- Joined
- Jun 1, 2015
- Messages
- 17
- Reaction score
- 2
Hello,
I know there are previous threads discussing the differences, pros and cons but I would love a current perspective now that shifts in the medical world are taking place due to obama care and popularity of mid-level provider careers.
I am 30 years old, and decided to switch from my current career in journalism to medicine through the process of becoming very ill, and recovering over a span of 2 years. I had a mostly negative experience with Physicians, but there were a few stars that stuck with me, and ultimately the kind of provider I would like to become.
I initially decided to aim for NP, as being 29 (at the time of my decision) I felt MD was too long of a road. Moreover I have heard mixed reviews of what it's actually like to be a practicing physician and most of the nurses I know are very happy with their careers. I have just now completed all my pre-reqs for direct entry MSN and accelerated BSN programs and am lined up to apply, however I still feel as though I am trying to prove to myself this is the correct thing to do.
My concern about NP and PA are as follows:
*I am afraid I will not have enough scientific/medical knowledge to help others at the level I wish to*
The reason I decided to switch to a medical career is because my personal health case was very complex, and although it was not enjoyable trying to solve my own medical mystery, I want to be able to take on complex cases and really use the depth of knowledge I have, to help others. I love medical research and am sincerely fascinated by immunology, studies regarding microbiome, infectious disease, physiology in general, autoimmune problems, rare diseases etc. I think I make my point.
I do realize that NP's work with doctors in specialty fields now outside of Family Medicine. But Im assuming, if someone is seen with a less common presentation, the NP is not the one to ruminate or help the physician come to a diagnosis. Please correct me if Im wrong!
I also realize the PA's have the 'medical model' but again, same question as above... Im afraid that I will get stuck with the most basic cases and if I do encounter an individual searching for the root of a problem, it will be beyond my intellectual and legal scope to assist them in their search for an answer.
So I am basically asking if I am wrong in my assumptions. Does anyone work with NP/PA's and can confirm there is room for complex problem solving as an NP/PA?
*If I go the MD route, my career will be spent doing paperwork at a low salary (in comparison to past MD salaries)*
I am also curious if anyone is practicing as an MD, how labor intensive the current documentation process is? Do you really feel as though it has ruined being a physician? I have heard so many mixed feelings on how much documentation there is...this may be due to the fact that some had to switch to constant documentation, whereas others began their career dealing with this?
My concern regarding MD/DO is that the career will be basically flat by the time I am actually practicing, and may not be worth the effort or time (I dont really believe this, but have read on numerous accounts). By flat I mean salaries will be at an all time low and that NP/PA's will be the most common providers while MD's are overheads/supervisors.
And finally, I can become an NP by 2019, and a physician by 2025... so this is of concern as well. But if I am never satisfied as an NP, I dont think a few years matters at all in the end. I have read many forums discussing the time commitment and debt that doctors incur, however this confuses me as doctors typically make a decent salary, so the time spent and debt seems to be replaced with a high salary, allowing you to pay off those debts. Am I wrong? I dont have kids yet, but am 99% sure I dont want them, so that is not a deciding factor for me.
It is amazing if you have read this far. I so greatly appreciate any advice. Thank you!!!
I know there are previous threads discussing the differences, pros and cons but I would love a current perspective now that shifts in the medical world are taking place due to obama care and popularity of mid-level provider careers.
I am 30 years old, and decided to switch from my current career in journalism to medicine through the process of becoming very ill, and recovering over a span of 2 years. I had a mostly negative experience with Physicians, but there were a few stars that stuck with me, and ultimately the kind of provider I would like to become.
I initially decided to aim for NP, as being 29 (at the time of my decision) I felt MD was too long of a road. Moreover I have heard mixed reviews of what it's actually like to be a practicing physician and most of the nurses I know are very happy with their careers. I have just now completed all my pre-reqs for direct entry MSN and accelerated BSN programs and am lined up to apply, however I still feel as though I am trying to prove to myself this is the correct thing to do.
My concern about NP and PA are as follows:
*I am afraid I will not have enough scientific/medical knowledge to help others at the level I wish to*
The reason I decided to switch to a medical career is because my personal health case was very complex, and although it was not enjoyable trying to solve my own medical mystery, I want to be able to take on complex cases and really use the depth of knowledge I have, to help others. I love medical research and am sincerely fascinated by immunology, studies regarding microbiome, infectious disease, physiology in general, autoimmune problems, rare diseases etc. I think I make my point.
I do realize that NP's work with doctors in specialty fields now outside of Family Medicine. But Im assuming, if someone is seen with a less common presentation, the NP is not the one to ruminate or help the physician come to a diagnosis. Please correct me if Im wrong!
I also realize the PA's have the 'medical model' but again, same question as above... Im afraid that I will get stuck with the most basic cases and if I do encounter an individual searching for the root of a problem, it will be beyond my intellectual and legal scope to assist them in their search for an answer.
So I am basically asking if I am wrong in my assumptions. Does anyone work with NP/PA's and can confirm there is room for complex problem solving as an NP/PA?
*If I go the MD route, my career will be spent doing paperwork at a low salary (in comparison to past MD salaries)*
I am also curious if anyone is practicing as an MD, how labor intensive the current documentation process is? Do you really feel as though it has ruined being a physician? I have heard so many mixed feelings on how much documentation there is...this may be due to the fact that some had to switch to constant documentation, whereas others began their career dealing with this?
My concern regarding MD/DO is that the career will be basically flat by the time I am actually practicing, and may not be worth the effort or time (I dont really believe this, but have read on numerous accounts). By flat I mean salaries will be at an all time low and that NP/PA's will be the most common providers while MD's are overheads/supervisors.
And finally, I can become an NP by 2019, and a physician by 2025... so this is of concern as well. But if I am never satisfied as an NP, I dont think a few years matters at all in the end. I have read many forums discussing the time commitment and debt that doctors incur, however this confuses me as doctors typically make a decent salary, so the time spent and debt seems to be replaced with a high salary, allowing you to pay off those debts. Am I wrong? I dont have kids yet, but am 99% sure I dont want them, so that is not a deciding factor for me.
It is amazing if you have read this far. I so greatly appreciate any advice. Thank you!!!