what's up with u chicago rejecting this early?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Yup, those IL schools. Haha, Northwestern is rejecting people left and right too. I've been sitting on my Pritzker secondary for a while already. Not sure if I should even complete it, considering the swiftness with which Northwestern swatted me down.
 
umm, not to sound mean but go look at the rejection thread, a lot of schools are rejecting people and started as early as August. Not at all unusual
 
leiface said:
umm, not to sound mean but go look at the rejection thread, a lot of schools are rejecting people and started as early as August. Not at all unusual

A lot of those rejections are pre-secondaries. Northwestern and Pritzker has the most post-sec rejections.
 
Cmon man... not everyone can be accepted at Chicago. With your stats, youll definitly get in somewhere good (and not to mention your excellent choice of undergrad 😉)
 
Both U Chicago and Northwestern wasted no time in rejecting me. In fact, I got both rejections in the mail on the same day! Wasn't too good for the ego, but I've gotten some good interviews since then so I am now over it.

UC has rolling admissions and NW sort of does, so maybe thats one reason. UC says that they might put you on hold but I wonder if thats something they actually do very often or if it is likely you will end up interviewing if that is the case.
 
iamgoaloriented said:
Both U Chicago and Northwestern wasted no time in rejecting me. In fact, I got both rejections in the mail on the same day! Wasn't too good for the ego, but I've gotten some good interviews since then so I am now over it.

UC has rolling admissions and NW sort of does, so maybe thats one reason. UC says that they might put you on hold but I wonder if thats something they actually do very often or if it is likely you will end up interviewing if that is the case.


So did I! Axis of evil!!!!! 😡
 
iamgoaloriented said:
Both U Chicago and Northwestern wasted no time in rejecting me. In fact, I got both rejections in the mail on the same day! Wasn't too good for the ego, but I've gotten some good interviews since then so I am now over it.

UC has rolling admissions and NW sort of does, so maybe thats one reason. UC says that they might put you on hold but I wonder if thats something they actually do very often or if it is likely you will end up interviewing if that is the case.

Some people got placed on hold at Pritzker on the forums. So what are they looking for in an applicant? Their average stats, which usually doesn't tell you much anyway, are not as high as NW or some of the other more notable schools.
 
Uegis said:
Some people got placed on hold at Pritzker on the forums. So what are they looking for in an applicant? Their average stats, which usually doesn't tell you much anyway, are not as high as NW or some of the other more notable schools.

I have no idea what they are looking for. My stats are way above their averages, above average for Northwestern to, but of course there is a lot more to it than that.

U Chicago's undergraduate institution has a reputation for putting a lot of weight on their essays, don't they, so I am wondering if the med school does to? The essay about the guiding principles of everyday living (I dont remember the exact wording) really annoyed me. I was a little bold in the essay about the ethical dilemna to. I wrote it carefully but perhaps it got me in trouble.

Northewestrn essay asking to bs about their "innovative curriculum" was also annoying, as if its so obviously radically different from everyone elses.

People have told me that it is far more likely that good applicant get rejected for random reasons as opposed to writing sub par essays, but I think the essay do carry a good bit of weight, especially at UC. Another thing to consider is the schools mission. Some schools want to send all of their students into research (like Mayo so I've heard), and even if you are an amazing applicant, if you state that your goal is to treat patients, as good as you may be what use to do they have for you.

I think it comes down to being well rounded, fitting their mission, standing out in some good way, and being lucky. Numbers matter somewhat but so many people have good grades and test scores that they alone mean virtually nothing.
 
iamgoaloriented said:
U Chicago's undergraduate institution has a reputation for putting a lot of weight on their essays, don't they, so I am wondering if the med school does to? The essay about the guiding principles of everyday living (I dont remember the exact wording) really annoyed me. I was a little bold in the essay about the ethical dilemna to. I wrote it carefully but perhaps it got me in trouble.

Can I ask what you wrote about for the ethical dilemma? You make me nervous about what I wrote about now... 😕
 
lizbjrddnr said:
Can I ask what you wrote about for the ethical dilemma? You make me nervous about what I wrote about now... 😕

I would have to go into a lot of detail to describe the exact situation to you (U Chicago was the only school that allowed me room to use this story, I used a milder story for other schools and am glad I did). If I try to tell you without all the details you will probably be horrified (I do believe I did the right thing, or at least what I did was reasonable), so I will just leave it at that.

Did you go the route of describing a situation in which you failed to act or possibly did the wrong thing? That's not necessarily bad. I went that route for the other two schools who asked the question and got interviews. I know someone who got accepted who did the same thing as well. You have to write about such a situation correctly of course (I'm not sure telling people how is appropriate but I'm sure most if not all of you should know how to go about it).
 
iamgoaloriented said:
I would have to go into a lot of detail to describe the exact situation to you (U Chicago was the only school that allowed me room to use this story, I used a milder story for other schools and am glad I did). If I try to tell you without all the details you will probably be horrified (I do believe I did the right thing, or at least what I did was reasonable), so I will just leave it at that.

Did you go the route of describing a situation in which you failed to act or possibly did the wrong thing? That's not necessarily bad. I went that route for the other two schools who asked the question and got interviews. I know someone who got accepted who did the same thing as well. You have to write about such a situation correctly of course (I'm not sure telling people how is appropriate but I'm sure most if not all of you should know how to go about it).

My situation was failure to act but that that turned out to be the right decision...
Np, if not comfortable saying what it was
 
Top