What a weird topic to come up today of all days.
Personally, I don't care whether someone wears a watch or what the brand is (within common sense limits, as Goro and others pointed out).
@OrthoTraumaMD, with all due respect, I completely agree with you that people who work hard deserve success and nice things. Some people wear fancy watches because they like to use them to take blood pressures, because they enjoy fashion, it just makes them feel nice to look nice, or they just don't like to tell time with their cell phones because they're worried others might perceive it as rude. I have no problem with any of those reasons for wearing a watch. I also believe it's dangerous to discriminate against people because of wealth or privilege (or any other reason that has nothing to do with their character directly). There's good people and not so good people in every category.
However, I do personally dislike it when people use fashion accessories (or anything else for that matter) to make other people feel less than. Social comparison is a plague on humanity, and I don't like people who
intentionally feed into it to feed their egos.
I think that part of what's pushing my buttons a bit about this thread is that I come from a country run by an oligarchy mostly made up of older white men born into extreme privilege and wealth. And let's just say that there are certain tell-tale signs that this power and privilege has corrupted some of them to the point where they think it's OK to harm others in heinous ways just because they feel like it. And what's more, the institutions in my country are so corrupted that causing egregious harm to another human being with malicious intent is not considered a deal-breaker when it comes to selecting a candidate for one of the most powerful positions in the country, even when everyone believes that he committed the crime.
Because of this background, part of me wonders if adcomms shouldn't start seeing young premeds wearing fancy watches as a possible sign that they should check this person more carefully and make sure they're not the kind of person who will abuse their power. The watch itself proves nothing, like I said. Lots of people wear fancy watches for lots of reasons. But it might be a risk factor with some small predictive power to help pinpoint the ones that need to be stopped before they're running the show. Or maybe not. I honestly have no idea.
As an example of something related, isn't there a study showing that people who drive Lexuses are more likely to cut off other people in traffic? Clearly, that doesn't mean everyone who drives a Lexus is a bad person. But if we can't rely on our institutions, can we really blame people for wondering if they can use details like that to pinpoint the people they need to due some extra due diligence on?