Why so many race threads????

Med School Insiders
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
R

Redpen200

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2006
Messages
34
Reaction score
0
Members don't see this ad.
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
 
Redpen200 said:
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
Click to expand...

why are some people so uptight. who cares just skip the thread and move on with your life.
 
dude relax..its juss a community within a community..its fine to me as long as everyone respects one another and doesnt throw out any racist remarks...I started the Nigerian thread so i can share some similar experiences, stories, etc. with my fellow Nigerians..thats all..thus far it has really been successful and informative..so its not a bad thing to start an ethnic thread..not everything should be gpa, mcat, and extra currics...
 
Personally I don't care one way or the other whether they start a thread, but I don't think the AMCAS and similar things should be allowed to inquire about race or ethnic origin.
 
DropkickMurphy said:
Personally I don't care one way or the other whether they start a thread, but I don't think the AMCAS and similar things should be allowed to inquire about race or ethnic origin.
Click to expand...

I don't really care that much, either, i guess, i just don't understand it. And I agree that race/ethnic origin shouldn't even be a factor in the med school application process.
 
the race factor in the med school app process is widely exaggerated among premeds. it is a very small factor.
 
I must say I enjoyed the "Any cyborg premeds out there?" parody thread, though.
 
Redpen200 said:
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
Click to expand...

redpen, i imagine this is a serious issue to you as you've dedicated 20% of your total posts to it. hahahah why the beef with koreans and nigerians? it seems you forgot one other race that is taking up a lotmore space on the boards: the texans, or those who hail from the republic of texas. they'll got about 6 diff threads. if you're gonna discriminate, at least be an equal opportunity discriminator.
 
And I was about to start something for dutch premeds. Never mind.
 
Redpen200 said:
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
Click to expand...

I agreee.....bringing up the race question is just plain out stupid........what does race have do with all of us trying to get into medical schools?
 
DropkickMurphy said:
Then why not get rid of it all together?
Click to expand...

Good point. I guess theyre trying to be consistent with everything else in America that inquires about race... but I was just saying that race is not necessarily "factored" in like in some undergrad processes and if people talked with admissions officials they would realize that
 
BarrySanders said:
the race factor in the med school app process is widely exaggerated among premeds. it is a very small factor.
Click to expand...

With all due respect, what evidence do you have to support this assertion? At my school there is significant preference given to URMs. At the time of their initial application, they are put in touch with the 'Dean of Diversity', who personally coaches them on how to maximize their chances for admission to our school. The Diversity Office runs them through numerous mock interviews and gives exensive advice on completion of their secondary applications.

Maybe this is necessary because my school is pretty much in a 'white bread' area and URMs might not otherwise feel welcome here ... I don't know. But it doesn't seem to be a 'very small factor' here.
 
Any Asian female premeds in this thread agree with the OP?
 
Tired Pigeon said:
With all due respect, what evidence do you have to support this assertion? At my school there is significant preference given to URMs. At the time of their initial application, they are put in touch with the 'Dean of Diversity', who personally coaches them on how to maximize their chances for admission to our school. The Diversity Office runs them through numerous mock interviews and gives exensive advice on completion of their secondary applications.

Maybe this is necessary because my school is pretty much in a 'white bread' area and URMs might not otherwise feel welcome here ... I don't know. But it doesn't seem to be a 'very small factor' here.
Click to expand...

With all due respect, yes your school may be doing a fair amount of urm recruiting, but like i said race is a small factor in the actual admissions process and decision making. Upon submitting an amcas app, there is not much that the applicant can be told to better his/her chances (that the applicant does not already know). I'm sure that non-urm applicants to your school may receive advice if they inquire, but since the urm students at your school are being "recruited" then they just do not have to inquire. What kind of edge will be gained by giving advice on secondary apps? This does not equate at all to being a factor in admissions decisions.
 
Redpen200 said:
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
Click to expand...

Are you one of the restaurant owners who has the sign "you are in America, so order in ENGLISH" :laugh:. I guess surfing through SDN i get the impression perhaps America isnt the melting pot I always thought it was...
 
someone needs to make that damn owl a tos violation
 
EBI831 said:
redpen, i imagine this is a serious issue to you as you've dedicated 20% of your total posts to it. hahahah why the beef with koreans and nigerians? it seems you forgot one other race that is taking up a lotmore space on the boards: the texans, or those who hail from the republic of texas. they'll got about 6 diff threads. if you're gonna discriminate, at least be an equal opportunity discriminator.
Click to expand...

THE EMPEROR OF THE WORLD IS TEXAN!

george-bush-picture-52-766813.jpg
 
BarrySanders said:
What kind of edge will be gained by giving advice on secondary apps? This does not equate at all to being a factor in admissions decisions.
Click to expand...

Secondaries weigh very heavily here (YMMV, of course). Ours had a lot of essays, and advice on what to say & how to say it, along with extensive editing services, could provide a significant advantage. Also, I think the previously mentioned practice interviews could be quite helpful as well.
 
And no, these services weren't available to non-URM applicants.
 
Tired Pigeon said:
Secondaries weigh very heavily here (YMMV, of course). Ours had a lot of essays, and advice on what to say & how to say it, along with extensive editing services, could provide a significant advantage. Also, I think the previously mentioned practice interviews could be quite helpful as well.
Click to expand...


What school is this and what does "YMMV" mean?
 
eternalrage said:
THE EMPEROR OF THE WORLD IS TEXAN!
Click to expand...

Born in Connecticut
High school at Andover
College at Yale
MBA at Harvard

Nah, he's the heir of old New England money trying to pass himself off as Texan.
 
Gut Shot said:
Born in Connecticut
High school at Andover
College at Yale
MBA at Harvard

Nah, he's the heir of old New England money trying to pass himself off as Texan.
Click to expand...
Thank you....you beat me to it.
 
DropkickMurphy said:
Your mileage may vary. He attends the school that has a large number of minorities that created this:
exploitedtroll_pigeon.jpg
Click to expand...

Geez, DKM, just when I was starting to fall in love 😍 with your brilliant wit, you have to crush my dreams.
 
Gut Shot said:
Born in Connecticut
High school at Andover
College at Yale
MBA at Harvard

Nah, he's the heir of old New England money trying to pass himself off as Texan.
Click to expand...

and I believe is GPA was 2.4. I feel secure, how about you?
 
They deserve their own thread. And EnternalRage gets a free pass because of his impeccable taste. I am a white guy. Oh, never mind. It is too complicated.
 
<---Sitting by inbox waiting for the reported posts to pile up :meanie: DKM your cereal doesnt include the asian guy, im offended lol jp
 
Redpen200 said:
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
Click to expand...

I have been asking this for 5 years.
 
I went on a good amount of interviews, and do you know how many black people I saw...10? All 10 were at black medical school interviews. Out of those 10 black people, do you know how many were guys?.....1. As you are applying, sometimes its nice to know that you aren't the only one out there. Its a basic principle of life; people commune with those whom they share similarities. Its a bloodly online forum; leave it alone because there are thousands of other threads.

Also, most of the race threads are spoofs of the real ones.
 
Redpen200 said:
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
Click to expand...

Dude, I go into like, all the random race threads and read them and post anyways. It's not like you're not allowed into the threads just because you're not of that particular ethnicity, lol.

Personally I find it kinda interesting, since you'll see people relate about culturally specific things whether it's food or being beaten as a child because you got an A-.

Seriously though, it's not like the threads say you're not allowed in if you're not black/white/korean/chinese/nigerian. I'm pretty sure I've posted in like 4 different ethnicity threads, and only one was my own ethnicity, lol. And I'm also sure that I wasn't chased out by people with pitchforks in any of those threads, lol.

So get over yourself ok? Maybe go see how people are relating to each other in those threads, lol.

Plus seriously, some of those posts would make NO SENSE in a regular thread. Observe:

"My parents beat me with bamboo sticks when I was a kid, because I went on a field trip and bought souvenirs. In fact, the bamboo sticks were the souvenirs. I had so many injuries it hurt like hell to even try to sit for the next 2 weeks. And one time they beat me so hard the bamboo sticks actually broke."
Reaction in regular thread: Other members stare at you with jaws wide with horror, proceed to ask why you didn't tell your teacher and have your parents arrested.
Reaction in asian-themed thread: Other members one-up you with more violent beatings, proceed to make you feel both at home and lucky that you hadn't purchased ninja throwing stars as souvenirs.

"Man I can't wait to go home and have some kimchi and bibimbap, and blood and rice vermicelli stuffed inside of pig intestines (yeah sorry, I'm not actually korean so I have no idea what koreans call this, and I don't even know what it's called in Chinese other than pig intestines with blood stuffed inside)! Oh boy!"
Regular thread: Questions about what bibimbap is, and EWWW WTF PIG INTESTINES WITH BLOOD?!
Asian thread: Oh yeah pig intestines are delicious, have you tried *fill in probably much more disturbing dish involving either genitalia or animal you usually run away from on a plane*
 
Redpen200 said:
Why are there so many thread topics of "Any (insert race here) premeds here?" What the hell does it matter if there are other Korean premeds on the forums, or Nigerians, or any other race? I can understand for some minorities that need suggestions based on something specific to that race, but its reeally unnecessary to simply do a roll call. Quit cluttering the board.
Click to expand...

Because in the USA we judge people by the color of their skin, not the content of their character... duH!!
 
DropkickMurphy said:
Happy now?

Colorfinger-fortee.jpg
Click to expand...

i am sitting here wondering how many people have heard of fawlty (not sure the real spelling) towers - let alone watched all of them) and know what a classic british comedy it is...

you have to like john cleese a lot though
 
mikeinsd said:
i am sitting here wondering how many people have heard of fawlty (not sure the real spelling) towers - let alone watched all of them) and know what a classic british comedy it is...

you have to like john cleese a lot though
Click to expand...
The German tourist episode still ranks as one of the great pieces of comedy ever recorded. "Oh, you're speaking German! And I thought there was something wrong with you!" :laugh:
 
"Polly - whatever you do, dont mention the war... I mentioned it once, but I think I got away with it..."😱


"que?"
 
icecoldalpha06 said:
dude relax..its juss a community within a community..its fine to me as long as everyone respects one another and doesnt throw out any racist remarks...I started the Nigerian thread so i can share some similar experiences, stories, etc. with my fellow Nigerians..thats all..thus far it has really been successful and informative..so its not a bad thing to start an ethnic thread..not everything should be gpa, mcat, and extra currics...
Click to expand...

It's fine with me too, and I understand the desire to bond with people of similar backgrounds! Only drawback is that it perpetuates the "left out" feeling amongst many SDNers that ethnic/racial groups always found so unpleasant and unacceptable. It was my impression that the only real "group" here is "medical school hopefuls", which crosses all ethnic and racial lines. Everyone is in the same group here, actually!
 
mikeinsd said:
"Polly - whatever you do, dont mention the war... I mentioned it once, but I think I got away with it..."😱


"que?"
Click to expand...
"You started it!"
"No, you started it!"
"NO! YOU started it! YOU invaded Poland!"
*goosesteps out of the dining room*

:meanie:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

M
How many applicants have type 1 diabetes?
Replies
7
Views
368
Mr.Smile12
Mr.Smile12
J
Ethnicity/Race
Replies
6
Views
1K
Mr.Smile12
Mr.Smile12
H
why does it take so long for amcas to process your primaires?
Replies
13
Views
3K
RunnerDad
R
T
SGU why bad rep?
Replies
5
Views
3K
Splenda88
S
uaena123
How do some applicants have so many publications?
Replies
7
Views
2K
EdgeTrimmer
EdgeTrimmer
Top