If patients ask to be awake, I generally advise them against it unless they are a surgeon or OR nurse themselves.
It adds too much unpredictability. Sounds, smells, pulling, tugging, coughing..etc. All hard to predict how the patient will respond if they're awake.
Most importantly, I want the OR team to be comfortable and following their routine. If the OR team feels on edge because the patient is awake, or that they can't have their usual banter, it changes the flow and I think that increases the risk of mistakes.
C SXNs are different, as the expectation is to be awake.