So what if you're playing b-ball with a friend who tears a ligament and it's the weekend, you know that the ER won't do anything for him and he needs to see an orthopedic surgeon but the dude is in a lot of pain. you can't simply call in a prescription for some Tylenol #3? to hold him over until he sees an orthopedic surgeon on monday or tuesday?
There are a lot of assumptions in this situation.
- You're assuming that you know enough to correctly diagnose a torn ligament (without missing anything potentially more serious, like an avulsion fracture) with minimal diagnostic equipment.
- You're assuming that the Tylenol #3 will be enough to hold him. It probably will, but what if he calls you up at 11 PM and says "I'm in too much pain; these pills aren't doing anything for me." Then what?
- You're assuming that the ER "won't" do anything for him. At the very worst, they can rule out anything potentially more serious and give him adequate analgesia. They may even be able to put a brace on it should that be necessary.
- You're assuming that your friend actually WILL go to the orthopod on Monday or Tuesday. If he goes to the ER and they send him home with instructions for followup, but he doesn't, at least they have documentation that he was neurovascularly intact, that they told him to followup, etc. If he doesn't go to ortho, and something goes wrong, and he points the finger at you, then what? What are you going to say when he says that you didn't tell him to go to ortho? Or that you just gave him pain meds but didn't make him go to the ER for x-rays?
A friend called me a few weeks ago. She said that she was having suprapubic pain, with a lot of urinary urgency. She had had a UTI a few weeks ago and "cipro really helped," so could I call some more cipro in for her? I told her no, sorry, but if it was that unbearable that she was calling me on a weekend, she should go to the ER. You know what that "suprapubic pain" turned out to be? An incarcerated hernia - she was in the OR 12 hours after I talked to her. You never know.