This is just my opinion....
PCOM and MSUCOM have the reputation for haveing the best academics...NYCOM has the reputation of having the best hospital affiliates to do clerkships in. NYCOM also has a higher % of students going into speciality fields.
I just graduated this year from NYCOM and I can telll you this, my classmates did great in the match, both allopathic and osteopathic an we kicked butt in the competitive fields....10 Surgery (5 allo,5 osteo), 18 ER (12 osteo, 6 allo), ?5 or 6 Radiology(3 allo/2-3 osteo), 6Neurology (6allo), 1 optho(ALLO), 1 Urology(ALLO),....this is off the top of my head, but as you can see we kicked butt.
Here is my advice, you should check into as many schools as possible, because no matter how great the school is, if you hate the school, you will be going into a tough 4 years with a strike against you. Good luck....pm me if u have more questions