Wondering about importance of early interview

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

dsk89

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2012
Messages
323
Reaction score
14
I keep seeing people on SDN say that only the extremely qualified people get such early interviews where they interview in August and September. However, I'm definitely an underdog applicant for MD schools, yet I got an interview at a private school, where I interviewed at in late August (I was in the batch of the first 25 interviewees for that school). How much does interviewing early really matter? Does this necessarily put me in a good position? Any input would be helpful, thanks!

EDIT: I am not URM
 
See, this comes from a fundamental misunderstanding concerning "qualification." Indeed, more qualified applicants who apply early are given priority when it comes to interview invitations. That being said, you might have below median statistics and still be one of the more qualified applicants at a school if you have ECs that they find valuable (I don't like saying that there are good and bad ECs, but rather ECs that different schools will apply a certain value to) and also fit the mission of the medical school. Your essays are also very important - I know I had at least one interviewer remark about my personal statement and supplemental essays being both passionate and well written.

Yes, there is no denying that your numbers are one of the most important aspects to your application, but be confident - you receiving an interview means that they find your academic transcript to be strong enough that you could succeed academically at their school, or else they wouldn't have offered the interview.

Now I'll get off my soapbox for a second to answer your question. First, does this school have rolling admissions? If so, then interviewing early is a huge advantage, even if you don't know that the school is extremely selective for interviews. Even if it isn't rolling, they had to make some serious cut downs between primary/secondary applications and interviews, and the fact that you weren't even put on hold to review your application in the future indicates that you were probably in a good to strong position before you even went to the interview. From there, it's up to your interview to REALLY set you apart and earn you an acceptance versus a hold/waitlist spot in October.
 
See, this comes from a fundamental misunderstanding concerning "qualification." Indeed, more qualified applicants who apply early are given priority when it comes to interview invitations. That being said, you might have below median statistics and still be one of the more qualified applicants at a school if you have ECs that they find valuable (I don't like saying that there are good and bad ECs, but rather ECs that different schools will apply a certain value to) and also fit the mission of the medical school. Your essays are also very important - I know I had at least one interviewer remark about my personal statement and supplemental essays being both passionate and well written.

Yes, there is no denying that your numbers are one of the most important aspects to your application, but be confident - you receiving an interview means that they find your academic transcript to be strong enough that you could succeed academically at their school, or else they wouldn't have offered the interview.

Now I'll get off my soapbox for a second to answer your question. First, does this school have rolling admissions? If so, then interviewing early is a huge advantage, even if you don't know that the school is extremely selective for interviews. Even if it isn't rolling, they had to make some serious cut downs between primary/secondary applications and interviews, and the fact that you weren't even put on hold to review your application in the future indicates that you were probably in a good to strong position before you even went to the interview. From there, it's up to your interview to REALLY set you apart and earn you an acceptance versus a hold/waitlist spot in October.

Thanks for the helpful explanation! And yes, this school is rolling admissions. So now I'll just wait and hope for the best!
 
I definitely don't agree with the sentiment that only high number applicants get early interviews; I was an example of someone who broke that trend last year. I think it's more whether or not you fit their mission. Something I noticed with my early interviews was that they were all at places focused on community service and underserved medicine, which probably was my biggest selling point in my application and then my later interviews were at places that did not have as big of a focus on that. So I think it probably has a lot more to do with the mission fit more than any numbers. The numbers are more a bar you must meet to get an interview invite; there are some schools with a high bar and you could say those schools are the ones with only high number applicants...I think of schools like UChicago and Pitt since they give out IIs so fast but in reality, most schools outside the top tier aren't like that.
 
Top