University of Pennsylvania

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Andrew_Doan

Ophthalmology, Aerospace Medicine, Eye Pathology
Moderator Emeritus
Lifetime Donor
20+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2002
Messages
5,643
Reaction score
29
Points
4,746
Location
United States
Website
dr.andrew-doan.com
  1. Attending Physician
I interviewed at Schei in 2006.

Pros: Large faculty who are well respected, chair and PD seemed like great people, residents get great fellowship matches and have ample time to participate in research. Residents get a lot of interaction with medical students. The children's hospital was amazing. Somewhat lighter call schedule.

Cons: Average surgery numbers. Philadelphia can be a con. Lower on the clinical volume.
 
Last edited:
I was hoping that others could comment on the UPenn program in terms of:

Autonomy vs. Supervision:
General atmosphere: (residents overworked, laid back, stressful/malignant?)
Call: how busy, etc. (I'm aware it is q5 for 1st/2nd year)
Quality of teaching:
Comparison with other highly academic regional programs: (ie: MEEI, NYEE, Wash U, etc.)

Thanks much in advance.
 
Excellent program. Very research oriented. They say that means they like their residents to think with innovation. Seemed like a cool philosophy. Surgical experience is average, but makes up for it with excellent teaching. Oddly large neuro-op department. Philly is pretty nice. Big name in ophtho. I think it's rare that two great programs can co-exist in the same city without overshadowing each other, but it happens here. Wills is the bigger name of course, but Scheie still shines. Happy residents.
 
General impression: Very academic and research oriented. A top program, but definitely earns its keep through its mix of clinical volume, research, and didactics. The largest attending staff I'd ever encountered (25+). Takes 5 residents a year, and the program is a very "hand-holding" program, meaning that they walk the residents through a lot of things closely and carefully for a while.

Pros: Working at one of the best hospitals, including HUP and CHOP. Very strong didactics. Great lectures and didactics, reasonable clinical volume despite 3 other residencies in the area. Very strong sense of camaraderie among the residents and attendings, though grand rounds tends to get a little tense. Very friendly staff overall. Philadelphia is also a great city to live in (despite what some other haters may say about the city).

Cons: Surgical volume is probably one of its biggest weaknesses. Cataract surgeries range from 100-140, though they are well-taught by an excellent attending (Sulewski I believe). The new chairman is trying to bring in more volume, but not sure how. Coverage is across four hospitals, but are within 6 blocks of each other. The hand-holding attitude can get irritating for some. I've also heard some residents saying they wished the residency was a year longer because they felt they did not get enough surgery and clinical exposure.

Overall: Definitely an awesome place to match, despite its flaws. Very academic atmosphere in a good way. Will be lined up for lots of top fellowships (every resident has matched into a fellowship the past several years). Was my #1 pick.
 
Any recent interviewees or residents who wouldn't mind updating us on Scheie? Thanks
 
Scheie is a fantastic program esp for people who are interested in going into academics. Faculty are very well connected. Residents have historically matched into top fellowships. My interaction with the fellows who came from Scheie when I was a med student have all been great.

I didn't get a chance to attend grand rounds, but based on my interactions with 9-10 faculty members on the interview day, I can say that they are very supportive of the residents and prioritize the needs of the residents. The chair is very involved with the program as well.

Surgical numbers are on the lower side, which I heard was around 120-140 phacos on my interview day. However, considering that there are 4 other programs in the area, I think this is adequate and understandable. Wills residents go to New Mexico to get some of their surgical numbers, and Temple residents go to Delaware to get their numbers. Scheie residents get all of their numbers in Philly, which I think is a plus.
 
Top Bottom