Honestly I might be overthinking the letters. I am getting a couple letters from preceptors I've worked with for 1-2 weeks on my sub-i where I performed very well and got great feedback, but it feels weird to get a letter from someone you've known for that little time. But maybe that's just par for the course for residency and I should adjust my expectations?
As for the misdemeanor, I'm very comfortable talking about growing from it and putting it behind me. I am hoping my strong record for service and altruism since will make for a somewhat strong narrative.
I would potentially be happy at a non-"top" IM program, but I would really like to match into as strong a program as possible to have the best training possible, as well as maintaining competitiveness for fellowship.