what is the answer?
Started by laya533
laya533 said:
Hmmm...
I'd eliminate III., because if I wanted skin respiration, I'd probably design it with a capillary bed beneath a thin moist membrane.
At that point I'd go 50/50. My guess would be II, too dry, but this is really a stupid question. Where did you get it from?
http://www.scientia.org/cadonline/Biology/respiratory/respiration.ASP
....In order to perform these two functions, the human respiratory system must meet the four basic needs common to all aerobic respiratory systems: 1) It must provide a large enough respiratory surface to take in enough oxygen for all the cells of an individual; 2) it must provide a method of transporting gases between the area of exchange with the outside environment and the internal cells; 3) it must protect the exchange surface from mechanical injury; and 4) it must keep the exchange surface moist so that gases can diffuse into solution and be absorbed by the body.
Compare your lungs and your skin at this point:
1)surface area: skin has lots; moving on
2)method of transport: capillary system (skin has it)
3)protect: yes (thick)
4) moisture: nope. My guess is "too dry"
I guess you could compare your skin to a frog's, too
....In order to perform these two functions, the human respiratory system must meet the four basic needs common to all aerobic respiratory systems: 1) It must provide a large enough respiratory surface to take in enough oxygen for all the cells of an individual; 2) it must provide a method of transporting gases between the area of exchange with the outside environment and the internal cells; 3) it must protect the exchange surface from mechanical injury; and 4) it must keep the exchange surface moist so that gases can diffuse into solution and be absorbed by the body.
Compare your lungs and your skin at this point:
1)surface area: skin has lots; moving on
2)method of transport: capillary system (skin has it)
3)protect: yes (thick)
4) moisture: nope. My guess is "too dry"
I guess you could compare your skin to a frog's, too
so it is I and II? (well...the first II)
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I'd go with II, dry skin. All of our outer skin cells are dead. Contrast with frogs, which have pulmocutaneous circulation (some respiration through skin).
I have no idea how you remembered that.laya533 said:
I couldn't remember where I parked my car after the April MCAT!
laya533 said:
Really? Then was there an option I and II?
Animals that use moist skin as a respiratory surface exchange gases by simple diffusion. The skin of humans is both too thick and too dry to accomodate diffusion of gases. As mentioned earlier, thin skin with a capillary bed would aid skin respiration. The answer is I and II.
ADam
ADam
As a reminder, you should've learned this in general biology: cutaneous respiration (or any respiration for that matter) can only occur if the membrane (skin) is thin, moist, and well-vascularized.
No, it isn't quite. I remember this question; the question itself and the first two choices are approximately what was there, but the third is not. Also, the question stem on the MCAT specifically mentioned the walking catfish, if I recall correctly.laya533 said:
Unfortunately, I don't remember what the analog of your choice III was (I memorized that test, but it was a while ago); I know it was similar to what you wrote, but the statement made somewhat more sense than it does as you've written it. (If it had been a reasonable choice, however, I'd probably remember it; apparently it was easy to dismiss.)
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Shrike, you're a strange person. Not in a bad way, you understand, but still.Shrike said:
Shrike, I have heard it from others who took it. I just wanted to let the others know about that. they can probably figureout the III in the test. I just wanted to have a general concept for answering that. Any argues with that? 😕
I am not arguing, I am pointing out that the wording on the test differed from what you wrote, and by extension that that difference may affect people's reactions to the question. I agreed that the concept was present. In effect, I backed you up.
You have no idea...... 🙄liverotcod said:
This is both accurate, and an understatement. 👍Shrike said:
Hello, BTW. Nice to see you. 🙂
