Hey Jaded03,
Congrats on your acceptances to both schools
My advice after just graduating from UCLA and as I am about to start medical school - is to go where you feel you'll have the greatest opportunities.
My stats after high school were not as good as yours. I chose UCLA and survived as a premed.
UCLA is competitive- but if you?re disciplined, open minded and persistent you'll get into medical school. You can still have a life and get into medical school out of UCLA.
After spending some time on the UCI campus and talking to premeds there- i felt UCLA has a better pre-med applicant pool because of the competitiveness. You?re forced to stay on your toes, and explore your other options. I'm not saying that the premeds from UCI are not as smart or not as well rounded. However, UCI students seemed to be less focused.
The competition is not as bad as you may think. There are a handful of classes where the curves may hurt you. For the most part the curves help.
There are so many opportunities for clinical and research experience through the school and in the surrounding areas. The medical center is on campus, which adds to greater exposure to the medical field.
The main negative aspect of being a premed at UCLA- at least in my eyes- is the lack of a good premed counselor. Karol Johansen at the career center is supposed to be the new "pre med counselor", but she just adds to the pessimism geared toward premeds on campus. The upperclassman will give you the best advice.
Professors teaching the "weeder" classes tend to have negative attitudes toward premeds- all you have to remember is that they are there to teach you about xyz, they are not your career counselor. There is a reason they have a PhD. and not and MD. - and you have your reasons for going after the MD.
Recently, there have been a handful of new premed organizations popping up. Those groups have done a great job at bridging the gap between the UCLA med students and the premeds.
Go visit the UCI campus and find the premeds, find the premed AMSA people, ask them about the kind of research you can get involved in as an undergrad, what kind of clinical opportunities there are, and what kind of support/counseling system there is for premeds there.
Whatever decision you'll make - I am sure it will be the best one.
But I don't think a little competition should discourage you.