70% or more of my class also applied to other MD/DO schools and many of us got outside acceptances (some even pulled their UTCOM applications when they got into their first choice schools).

This is a super important question and one that was most important to me in choosing a SMP. The short and official answer from UTCOM is "no - you are not starting over", and "yes-there is a chance of getting rejected based on pre-MSBS performance".
HOWEVER, what I care about is what does this school do in practice. From my class and historically, people in the Toledo MSBS got accepted into UTCOM with undergrad GPAs <3.0. Some had sub 500 MCATs that they retook during MSBS year to get above 505 (and hated their lives), and got in. Some even had "professionalism violations" or misdemeanors from undergrad and got in. So, while the short answer to your question is "no - you are not starting over", what made me choose Toledo despite that official answer is their proven track record of taking people with situations similar to my own and then matriculating them. Again, I'll have the successful MSBS student stats in a few weeks so you can compare your own stats and see if you fit into what successful MSBS students had. Choosing the right SMP is simply a game of statistics (and evaluating the cost). Find the one that gives you the best statistical chance of matriculating based on your stats, without completely bankrupting you.

Also, consider that UTCOM has many reasons to admit as many MSBS students as they can. Here are a few off my head:
  1. they know you and hopefully like you, so you arn't a wild card (if you piss people off or get professionalism violations during MSBS, your chances of matriculating will go down).
  2. you have done well (hopefully) in class material that is taught to the med students, so you statistically will do well in Med school
  3. you basically got a year of foundations of board prep, so you are more likely to do well on your boards.. and UTCOM likes it when people do well on their boards.
  4. accepting lots of MSBS students means more people will want to do MSBS, so they then get more $$$. SMP programs are kinda cash cow programs as they already have all the infrastructure and faculty in place d/t the med school. They just need a few more cadavers and pay a few people to be a program director, program coordinator, and faculty to teach extra classes.

I really don't know much about how the MSBS program chooses who they accept and not. Things that I think were helpful for me were:
  • I talked about the reasons why I wanted to be a doctor, my journey that brought me to being fascinated with medicine.
  • I talked about how my med-school application weaknesses (poor undergrad GPA) have been keeping me from reaching my goals (med school), and how I planed to use the MSBS program to address those weaknesses.
  • I didn't make any excuses about my poor undergrad cGPA, I owned it. I talked about how i've evolved as a student since then (using my high sGPA as an example that I don't actually suck), and what I have changed to ensure I won't get poor grades in MSBS.

Hope that helps! Feel free to reach out if you have any more questions!
Hello, I recently got accepted for the MSBS program 2020-2021. Could you private message me? Had some questions to ask about the program and if it is the right one for me.
 
Hello, I recently got accepted for the MSBS program 2020-2021. Could you private message me? Had some questions to ask about the program and if it is the right one for me.

Hey kingslayer, just wanted to add that @Sophil15 is a current student at Toledo MSBS and that you might want to message him too :) congrats on your acceptance!
 
Hello, Current MSBS student here. Feel free to ask me questions.
Hi! I actually have a question about which medical schools other than Toledo do students typically matriculate into? A lot of other programs list the different medical schools their students get into, but I couldn't find that with Toledo.
 
Hi! I actually have a question about which medical schools other than Toledo do students typically matriculate into? A lot of other programs list the different medical schools their students get into, but I couldn't find that with Toledo.

Probably the best place to get the most up-to-date MSBS info is in the current application cycle thread. Toledo MSBS 2020-2021, so definitely pop in there!

The most common outside matriculation sites are other Ohio and Michigan schools, and state schools for people who are from out of state.

So for my class last year, a few went to OSU, and a couple to OU (DO school). LECOM grabs a few of us every year.

In past years I can think of people that went to Wright State (I got accepted here too and many of us interviewed here. One of my interviewers here was a former MSBS grad), again various state schools for those of us that are from out of state (I got into both of my state schools), Michigan, Michigan State, Cen Michigan, Wayne St (a few of my class interviewed here)... basically everywhere in Michigan if you are from Michigan, Pen St., Baylor, Northwestern, Ponce, various DO schools I can't remember the acronyms for, Rosalind/Franklin, Arizona, Medical College Wisconsin, and I am starting to blank on the rest.

Keep in mind that many of us who matriculated here at Toledo also got into other schools, but ultimately chose to stay here.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I was told by the Dean of the program that my score of a 501 on my MCAT would be sufficient and he specifically told me not to retake the exam. I had a meeting online with him to ask him this very question. I am reading contradicting information on here and am getting a bit nervous.
 
Top