- Joined
- Mar 19, 2005
- Messages
- 7,704
- Reaction score
- 7,467
Meaningless label.....I declare "Shenanigans!"
I dunno...WHO has avoided using the designation and has pointedly announced that the term pandemic not to be used...so for them to now use the term?Meaningless label.....I declare "Shenanigans!"
I dunno...WHO has avoided using the designation and has pointedly announced that the term pandemic not to be used...so for them to now use the term?
The H1N1 was a pandemic as well. I don't think it's actually helpful, and gives the news another talking point to generate more mass hysteria.
How are you guys with testing for patients? Is it easily accessible and done now? Are you only testing the rly sick?
I think in the USA we will see higher mortality than south Korea but lower numbers cause we appear to be barely testing.
I'm not worried.....may a dread disease strike me down if I'm wrong.
using the time to schedule extra keg parties and orgies at which bodily fluid will be rampantly and wantonly exchanged.
So, how bad is the situation in Seattle? Is it exactly like Italy where they’re turning ORs into makeshift ICUs and giving up on treating anybody over age 65?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I'm definitely with birdstrike. Ebola was truly terrifying. A disease with 90% death rate that makes your insides liquify? Count me out. With a serious outbreak of that I wouldn't go to work.
For Corona virus, the media wants ratings, but 90% of the American media is on record wanting a specific political outcome in November. To many of them a recession is the only way to accomplish that at this point. They'd be happy with millions of Americans out of jobs, and an economy in ruins if it meant they got a Biden presidency.
See, I was quoting Professor Wikipedia. I, personally, thought the last wild case of Variola major was in Pakistan, in 1971! Again, thank you for that!
Actually, the outlier for polio is western central Africa (at least, per the CIA). However, you may quite very well be correct in that. Local warlords in Africa say that it is "white men trying to poison you".Probably Pakistan will take the trophy for the last case of poliio. But i will say, the government is truly fighting hard on that front with door to door vaccinations of all children in the country.
It's actually a pretty good country to live in though. Amazing food, beautiful northern areas, extremely hospitable people if you ever show up as a foreigner. Consider going to kaghan naran, hunza valley, skardu in the northern parts of the country if you want natural beauty. Lahore if you like big cities with a history and lots of examples of Mughal architecture. Or moenjodaro harappa if you want to check out ruins from some of the most ancient civilizations of the world (2500 BC).
Actually, the outlier for polio is western central Africa (at least, per the CIA). However, you may quite very well be correct in that. Local warlords in Africa say that it is "white men trying to poison you".
But, I gotta be honest here - I'm a white, lapsed Catholic, Polish/Scots-Irish guy, and you have sold me TOTALLY on Pakistan!! Forget you - I am going to retire there!
This is criminally underrated. Best comment in the forum this year by far.In case people don't want to read a subpar article written by a hypochondriac, here's the TL;DR: Journalist was in an airport in the USA where there were Chinese people getting off a plane. Journalist later gets a URI. Journalist assumes she has coronavirus. Gets mixed messages from everyone except the doctors at the ED that she goes to 3 times. The docs repeatedly say she doesn't meet criteria for testing. She then calls a bunch of people at the hospital in admin to get quotes about why they refused to test her. C-suite makes sure she gets a test for PR reasons. Surprising to absolutely no one, her swab comes back negative for COVID-19.
Dude, sold!!There are tv ads telling people to get vaccinated sponsored by the government. Literally once a year, you get government workers knock on your door and ask if they are any children in the house that need a polio vaccine - if yes, they get the polio drops. They are genuinely trying. And should hopefully get there before Western Africa.
On a side note:
All you need is 30k a year to live like a king/queen.
30k annual = $2500 monthly = 375000 Rs monthly.
Monthly rent - 100,000 ($630) for a 3-4 bedroom furnished home in the best areas of Lahore. Obviously cheaper options are available. The northern parts are dirt cheap. These are prices in the 10th largest city of the world.
Food cost - 30,000-50,000 ($200-300) if you're eating lamb, beef, chicken every day.
Utilities - 30-50000 per month. ($200-300) Mostly electricity since it's expensive.
Cook - 15000 per month ($100)
Maid for cleaning 5 days a week, a couple hours a day - 10000 per month ($63)
Driver - 15000 per month ($100). Nobody should be driving in Lahore traffic themselves lol.
And you still have half of that $2500 left for whatever else you want for entertainment ($7 for a steak, $4 for a movie). Shopping is the only variable that can be as expensive as you want. Healthcare is pretty cheap. My 4 stitches on my finger cost $0.33 a decade ago. My dad's cabg was $1500. Most middle/upper middle class families live on $1000/month. And then there is the lower middle class and lower class (more than half the country) who have a fairly difficult financial life.
A fairly new doctor with 2-3 years of experience basically makes $1000/month salary. My American board certified psychiatrist mom, Vanderbilt trained, makes $650/month for 2 days a week at a medical school lol. So $2500/month is a lot of money.
Word on the street is it's very bad, they just aren't letting on. This virus is most contagious when it's incubating and asymptomatic. We need to make like Italy now with a lockdown. Also, it's worse in young people than folks realize. Post-mortems are coming out of Seattle left and right for young ARDS/PNA patients showing COVID.
Since it seems like South Korea has had the most organized response to this, I tend to think they have what is likely to be the best data of all the affected countries. Table 2 is of particular interest.
Basically under 60 seems to have a similar death rate to flu, except that no kids have died yet (but its a pretty small N so may not mean much). Its the over 60 crowd that's getting clobbered by this.
That's not even close to true.Always do? We did phenomenally poorly with HIV, and continue to do so.
That's not even close to true.
Texas is in the process of sending out 1 million test kits. Numbers of positives will probably skyrocket, mortality percent will go down though. I hope.Yeah the complete lack of testing availability is a pretty serious letdown and we are more on a path to italy than we are on a path to South Korea.
Always do? We did phenomenally poorly with HIV, and continue to do so.
If I had asked you in the mid 1990's, "If we could reduce U.S. AIDS deaths by 75%, would that be a good thing?" you would have said, "Hell yes! Show me how to do it and let's start now!" Now 25 years later, you say the same thing is bad. U.S. HIV death rates are way down from their peak in the mid 1990's. I suppose if your response is, "But zero infections would be better," then I suppose we agree. Zero cases of HIV, COVID-19 and influenza would all be better.That's not even close to true.
Because our new infection rate is essentially the same as everyone else at the moment and are declining at the same rate as everyone else as well.Really? We have one of the highest infection rates among developed nations. Other countries don't have outbreaks like the one in Indiana. How, exactly, are we doing well?
I don't understand the constant, ongoing need to pretend COVID-19 is less of a big deal than the seasonal flu. It's more infectious, has a longer incubation period, is most infectious during the incubation period, there's no vaccine, there's no herd immunity, the population is completely naive to the virus, and the mortality rate is 20x as high.
Yeah. I know Fauci said covid-19 has a death rate of 1% which is ten times higher than this years flu which is 0.1%. And I also know that somehow flu has still managed to kill 20,000 Americans this year, and more Americans this week (20,000/52 weeks = 384), than covid-19 has killed Americans, ever (<40). And I also know that you and I agree on the most important thing, which is that neither you nor I want either one!Right. But transmission is much higher than other Western nations. That's my point.
@Birdstrike and @GeneralVeers here's Fauci himself: Top Disease Expert Repeatedly Checks People Comparing Coronavirus To The Flu
Because our new infection rate is essentially the same as everyone else at the moment and are declining at the same rate as everyone else as well.
It took us longer to get a handle on it, but we're actually pretty good at it now.
We were on the same page as of at least 2010 (maybe earlier, I just don't know). The history of HIV in this country is a troubling one, but that wasn't your initial post which is what I'm responding to.Um. Yeah. I consider it disturbing that the best-resourced country in the world is only just catching up on HIV, 40 years on.
Yeah. I know Fauci said covid-19 has a death rate of 1% which is ten times higher than this years flu which is 0.1%. And I also know that flu has killed 20,000 Americans this year, and more Americans this week (20,000/52 weeks = 384), than covid-19 has killed Americans, ever (<40). And I also know that you and I agree on the most important thing, which is that neither you nor I want either one!
I'm not going to continue to try to ease anyone's anxiety about COVID-19, anymore. That's not going to be successful. I don't care who turns out to be "right" or "wrong" with their predictions. I'm just going to take common sense actions and follow recommended precautions like everyone else while moving forward with a positive attitude that'll we'll get past this, like we have other health threats. As things progress, I'll gladly change and adjust, as the facts change as will our CDC and infection control agencies. But other than preparing for the worst, which is having myself and family follow infection precautions to keep from getting viral pneumonia, and hoping for the best, there's not much more that I can do. If COVID-19 "crushes our health systems" here in the States, then we'll have much bigger problems than whether or not I come to SDN and admit I turned out to be wrong. And if we pass through this better than expected, then I'll be too happy about that to worry about who predicted the best or worst, as we all hopefully will.Sure. But COVID is just starting to ramp up here. I would consider a disease that is 10-20x as deadly and more contagious to have much more potential for mass devastation and hospital system collapse. The flu hasn't crushed any health systems this year, unlike COVID-19.
Um. Yeah. I consider it disturbing that the best-resourced country in the world is only just catching up on HIV, 40 years on.
I don't think it's too surprising, the two primary American demographics for HIV were gay men and IV drug abusers. Had it been spreading in less "objectionable" subgroups I think we would have seen the research progress at a significantly quicker rate.
Keep in mind, when COVID-19 sweeps through a nursing home, not only are these people elderly, they're very likely to have DNR orders on file. So if they get sick and it's a survivable COVID-19 infection that's treatable with aggressive care, they may die anyways, because they're allowed to die, pre-existing DNR orders. So when you go to Seattle, for example, on this really great COVID-19 tracking map and you see 30 deaths in Seattle alone (which is 75% of the deaths in our whole country) out of 373 cases, and conclude a death rate of 8%, you have to ask, 1) How many were in nursing home patients, and 2) How many of those patients were DNR?
It's already been reported that 18 of those deaths in Seattle were from one nursing home. How many others were from other nursing homes in Seattle? How many of those patients were DNR?
I realize that the fact a patient was DNR doesn't make the virus any less lethal to this population, in fact more so. Also it doesn't make their death any less tragic or ease the pain of the family. But epidemiologically it does make a big difference. It means, 1) Nursing homes need to be under the strictest isolation precautions because COVID-19 is incredibly dangerous in that setting, which so far everyone seems to understand, but it also means that, 2) Just because COVID-19 swept through a nursing home and killed 18 extremely elderly patients most of whom were under DNR orders, doesn't mean it's going to sweep through your house, kill everyone in your family and collapse the country's health care systems. It might do that. But it might not. It might sweep through your house and give you all nothing but the sniffles, anti-bodies against COVID-19 and a lifetime supply of TP. Or maybe you won't get it at all.
What is it that you want me to do, with this information? What are you trying to convince me to do or think? To wash my hands, avoid sick people, stay home if I get sick, get the vaccine when it comes out, don't take any trips to Europe, Iran, or China, and that we don't want to become Italy? Because if so, I'm convinced. But beyond that, I'm not sure what you're trying to convince me of at this point.Since we aren't testing people, we won't know, and we can't know. We will know something is up if we see a big bump in admissions and ICU patients. Which is what happened in Italy; I'm not sure why we are so quick to dismiss their disaster. Or the number of young people affected there. Or the effect on their health system, which is collapsing.
What is it that you want me to do, with this information? What are you trying to convince me to do or think? To wash my hands, avoid sick people, stay home if I get sick, get the vaccine when it comes out, don't take any trips to Europe, Iran, or China, and that we don't want to become Italy? Because if so, I'm convinced. But beyond that, I'm not sure what you're trying to convince me of at this point.
Agreed.I think we should all promote and publicly support social distancing,
Agreed.I think we should all promote and publicly support ... encourage your health facility to test widely
As exactly stated, technically, I agree that telling patients this right now, as doing so is probably without much downside, so they take virus precautions seriously. But ultimately we won't know it's true until it's run it's course and the two can be compared at large. And it depends on how you define, "worse." If you're going by the death rate, we can't say which is "worse" yet, because as you said yourself, we know the number of deaths but don't know the total number of cases and therefore don't know the death rate rate and may (or may not) go down dramatically as we test more and identify carriers that aren't sick. If you are defining "worse" as by total number of deaths, it's not even close to being true yet, with influenza killing 250,000-500,000 per year worldwide, including right now, to not yet 5,000 so far, for covid-19. It might get there, but currently by that measure, it far, far away.I think we should all promote and publicly support... help inform our patients that this is much worse than the flu.
I guess I'm a "Right-wing Conspiracy Theorist" for stating facts:
1. The news media (including Fox) is reporting on every death, and whipping up hysteria to help feed their 24-hour news cycle. Rather than just encourage people to wash their hands, and stay home if they are sick, they are encouraging hording and broadcasting "what if" apocalyptic scenarios.
![]()
Pence says there's been 'irresponsible rhetoric' from people downplaying the coronavirus
Trump said Monday that the “fake news media and their partner, the Democrat Party, is doing everything to inflame the coronavirus situation.”www.nbcnews.com
But Veers, I don't think you understand. How much panic is enough? They've whipped the country into such a frenzy, the stock market, our life's savings are down 30%. But maybe that's not enough. 40 people have died from coronavirus, preventive measures are under way, but the number is going to grow. So maybe they need to panic the stock market down 40%. No, maybe 40% isn't enough. Oh, but wait until the media discovers that 50,000 American die every week in America. Then, maybe notching the panic up a notch so the market goes down 80%, will help. Then when they realize half of those deaths are preventable, caused literally by food, that we voluntarily choose to ingest in poisonous quantities, they'll really put the flame thrower to the panic and burn everything to the ground so we're in a Great Depression. That'll help. We'll be thin, healthy, virus free and we'd live forever, if not for the dying of starvation waiting in bread lines.1. The news media (including Fox) is reporting on every death, and whipping up hysteria to help feed their 24-hour news cycle. Rather than just encourage people to wash their hands, and stay home if they are sick, they are encouraging hording and broadcasting "what if" apocalyptic scenarios.