WW: -Omitted Topic-: Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Ms Procrastinator said:
Click to expand...
259826
 
I don't think I like the insinuation in the write up that Mel knows how to control a ship that has killed lots of people...

but I don't know, it almost feels too easy? like the whole thing about me/paws/dolphin still being wolves after Stagg's conversion. Idk, discussion for today maybe
 
AM, I don't suppose you want to give me a target list, do you?

Edit to add: I'm curious about how some things fit together with a timeline and I know you don't enjoy that stuff as much
 
PippyPony said:
I'll be out of commission for most of today but as we're approaching end game, I think it would be great to hear from people who have been on the quieter side.

@mizchiefmanaged @PrincessButterCup @Melchizedek

It's no fun if it's just me & AM talking (I mean she is lovely to talk to, don't get me wrong, but I am interested in hearing from others too)
Click to expand...
What am I chopped liver?
 
PippyPony said:
I'll be out of commission for most of today but as we're approaching end game, I think it would be great to hear from people who have been on the quieter side.

@mizchiefmanaged @PrincessButterCup @Melchizedek

It's no fun if it's just me & AM talking (I mean she is lovely to talk to, don't get me wrong, but I am interested in hearing from others too)
Click to expand...
Sick as hell today. Will get on in a few hours, in the meantime I’m sleeping.
 
Coopah said:
@Melchizedek thoughts today?
Click to expand...
I have a list of people that I had cleared and a list of ???’s
But honestly at this point with so many affiliation changes and lynch avoidances and etc I am just either hoping to get killed or waiting til we get to 7 people and it becomes a basics game before I do more analysis. I’m much better at that.

That being said people on my soft clear list are:
Miz, Coopah, PBC,
Neutrals:
AM - I know she started village but her play has gotten wonky the longer the game has gone on.
Trilt - I want to put her village for the way she questioned me early, it felt like her pressuring me back in Pokémon (take with a grain of salt because I was high on morphine the majority of that game) but she’s also made some really ****ty pushes this game

????’s/who I’m considering for wolves:
Pippy - obvious reasons. And I’m mad that i let her pissy outrage talk me out of keeping my vote on her a couple days ago.
SOV - I’ve only played two other games with SOV but he doesn’t feel like the other games. He’s not as pedantic and looking to teach people how to play, just condescending.
 
Melchizedek said:
I have a list of people that I had cleared and a list of ???’s
But honestly at this point with so many affiliation changes and lynch avoidances and etc I am just either hoping to get killed or waiting til we get to 7 people and it becomes a basics game before I do more analysis. I’m much better at that.

That being said people on my soft clear list are:
Miz, Coopah, PBC,
Neutrals:
AM - I know she started village but her play has gotten wonky the longer the game has gone on.
Trilt - I want to put her village for the way she questioned me early, it felt like her pressuring me back in Pokémon (take with a grain of salt because I was high on morphine the majority of that game) but she’s also made some really ****ty pushes this game

????’s/who I’m considering for wolves:
Pippy - obvious reasons. And I’m mad that i let her pissy outrage talk me out of keeping my vote on her a couple days ago.
SOV - I’ve only played two other games with SOV but he doesn’t feel like the other games. He’s not as pedantic and looking to teach people how to play, just condescending.
Click to expand...
Interesting I have the same thoughts on SOV and AM. Hopefully today will shed some light.
 
Karabiner13 said:
D16 Official Lynch Tally

dolphin (5) - stagg, miz, coop, pbc, dubz
pippy (1) - mel
stagg (3) - pippy, MsP, paws
coop () -

9/14

Missing: dolphin, cubs, am, sov, trilt
Click to expand...
Animal Midwife said:
@Trilt Why didn't you vote yesterday?
Click to expand...
Why only asking me?

I have pushed the dolphin lynch for like, five days, and to get revenge exploded from it sounded suboptimal. I caught up about a half hour before close and just kept a close eye to make sure things continued there.
 
Trilt said:
Why only asking me?

I have pushed the dolphin lynch for like, five days, and to get revenge exploded from it sounded suboptimal. I caught up about a half hour before close and just kept a close eye to make sure things continued there.
Click to expand...
You're probably really busy and are responding right now or missed my post by accident, so friendly reminder: Now that paws and dolphin are dead, who are your wolf reads?
 
D17 unofficial zigjazz Lynch Tally

PBR (1) - Pip

1/9

in the lead = pbr
Missing: everyone but pip

Deadline 10pm est (~6.5 hours)


giphy.gif
 
Melchizedek said:
????’s/who I’m considering for wolves:
Pippy - obvious reasons. And I’m mad that i let her pissy outrage talk me out of keeping my vote on her a couple days ago.
SOV - I’ve only played two other games with SOV but he doesn’t feel like the other games. He’s not as pedantic and looking to teach people how to play, just condescending.
Click to expand...
Can you please articulate your "obvious reasons"? Because I don't know that I have actually seen any reasons from you except that "it's about time" to lynch me, and you will continue to get pissy outrage from me if that's all you've got.

Can you point me in the direction of where I have lied to you or anyone else, or played in a manner that is anything other than consistent with what I have told you about my progression arc?

Are SOV and I wolves together? Is there only one wolf left? Two wolves in a pack? Two lone wolves? Two wolves and a pocketed villager? Three wolves?
 
Last edited:
Trilt said:
Why only asking me?

I have pushed the dolphin lynch for like, five days, and to get revenge exploded from it sounded suboptimal. I caught up about a half hour before close and just kept a close eye to make sure things continued there.
Click to expand...
Ok, so you pushed a lynch on chaos for 5 days and then didn't want to die, so you let other people finish them off for you? Am I reading that correctly?
 
Okay, so I'm kinda stuck between miz, PBC, Trilt, and SOV. But the reason I'm appearing erratic is because things are coinciding with finals and my sleep schedule keeps oscillating.
 
Speaking of, I have an enormous final tomorrow.

If people want to lynch me, I suggest waiting until we get down to 7 players and it is possible to do so 🙂

Or like...even until tomorrow when I am officially done with neuro would be great lol.
 
Trilt said:
Why only asking me?

I have pushed the dolphin lynch for like, five days, and to get revenge exploded from it sounded suboptimal. I caught up about a half hour before close and just kept a close eye to make sure things continued there.
Click to expand...
Okay, but they mentioned anyone on or off the lynch could be blown up. So you were no safer by not lynching them. I just though you'd get on for the reason that you've been pushing them and it could've swung to Pippy or something. It turned out to be vengeful lover rather than a standard bomb role.
 
Melchizedek said:
I have a list of people that I had cleared and a list of ???’s
But honestly at this point with so many affiliation changes and lynch avoidances and etc I am just either hoping to get killed or waiting til we get to 7 people and it becomes a basics game before I do more analysis. I’m much better at that.

That being said people on my soft clear list are:
Miz, Coopah, PBC,
Neutrals:
AM - I know she started village but her play has gotten wonky the longer the game has gone on.
Trilt - I want to put her village for the way she questioned me early, it felt like her pressuring me back in Pokémon (take with a grain of salt because I was high on morphine the majority of that game) but she’s also made some really ****ty pushes this game

????’s/who I’m considering for wolves:
Pippy - obvious reasons. And I’m mad that i let her pissy outrage talk me out of keeping my vote on her a couple days ago.
SOV - I’ve only played two other games with SOV but he doesn’t feel like the other games. He’s not as pedantic and looking to teach people how to play, just condescending.
Click to expand...
How about MsP?
 
For what it's worth, I believe that Pip wouldn't die today. Something to consider.

A separate strategy point, if you feel that no other candidates are prominent and don't want what you believe other villagers to die "wasting a vote" is appropriate imo.
 
Has anyone had any status effects over the last few days? I'm trying to determine if the remaining antagonists/wolves are 'newer' wolves or if they've been around a while and are still 'contributing' like normal.

I'm going through each ISO one by one in between naps, so bare with me.

Trilt: has been SPOT on for the pippy-paws-dolphin pack since at least 4/16, so quite a bit before they were converted to chaos, I believe. Unless she's a SUPER recent convert, I extremely doubt that she's a member of that pack. I also know next to nothing about her role claim, unless I missed something somewhere. To my knowledge, pretty much all roles (that I've been able to figure out) have more or less been attached to certain players, barring the newer roles. If she is an antagonist I'd likely place her in the 'true antagonist' party. She's the first person I'd like to hear some more from.
 
mizchiefmanaged said:
@PippyPony were you one of the people confused about who my role is?
Click to expand...
Nope

I also think I know what you do (or did), in case that affects how you view me

That being said, I am not permanently clearing anyone based on role in this game, and I think you could imagine why I might have a scenario in my mind where you have the potential to turn to the dark side. Apple doesn't fall far from the tree, etc.
 
mizchiefmanaged said:
Has anyone had any status effects over the last few days? I'm trying to determine if the remaining antagonists/wolves are 'newer' wolves or if they've been around a while and are still 'contributing' like normal.

I'm going through each ISO one by one in between naps, so bare with me.

Trilt: has been SPOT on for the pippy-paws-dolphin pack since at least 4/16, so quite a bit before they were converted to chaos, I believe. Unless she's a SUPER recent convert, I extremely doubt that she's a member of that pack. I also know next to nothing about her role claim, unless I missed something somewhere. To my knowledge, pretty much all roles (that I've been able to figure out) have more or less been attached to certain players, barring the newer roles. If she is an antagonist I'd likely place her in the 'true antagonist' party. She's the first person I'd like to hear some more from.
Click to expand...
I am not a newer role btw. I've been in since the beginning. I'm not sure which roles, if any, are newer. I agree with this evaluation of Trilt, but I can't imagine her being an original.
 
Coopah said:
I am not a newer role btw. I've been in since the beginning. I'm not sure which roles, if any, are newer. I agree with this evaluation of Trilt, but I can't imagine her being an original.
Click to expand...
What is it about her that makes you think she wouldn’t be an original? I will say I’ve really enjoyed reading her posts logistics-wise and if she is a wolf I think she’s a damn good one.
 
Sorry..busy last 2 days. I am off tomorrow so can be here more if that helps. I have a bunch of thoughts so here goes...

Sadly my best idea coming into today was Lynch WZ. I just can’t understand why no one owned up to rezzing her. It is such a simple thing to remove confusion,but that is water under the bridge,

My other big idea was coopah, but haven’t followed up on that. I saw some quotes from the writeup but in my quick skim could make nothing of it.

My inclination now is to Lynch trilt. She is a good player as a wolf, and in a way, there is nothing at all wolfy about her, which seems odd. How can you not make villager mistakes over 2 weeks? I am just guessing she is being careful as a wolf.

Unfortunately I honestly don’t know how to find this last wolf. They were clearly not part of the other pack, so probably had no trouble looking villagery and lynching other wolves...and if they are late to wolfdom (which I doubt) would make it harder.

Now....if I make it through tonight I am not sure it matters anymore, so I am gonna talk a lot about my role here (without quoting and getting in trouble). My role name is irrelevant, it comes up with nothing on google, just some stupid story about a murdering guy in Africa, but the writeup the other day finally made some sense for me, I am an empty vessel. I have no affiliation “currently”. My role said specifically I am not neutral like some players, just I didn’t have an affiliation at start of game. I was supposed to take over certain roles if they got killed off too early. Never told which ones, except when Mel was temporarily lynched I was told to be ready to enter the game so I guess kavilan is one of them, now, I guess my role will remain unfulfilled, I believe as of tomorrow I will no longer have that opportunity so will remain unaffiliated, which kind of sucks, so if you leave me alive I will not count for villager numbers, but if you Lynch me you don’t gain much either. I obviously assumed I would be village all along so that was where my loyalty was. I am guessing if anyone investigated me they wouldn’t see much, I have not had a chat with anyone all game and have been a bit annoyed that everyone had someone to discuss the game with but me it seemed, I see msP just opened a chat with me for first time, but I wanted to get this out there.

Last thing, I know there are primary protagonists and primary antagonists from my role description, and that makes me think that the big baddie in this game has been there all along, but it is utter conjecture on my part.

Lynch me, don’t Lynch me. It really won’t affect the game, but I promise you, I am trying for a village win.
 
I wonder how long dead chat is. I don't think a game with this many pages has ever had one.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
72K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
60K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
86 87 88 89 90
Replies
4K
Views
52K
katiemcat
katiemcat
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
45K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
250
Views
17K
supershorty
supershorty
Top