pops317 said:
and what year are you again? obviously not a 4th year...not long enough to have been in clinic and know what its like. preclinical and clinical life are nothing alike. how many ppl in the past few years have had to stay behind because of not meeting clinical requirements? do you even know about them? most of them had to stay behind because they didn't get the patients they needed, since the pt pool is so small. so before you go glorifying the school that most of its own graduates don't even like, take a seat and talk to your upperclassmen. ask them how they like/dislike it.
I'm a 3rd year (just like it says at the bottom of my posts) and I guess I haven't been in clinic as long as you (I'm assuming you are a 4th year). Maybe I've lucked out and gotten better patients assigned to me or the ones I've recruited have been better. However, from talking to my classmates my patient type and load is not unique. They're doing dentures, removable, implants, endo, operative, and perio surgeries. Plenty of my classmates have complex cases as well.
Of course I've heard about the several people that put in an extra summer quarter each year. Obviously I can't comment on their situation and how they got there. It's very possible that ineffective patient management contributed/caused their lack of completed treatments. I've been working my ass off since I got into clinic and wouldn't want any more patients right now.
I also understand that you guys are starting to feel the pressure to graduate. Your experience is no different from any other 4th year dental student. If you read posts from dental students from other schools you'll find that everyone stresses out about graduation requirements. People always think their school's problems are unique. They are not. Some things are just part of dental school.
I know a lot of people in your class and most of them seem happy. In fact I really like your class. Obviously you're not happy, but I don't know if going to a different school would have helped this. Some people just deal with dental school better than others. It's a very stressful experience.
Regarding rude administrators and faculty, yeah some people are a little rough around the edges, but I've found if you don't try and BS them and instead play by their rules (which are generally reasonable) there's no problem and they're decent people. I actually think all the people in the clinic are really nice. I do agree that the ortho and perio secretaries are not the warmest, but that's how they want to run those clinics and it works for them and the residents. I'd want a hardass secretary too if I worked in those clinics.
I think the clinical faculty are great. They've always been nice to me and helped me when I've needed it. But then I've always been reasonable with them. I've never whined or tried to weasel my way into/out of something. My experience has been if you're respectful they'll return the favor.
As for your comments about a lack of an education, I don't get it. We certainly had enough class time to teach these things. I've learned a hell of a lot, both in lab and class. I've felt well prepared for clinic from lab. You can't ever replicate the real patient situation, but I can't image how you can get closer than simlab. You can't diagnose caries on ivorine. Plus, it's just a tooth. If I screw up, great! Now I've got endo and crown requirements. After all, I am a student. I'm going to make some mistakes.
🙂
I was in clinic today and there was 1 restorative instructor for 3 students/patients. This is a great ratio and not the first time I've seen it either. I know we had some issues with one restorative faculty member flaking on clinic in the past but from what I've seen this has been fixed.
You said the only thing you've been taught is to refer. Are you planning on doing whizzies, ortho, and perio surgery in your general practice? There's a reason there are specialties. The specialty clinics can't teach you to perform their bread and butter to the standard of care of a specialist in the brief period of time they have you.
However, I've learned a ton from the endo clinic so far. Those instructors are great. I know we don't do much of the perio surgeries but who cares, unless you want to do perio and then it doesn't even matter because you'll get 3 years of that in residency. (I hate calculus)
Another thing you mentioned was paying for patient's procedures. Clinic subsidies have gone up since last year and now even endo is on board. I'll add that occasionally paying for patient's work is not unique to UCLA students. I've even talked with some of our international (PPID) students who told me they did the same thing when they were in dental school. Again, some issues are just part of dental school. When you consider our tuition is $25,000 less than USC, it doesn't seem like that big of a deal.
I haven't noticed the exodus of instructors you talked about. I've seen the same faces for the past 3 years. How can you complain about faculty like Hewlett, Gritz, Stevenson, Morgan, Fisher, and the lovable Urbach? These guys are awesome.
The last thing was about alumni donations. You probably won't believe it but the dental school gets the highest percentage of alumni donations of any graduate school. Sure Anderson gives more per alumni but doesn't have as high a percentage from each class. And why wouldn't you donate? You'll be making great money. Don't you want to see your school get stronger? Our education is over 50% subsidized by the state of California. The way I see it we owe the state something afterwards.
Listen, I don't want to get into some lame internet message board argument. But I do like our school and will happily tell people why. That's great that you can provide the other side. I think you'll find people like us in every dental school. Some people are going to like it and others will hate it. I'd venture it has less to do with the school and more with the individual.
I hope things get better for you.